UNITED STATES NEWS

AP NewsBreak: Judge laments man’s return to prison

May 17, 2013, 11:26 PM

BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) – A Montana judge said he fears he’s done a “soul-wrenching injustice” to a man he freed from prison after more than 27 years, only to see him ordered back behind bars by a higher court.

Retired state District Judge E. Wayne Phillips told The Associated Press Friday he was troubled he “got it wrong” when he granted a retrial for Barry Beach in the 1979 killing of Beach’s teenage classmate on the Fort Peck Indian Reservation.

That 2011 ruling gave Beach 525 days out of prison _ before the Montana Supreme Court said Phillips erred, sending Beach, 51, back to prison Wednesday for what could be the rest of his life.

In a 4-3 split opinion, the majority of justices said Phillips gave too much weight to testimony offered by new witnesses and failed to adequately consider forensic evidence that pointed to a single attacker in the death of Kim Nees, 17.

Phillips said in emailed comments that he takes some consolation in the fact that a three-justice minority supported his ruling. But he said the majority opinion weighed heavily on him, particularly given the consequences for Beach.

“I am troubled that I got it wrong. I am, however, much more deeply troubled _ from the heart outwards _ that I may have done a soul-wrenching injustice to Mr. Beach,” Phillips wrote. “By my error and giving him a taste of freedom based on that error, he now faces an almost unimaginable return from the freedom any right thinking person cherishes to the confines of a prison cell.”

Beach’s lawyers, family and other supporters have promised to continue working for his release, possibly through the federal court system. Their fight dates to his original conviction in 1984 for the death of Nees, after Beach offered a confession to Louisiana law enforcement that he later said was coerced.

That started a legal saga that has seen Beach go through nine different sets of attorneys, according to his mother, Bobbi Clincher.

“What do you have to do to prove his innocence when there isn’t anything to match him (to the crime) except a false confession?” she asked after he was taken back into custody. “DNA seems to be the only thing that can offer proof, and we don’t have DNA.”

Clincher said Friday she had spoken with her son by phone since he returned to the 1,500-inmate state prison in Deer Lodge. He asked Clincher to get in touch with his landlord and tell her to hold off on putting Beach’s belongings into storage.

Clincher said Beach has a feeling it won’t be long before he’s back out. “But we don’t know that, really,” she added.

In their decision this week, justices said they were not declaring that Beach was guilty or innocent, only that he had fallen short of the legal standards needed to obtain a new trial.

Montana Gov. Steve Bullock was attorney general when the state asked the Montana Supreme Court to reverse Phillips’ decision.

“I think the Supreme Court has now ruled, and we should respect that decision,” Bullock said Friday.

The dissenting justices said Phillips had properly considered both the new and old evidence in the case. They said Phillips “sits in a better position to observe witnesses and determine credibility” than the high court, and that there was no reason to overturn his conclusion that a retrial was in order.

Phillips, for his part, suggested he was reluctant to criticize the majority opinion, both out of deference and because he knows many members of the court and considers them conscientious.

(Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

United States News

Associated Press

Student anti-war protesters dig in as faculties condemn university leadership over calling police

NEW YORK (AP) — Students protesting the Israel-Hamas war at at universities across U.S., some of whom have clashed with police in riot gear, dug in Saturday and vowed to keep their demonstrations going, while several school faculties condemned university presidents who have called in law enforcement to remove protesters. As Columbia University continues negotiations […]

7 hours ago

Associated Press

Tornadoes collapse buildings and level homes in Nebraska and Iowa

OMAHA, Neb. (AP) — Tornadoes wreaked havoc Friday in the Midwest, causing a building to collapse with dozens of people inside and destroying and damaging hundreds of homes, many around Omaha, Nebraska. As of Friday night, there were several reports of injuries but no immediate deaths reported. Tornado warnings continued to be issued into the […]

9 hours ago

A freight train derailed near the Arizona-New Mexico border, causing an Interstate 40 closure. (scr...

Associated Press

Freight train derailment, fire forces Interstate 40 closure near Arizona-New Mexico line

A freight train carrying fuel derailed and caught fire near the Arizona-New Mexico state line, forcing the closure of an interstate highway.

10 hours ago

Donald Trump's defense team tries to discredit testimony in trial...

Associated Press

Trump’s lawyers try to discredit testimony of prosecution’s first witness in hush money trial

Donald Trump's defense team sought to discredit detailing an alleged hush money scheme that impacted his 2016 presidential campaign.

11 hours ago

Biden vs. Trump debate could be on the horizon, both men say...

Associated Press

Donald Trump and Joe Biden say they’re ready to debate each other ahead of general election

President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump are discussing a debate. But how would the Biden vs. Trump debate happen?

12 hours ago

Associated Press

Retired pro wrestler, failed congressional candidate indicted in Vegas murder case

LAS VEGAS (AP) — A retired professional wrestler and former congressional candidate in Nevada and Texas has been indicted on a murder charge in the death of an Idaho man who suffered a head injury during a Halloween Party at a Las Vegas Strip hotel. Daniel Rodimer, 45, who now lives in Texas, is expected […]

13 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...

Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Day & Night is looking for the oldest AC in the Valley

Does your air conditioner make weird noises or a burning smell when it starts? If so, you may be due for an AC unit replacement.

...

Fiesta Bowl Foundation

The 51st annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade is excitingly upon us

The 51st annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade presented by Lerner & Rowe is upon us! The attraction honors Arizona and the history of the game.

(KTAR News Graphic)...

Boys & Girls Clubs

KTAR launches online holiday auction benefitting Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley

KTAR is teaming up with The Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley for a holiday auction benefitting thousands of Valley kids.

AP NewsBreak: Judge laments man’s return to prison