ADVERTISEMENT

ARIZONA ELECTION NEWS

8 noncitizens who voted in Maricopa County will not face charges, top prosecutor says

"It's my feeling that a jury would not convict these eight individuals because of the involvement of a government-involved glitch," County Attorney Rachel Mitchell said.

Watch: Rachel Mitchell confirms 8 noncitizens found on Maricopa County voter rolls | 1 min

Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell said Wednesday that eight noncitizens who cast ballots after they were erroneously registered to vote will not be prosecuted.

“We will not be filing charges in those cases,” Mitchell said during a news conference.

The Maricopa County Attorney’s Office investigation into potentially illegal voting stems primarily from a glitch in the state Motor Vehicle Division registration system that dates back to 2004 and was discovered in 2024.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Maricopa County Recorder’s Office ran more than 60,000 registered voters who were affected by the error through the federal SAVE database in an attempt to identify noncitizens. The SAVE database flagged 207 names that Recorder Justin Heap referred to the county attorney in March.

Investigators with Mitchell’s office confirmed that 60 of those people actually voted at least once, so they limited their investigation into citizenship to that group. In September, Mitchell announced that 52 of the 60 were confirmed as U.S. citizens.

What was the party affiliation of the Maricopa County noncitizens who voted?

Of the eight noncitizens who voted, all were in the country legally. Two were registered as Republicans, one as a Democrat, and five had no party affiliation.

They cast ballots a combined total of 16 times from 2012 to 2025, not enough to change the outcome of any race. No more than three of the noncitizens voted in any single election.

Mitchell said the state registration system error was responsible for seven of the eight cases.

“And in talking to individuals, they thought, ‘Well, if I’m being sent a ballot, I guess it’s OK for me to vote,’” she said Wednesday.

The eighth person filled out a registration form and checked the box saying he was not a citizen but still received a ballot.

“And so based on that, it’s my feeling that a jury would not convict these eight individuals because of the involvement of a government-involved glitch, if you will,” Mitchell said.

Subscribe to the KTAR Political Brief newsletter to get our top political stories, exclusive guest interviews and more to your email inbox.

Kevin Stone KTAR.com Senior Editor

Kevin Stone is KTAR's Senior Web Content Editor. He is a seasoned journalist who was born in New York and grew up in Phoenix. He got his start doing agate for the Mesa Tribune sports section in the 1990s while completing his print journalism degree.… Read more

Comments

0 Comments