ADVERTISEMENT

ARIZONA ELECTION NEWS

‘We got our teeth kicked in’: Arizona Republicans agree they were routed, not on why

Some Republican leaders blame party infighting. Others say voters rejected the candidates, not conservative ideas.

Watch: Is there any fixing the Republican Party? | 13 mins

Jon Seaton has spent a career helping Republican candidates put the best face on things.

On Wednesday, he didn’t bother.

“We got our teeth kicked in, like let’s call it what it is,” he said.

Democrats swept every statewide race this month, and Republicans lost control of the Legislature for the first time in 60 years.

Seaton, a former adviser to the late Sen. John McCain, was one of several Republicans who spent the morning on KTAR News 92.3 FM’s The Mike Broomhead Show trying to make sense of the rout.

ADVERTISEMENT

None of them disputed how bad it was. They just couldn’t agree on why.

‘Given up by our own party’

Arizona Republican Party Chairman Sergio Arellano took over in January promising to end the party’s habit of tearing into its own candidates. Ten months later, he said that habit cost the GOP the election.

“All the ammunition that the Democrats used against us this cycle was given up by our own party,” he said.

Arellano said the Democratic ads he saw recycled attacks Republicans had made on each other.

“All I saw in the ads that were coming to me were the same talking points that we murdered each other with in the primary,” he said.

Former Gov. Jan Brewer said personal fights inside the party now escalate quickly.

“So then you gather your gang, and they gather their gang, and pretty soon we have World War III going on in our Republican Party,” Brewer said.

She said some GOP voters her age sat out the election or crossed over.

“Unfortunately, the Republicans were so burned out and so tired of it they didn’t come out to vote,” she said. “They wanted to punish our actions. They voted Democrat.”

Brewer also blamed groups outside the party structure.

“I think that there’s too many outside, outlying organizations participating in our party politics. And it’s because they make money off of it,” she said.

GOP strategist Lorna Romero, a former legislative director for Brewer, said the party’s message came from Washington.

“It’s whatever the Trump administration says, and then it trickles down here locally,” she said.

Republican ideas in a ‘center-right state’

Josh Kredit, chief of staff to state Senate President Warren Petersen’s GOP majority, argued that voters rejected the party’s candidates, not its ideas.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I would say emphatically, yes, we are a center-right state,” Kredit said, defending the party’s candidates. “I actually think we did a really good job with candidate quality.”

Instead, he blamed a wave that he said no GOP campaign could have held back.

“This was an overwhelming blue tsunami that very few Republicans could avoid,” Kredit said.

Kredit said Democrats won partly by borrowing Republican themes. He said Republicans pushed through tax cuts and border security funding, and Gov. Katie Hobbs then campaigned on both.

“If you … close your eyes and listen to her commercials, she sounded like a Republican,” he said of Hobbs.

As further proof, Kredit pointed to the conservative ballot measures voters approved even as they rejected Republican candidates.

“Our policies do resonate,” he said.

The ballot results support that argument only in part.

ADVERTISEMENT

Voters approved a ban on transgender girls in girls’ sports, designated drug cartels as terrorist organizations and limited grocery taxes.

But they rejected a voter ID requirement and limits on diversity, equity and inclusion programs.

That mixed verdict leaves Republicans without a clear read on what voters want from them.

For Seaton, that’s the place to start rebuilding.

“What is Republican foreign policy in 2027, 2028? What do we believe domestically? What are we about?” he said. “And then let the voters decide.”

Subscribe to the KTAR Political Brief newsletter to get our top political stories, exclusive guest interviews and more to your email inbox.

David Iversen is a Phoenix-based journalist and digital content editor. He has covered local politics, national investigations and everything in between for FOX, The New York Times, Business Insider and other outlets. His work includes DuPont-winning… Read more

Comments

0 Comments