New lawsuit argues Arizona ban on mask mandates was passed illegally

Aug 13, 2021, 2:47 PM | Updated: 6:25 pm

(Getty Images File Photo)...

(Getty Images File Photo)

(Getty Images File Photo)

PHOENIX — A lawsuit filed Thursday argues that Arizona’s ban on face mask mandates in public schools should be invalidated because lawmakers violated the state constitution while passing it.

“Article IV, part 2, section 13 of the Arizona Constitution places two important limitations on laws passed the Legislature: (1) the laws can cover only one subject, and (2) their contents must be properly noticed in the title of the bill,” says the complaint filed in Maricopa County Superior Court by a coalition of educators, child advocates, doctors and concerned citizens.

“This legislative session, the Legislature passed several so-called ‘budget reconciliation bills’ that violate these constitutional mandates.”

Roopali Desai, an attorney for the plaintiffs, told KTAR News 92.3 FM on Friday the lawsuit is challenging the prohibition of mask mandates in K-12 schools and several other laws passed as provisions in the state budget in June.

“When the Legislature passes substantive laws, they cannot logroll into one bill unrelated subjects,” she said. “The same constitutional requirement also says that the Legislature has to give citizens fair notice of what’s contained in the laws that they are enacting by using a title, and that title has to adequately describe the substantive law changes that they’re making.”

Desai said those requirements “are intended to make sure that the people of Arizona know what their lawmakers are up to, have an opportunity to weigh in and participate in the process and to not have a situation like we had this past legislative session where legislators are just rolling together all of these pet projects and provisions that they want but without going through the full legislative process.”

Maricopa County Supervisor Steve Gallardo, who is part of the lawsuit as a citizen, not in his official role, said the ban on mask mandates is overreach of power that should remain in the hands of school boards.

“There’s a reason why our constituents elect school board members, city councilors and county supervisors, and not just state lawmakers and a governor,” he said in a statement. “This lawsuit is about reining in laws that go too far and restoring the power of communities to make their own decisions.”

The bill that includes the ban doesn’t go into effect until Sept. 29, but it contains a clause to make the mask provision retroactive to June 30.

However, there is an ongoing dispute over whether the retroactivity clause is enforceable after multiple districts required students and staff to wear face coverings on campus.

A Metro Tech biology teacher sued the Phoenix Union High School District over its mandate, and both sides argued their positions in court Friday. The district maintained the law doesn’t go into effect until Sept. 29.

Desai agrees with the district, saying new laws can’t go into effect until 90 days after the legislative session ends.

“We want the court to hear our case and to rule that these laws are unconstitutional prior to the effective date of the law so that they don’t go into effect at the end of September,” she said.

KTAR News 92.3 FM’s Griselda Zetino contributed to this report.

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

An image from Google Street View shows the third-party post office between a Jimmy John's and a Dun...

Southeast Valley shopping center evacuated while authorities investigate bomb threat

Multiple businesses at a southeast Valley shopping center were evacuated Monday because of a bomb threat, authorities said.

6 minutes ago

A DUI suspect drove down a 200-foot embankment in Cottonwood before a second DUI suspect was arrest...

Arizona DUI suspect’s car careens down 200-foot embankment before 2nd DUI suspect arrested

A DUI suspect drove down a 200-foot embankment in Arizona on Saturday morning before another DUI suspect attempted to evade police at the crash area, authorities said.

39 minutes ago

Split panel image of the front of an Albertsons grocery store on the left and a Kroger plastic bag ...

Kevin Stone

Arizona joins federal lawsuit to block merger of grocery giants Kroger and Albertsons

Arizona is part of a federal lawsuit filed Monday to block the controversial merger of Kroger and Albertsons, two of the nation’s largest grocers.

2 hours ago

The eastbound Loop 202 South Mountain freeway was closed in Phoenix on Feb. 26, 2024, for a fatal c...

Eastbound Loop 202 South Mountain Freeway closed in Phoenix for fatal wrong-way crash

The eastbound Loop 202 South Mountain freeway was closed in Phoenix on Monday for a fatal wrong-way crash, authorities said.

2 hours ago

Mugshot of Jill Houchens, who was arrested Feb. 19, 2024, on 146 counts of animal abuse and neglect...

Arizona woman arrested on nearly 150 animal abuse and neglect charges

An Arizona woman faces nearly 150 charges after more than 20 animals, including five that were dead, were removed from her property earlier this month, authorities said.

4 hours ago

Sun at high noon over a prison....

SuElen Rivera

Man sentenced to over 5 years for coordinating drug smuggling into Arizona

A man was sentenced last week to over five years in prison for his role in coordinating drug smuggling into Arizona, authorities said.

5 hours ago

Sponsored Articles


Midwestern University

Midwestern University Clinics: transforming health care in the valley

Midwestern University, long a fixture of comprehensive health care education in the West Valley, is also a recognized leader in community health care.

(KTAR News Graphic)...

Boys & Girls Clubs

KTAR launches online holiday auction benefitting Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley

KTAR is teaming up with The Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley for a holiday auction benefitting thousands of Valley kids.


Sanderson Ford

The best ways to honor our heroes on Veterans Day and give back to the community

Veterans Day is fast approaching and there's no better way to support our veterans than to donate to the Military Assistance Mission.

New lawsuit argues Arizona ban on mask mandates was passed illegally