Talking ICE: The uneasy relationship between Arizona officials, immigrants

Jun 27, 2017, 4:33 AM | Updated: Jun 29, 2017, 9:18 am

Editor’s note: In this multipart series, KTAR News’ Martha Maurer will take an in-depth look at the multifaceted and complex issue of undocumented immigrants in America under the administration of President Donald Trump.

Part one explores the uncertain relationship between those immigrants and immigration officials after Trump’s executive order that made all undocumented people a deportation priority.

Read part one, part two and part three.

Trump changes the status quo

Following Trump’s executive actions on immigration shortly after his January inauguration, several cases of Arizona immigrants who were deported during an ICE check-in garnered national attention.

The February deportation of Guadalupe Garcia de Rayos was the first of three to grab America’s attention. Her case was followed weeks later by that of Juan Carlos Fomperosa Garcia, who was ordered out of the country. In May, Marco Tulio Coss was removed from the United States.

All three immigrants were undocumented and all had orders of removal issued by an immigration judge. But their removal during a scheduled meeting with ICE is what caught the eyes and ears of Americans because, in the past, those with no criminal record or those who committed minor crimes were typically allowed to stay in the country.

“If you’re checking in, that means you’ve already been identified by ICE, that you are in the country without authorization,” Enrique Lucero, field office director for ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations in Phoenix, explained.

Lucero said most people who are ordered to check in with his agency have run out of legal options to stay in the country.

“There has to be some closure into a case,” he said.

Some of those who have orders to leave may have not committed a crime in the U.S., but Lucero said being in the country is a crime in itself.

“Anyone that ICE is removing, people should know they’ve committed a criminal act,” he said.

Both Garcia de Rayos and Fomperosa Garcia had a criminal record.

Tulio Coss did not have criminal past, but was pulled over for speeding in 2009 when officials discovered he was in the country illegally. He exhausted his appeals in 2013 and an order of removal was issued.

Instead of being removed, he was ordered to check in regularly with ICE. That held until this past May, when he was deported.

“There is no class that is exempt … from being removed,” Lucero said.

What changed?

In years past, Valley immigration attorney Margarita Silva felt confident she could tell her clients — especially those without criminal record — they would likely be safe from deportation for a few more months after they met with ICE.

“I’m not confident saying that now,” she said.

Since Trump’s order, Silva has told her clients they need to be prepared in case their next check-in ends with a permanent trip outside of the United States.

“This can happen at any time,” she said. “If you get detained today, who’s going to have power of attorney over your kids? We’re just trying to warn people ahead of time.”

Lucero said undocumented immigrants should not be surprised if they are removed from the country — criminal record or not.

Silva, on the other hand, believed ICE officers still have an option to not execute a removal order. Those officers cannot change the order, but they could opt to delay it.

“I think what we’re seeing is they are not exercising that discretion anymore,“ Silva said.

More headlines, fewer deportations

Data from Lucero’s office showed that, between Jan. 20 and April 29, ICE removed 5,308 undocumented immigrants.

More than 3,200 were convicted criminals.

In 2009, nearly 22,000 undocumented immigrants were deported in the same time frame. That figure began to decline in the following years.

In 2013, the number had dropped by nearly half to about 11,000.

In 2014, the number fell again to 7,000.

Last year, about 6,000 immigrants were removed from the country between Jan. 20 and April 29.

However, ICE has reported a nearly 15 percent increase in Phoenix-area arrests when compared to this time last year.

Why not skip the check-in?

Immigrants who miss their ICE appointments are considered fugitives and their cases are sent to a specialized team. Depending on the circumstances of the case, agents may prioritize the arrest of certain immigrants over others.

“You’re subject to being targeted by a team that could be knocking on your door, doors of (the homes of) people that we think you may be at, or conducting surveillance, looking for you,” Lucero said.

Lucero said it is in immigrants’ best interests to check in. If they do, they can protect family members and friends who may also be in the country illegally.

Silva has yet to have a client who refuses to check in with ICE.

“These people don’t want to risk their families,” she said.

Read part onepart two and part three.

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Editors’ Picks

(AP Photo)...

Corbin Carson

The rocky history of Martin Luther King Jr. Day in Arizona

Some of us will not be working on Monday as it is Martin Luther King Jr. Day, but the holiday was not always recognized in Arizona.

5 years ago



More than 20 years later, mystery of Phoenix Lights still fascinates people

Wednesday marks the 22nd anniversary of one of the strangest things to ever happen in Arizona, the Phoenix Lights phenomenon.

5 years ago

(Facebook Photo)...


Salud! Mark National Margarita Day at these Phoenix-area spots

Get ready for the excuse you needed on a Friday: It's National Margarita Day! Here are some great Phoenix-area spots to grab a drink with tequila.

5 years ago

(Facebook Photo)...


Here are 5 Phoenix spots to find pancakes on National Pancake Day

We thought we would put together a list to give you some of the top flapjack places in Phoenix to eat at on National Pancake Day.

6 years ago

(AP Photo)...


Before he was a senator, John McCain was a war hero and POW

Before U.S. Sen. John McCain went into politics, he was a young man flying fighter planes over Vietnam, where he was shot down and kept as a POW.

6 years ago

(AP Photo)...


Arizona Sen. John McCain has died of brain cancer at the age of 81

John McCain, a senator and veteran known as "The Maverick," passed away in Arizona at the age of 81 on Saturday evening.

6 years ago

Sponsored Articles


Sanderson Ford

3 storylines to get you revved up for the 2024 Arizona Cardinals

Arizona Cardinals training camp is just a couple weeks away starting on July 25, and Sanderson Ford is revved up and ready to go.


Condor Airlines

Condor Airlines can get you smoothly from Phoenix to Frankfurt on new A330-900neo airplane

Adventure Awaits! And there's no better way to experience the vacation of your dreams than traveling with Condor Airlines.


DISC Desert Institute for Spine Care

Sciatica pain is treatable but surgery may be required

Sciatica pain is one of the most common ailments a person can face, and if not taken seriously, it could become one of the most harmful.

Talking ICE: The uneasy relationship between Arizona officials, immigrants