ARIZONA NEWS

Arizona Supreme Court OKs disputed DNA evidence in 2015 Scottsdale murder case

Dec 17, 2024, 12:43 PM

Scottsdale murder case suspect Ian Mitcham...

Prosecutors can introduce disputed DNA evidence against Ian Mitcham in his Scottsdale murder case, the Arizona Supreme Court ruled. (Scottsdale Police Department File Photo)

(Scottsdale Police Department File Photo)

PHOENIX – The Arizona Supreme Court issued a ruling Tuesday that clears the way for disputed DNA evidence to be introduced in a 2015 Scottsdale murder case.

While the high court concurred that defendant Ian Mitcham’s Fourth Amendment protections against unreasonable search and seizure were, indeed, violated, it overturned a lower court decision to suppress DNA evidence.

That’s because the Supreme Court unanimously determined that the “inevitable discovery” exception was applicable in the case. Inevitable discovery is cited when evidence originally collected without a proper warrant is ruled admissible because its discovery by legal means was inevitable.

Mitcham was arrested in April 2018 for allegedly killing Allison Feldman in Scottsdale over three years earlier.

Feldman, 31, was found dead in her home near the Loop 101 and Pima Road in February 2015. Court documents said she died of asphyxiation with blunt force trauma.

What led up to Tuesday’s ruling in Scottsdale murder case?

According to the Arizona Supreme Court opinion, which was written by Chief Justice Ann Scott Timmer, police initiated a familial DNA investigation in 2017 using evidence found at the scene. That process identified Mitcham’s incarcerated brother as somebody closely related to the suspected killer.

Investigators then discovered the existence of a blood sample taken from Mitcham after a January 2015 arrest for DUI.

Without acquiring a warrant to do so, police used the sample to create a DNA profile and found in April 2018 that it matched DNA found at the scene of the Scottsdale murder case.

A week later, a grand jury indicted Mitcham for first-degree murder, sexual assault and second-degree burglary related to Feldman’s death.

In 2022, Mitcham pleaded guilty on two felony counts in the DUI case.

The same year, his murder case defense team moved to suppress the warrantless DNA evidence as well as swab evidence collected when he was arrested in 2018.

The trial court agreed that Mitcham’s Fourth Amendment protections were violated and ruled the DNA evidence inadmissible, but that wasn’t the final word on the matter.

The Arizona Supreme Court determined that the Fourth Amendment violation wasn’t a reason to suppress the evidence because Mitcham’s DNA profile would have been created after his 2022 felony convictions.

“This is certain, not speculative, so it easily satisfies the preponderance standard” for the inevitable discovery exception, Tuesday’s ruling states.

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

Scottsdale Airport...

Danny Shapiro

Scottsdale Airport runway shut down following accident

The Scottsdale Airport runway was shut down on Monday afternoon due to an accident, authorities said.

1 hour ago

new Surprise fire department West Valley Arizona...

Serena O'Sullivan

Surprise completes 1 new fire station, buys land for another

Surprise Fire Station 309, the new Surprise fire department at the north side of Cactus Road at Perryville Road, became operational last week.

2 hours ago

Republican state Rep. Matt Gress is questioning the legality of the lease-purchase deal that bailed...

Kevin Stone

Arizona lawmaker raises questions about legality of Isaac School District lease-purchase deal

An Arizona lawmaker is questioning the legality of the lease-purchase deal that bailed the Isaac School District out of its financial crisis last month.

3 hours ago

research funding...

Kevin Stone

Arizona joins lawsuit to stop Trump research funding cuts that could cost state millions

Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes joined a multistate lawsuit against the Trump administration to protect medical and public health research funding.

4 hours ago

The Arizona Constitution currently provides legislative immunity for traffic violations....

Kevin Stone

Arizona Republican wants lawmakers to follow same traffic laws as everyone else

An Arizona lawmaker introduced a resolution that would refer a constitutional amendment ending legislative immunity for traffic violations to the ballot.

6 hours ago

Officials: WM Phoenix Open 2025 more peaceful than last year...

Serena O'Sullivan

This year’s WM Phoenix Open upgrades made event smoother, more respectful, organizers say

Event organizers put in place a variety of changes during the WM Phoenix Open 2025 after weather conditions and crowd issues last year.

7 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...

Asset Preservation Wealth & Tax

How to optimize the most money in 2024 tax returns

As tax season begins, getting your financials in order is important to maximize your tax return.

...

Fiesta Bowl Foundation

Join us for the 52nd annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade

The 52nd annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade presented by Lerner & Rowe returns on Saturday, December 28, at 10 a.m.

...

Bright Wealth Management

How to save money on retirement planning following 2024 election

PHOENIX -- With the 2024 election over, economic changes could impact how people plan for retirement as 2025 is on the horizon.

Arizona Supreme Court OKs disputed DNA evidence in 2015 Scottsdale murder case