Your smart assistant is listening, but does that impact the ads you see?
Nov 24, 2023, 5:00 AM
Think of everything you do online — and in real life, too — that says something about who you are. Your likes, clicks, hobbies and activities all add to the wealth of data points companies already have on you.
What about your conversations with Alexa or Siri? How is that data used? Let’s take a deep look at how they use your conversations to create profiles.
I write about the latest tech gear, security alerts and digital life hacks in my daily emails. Join 600K+ who get the Current each day. It’s free!
Sizing you up
Consumer Reports and researchers at Boston’s Northeastern University created fake persons to interact with Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant and Apple’s Siri. This is data we all need to pay attention to.
They purposely asked the assistants questions designed to give away key user information. Think of asking about apartments near Boston. That checks a box that the user is a renter, not a homeowner.
How accurate were the profiles?
Google was hit or miss, like when it tagged users who asked about Disney tickets for a family as “single.” Not very helpful, but it says something nice about your privacy.
Amazon creates profiles based on shopping habits, not necessarily what you say to Alexa. Unless you’re gabbing with her specifically about shopping, you can chat away without Alexa adding the info to its marketing data. That’s nice to know.
Siri is the least gossipy of all the assistants. Requests to Siri aren’t tied to your Apple ID or used to build a marketing profile. Apple does have an ad network, but it creates a profile on you from non-voice data (like everything you’ve told the company and what you do inside apps or on the web) to target ads.
Why does all this matter?
When researchers used a married homeowner persona to ask Google for restaurant recommendations, it suggested Eddie V’s Prime Seafood, a high-end chain. When the same question was asked under a single persona, it offered a more affordable place. (If you’re single and want higher-end options, ask Google questions about Gucci loafers and Range Rovers.)
Unlike Google, Alexa didn’t change answers to basic questions based on tags and categories. Amazon does use interactions to serve ads, though. For example, asking Alexa for recipe ideas might get you a targeted ad for pots and pans.
The clear winner for privacy lovers is Siri. Apple doesn’t use Siri interactions to build profiles or change answers.
Your to-do voice privacy checkup
Based on what you’ve told Google Assistant and your other activity, Google makes it easy to see what it knows about you.
- Sign in to the My Ad Center page.
- Click on Manage Privacy on the left-hand side and scroll down to Categories used to show you ads.
- You’ll see how Google categorizes you with the option to change anything you don’t like or don’t want your ads based on.
With Amazon, it’s a little trickier. You need to submit a request and it could take days for Amazon to email you the information, so don’t hold your breath.
- Log in on a computer, hover your cursor over Account & Lists and tap Account.
- Scroll down to the Data and Privacy section and click Request Your Information.
- Select Alexa and Echo Devices from the drop-down menu and tap Submit Request.
Use an iPhone or Mac? Your profile isn’t based on Siri interactions. That doesn’t mean you don’t pass along a ton of other information.
- You can download any other data Apple collects from the Data and Privacy portal.
Keep your tech-know going
My popular podcast is called “Kim Komando Today.” It’s a solid 30 minutes of tech news, tips, and callers with tech questions like you from all over the country. Search for it wherever you get your podcasts. For your convenience, hit the link below for a recent episode.
Plus, I’m talking to Professor Scott Galloway about his views that Gen Z should be educated on mating dynamics — especially with sexbots on the rise. I’ll also show you how to spot phony retail sites, introduce a woman who turns her dating app matches into music, and tell you all about ChatGPT Plus’s new file analysis tool.
Listen to the podcast here or wherever you get your podcasts. Just search for my last name, “Komando.”
Sound like a tech pro, even if you’re not! Award-winning popular host Kim Komando is your secret weapon. Listen on 425+ radio stations or get the podcast. And join over 400,000 people who get her free 5-minute daily email newsletter.