Dave Ramsey says: Take the bigger check, it’s quick and easy

Sep 12, 2023, 1:00 PM

windshield broke...

(Getty Images Photo)

(Getty Images Photo)

Dear Dave,

My car was declared totaled because of hail damage, and my insurance company says I have two options. One is to take a higher total loss settlement check of $19,000 and use it toward the purchase of another car. The insurance company would then take possession of the car. The other option is to accept a check for $13,000 and have the car on a salvage title. The car is worth $15,000, and I have 20% car replacement assistance on my policy that increases the total loss settlement to the $19,000 amount I mentioned earlier. I’m on Baby Step 3 of your plan, and I owe nothing on the car. What should I do?

— Meagan

Dear Meagan,

Take the bigger check! That’s a quick and easy decision, but give me a minute to explain why. It’s not about being greedy—it’s a little more complicated than that.

If you had $19,000 in your pocket, would you go buy a $6,000 hail-damaged, salvage-title vehicle for everyday driving? Of course, you wouldn’t do that! The insurance company is probably hoping you’ll overlook the $19,000 offer and essentially pay $6,000 for this beat-up car. No. Thank. You. I’ll pass on that deal.

With $19,000, you’ll have plenty of cash to rent a car for a couple of weeks and take time to find a great-quality used car at a good price. You might even be able to negotiate with the insurance company to give you a little time to look for another ride before they come pick up the old one.

But no, you don’t want that messed up, old car. Why would you? That thing probably looks like a kid with a bad case of acne right now. Go find yourself a nice car, hon. There are plenty of affordable, slightly used vehicles on the market right now. There’s no reason for you to drive around in something that’s all beat up if you don’t have to.

Best of luck, Meagan!

— Dave


Dave Ramsey

scissors cutting credit card...

Dave Ramsey

Dave Ramsey says: Be gentle, he’s moving in the right direction

This week, Dave Ramsey discusses what best to do when one spouse is ready to get rid of the credit cards, but the other isn't.

2 days ago

woman with her head resting on what appears to be textbooks at a table...

Dave Ramsey

Dave Ramsey says: To pay off the student loan debt as soon as possible or hold off?

For some, the decision to pay off the remaining balance of student loan debt by dipping into savings could benefit them.

6 days ago

rings on a pillow...

Dave Ramsey

Dave Ramsey says: Go into debt for a wedding? Nope!

If you have to go into debt to make a wedding happen, you’re spending way too much, so Dave Ramsey offers some advice.

16 days ago

bag under tree with gifts...

Rachel Cruze

Dave Ramsey says: Here are tips on practicing contentment this holiday season

Here are five tips for keeping your expectations realistic and your spending in check throughout the holidays this year.

20 days ago

woman moving boxes...

Dave Ramsey

Dave Ramsey says: Risk is real when asking for outside help on a mortgage

Asking for outside help to pay off a mortgage may seem like a good idea at first, but Dave Ramsey explains why the risk is too big.

27 days ago

Dave Ramsey says it isn't smart to buy a home with your partner before marriage...

Dave Ramsey

Dave Ramsey says: Don’t buy a house together before you’re married

Never buy a home with someone that isn't your spouse. Dave Ramsey explains the pros and cons of the scenario.

1 month ago

Sponsored Articles


Dierdre Woodruff

Interest rates may have peaked. Should you buy a CD, high-yield savings account, or a fixed annuity?

Interest rates are the highest they’ve been in decades, and it looks like the Fed has paused hikes. This may be the best time to lock in rates for long-term, low-risk financial products like fixed annuities.


Midwestern University

Midwestern University: innovating Arizona health care education

Midwestern University’s Glendale Campus near Loop 101 and 59th Avenue is an established leader in health care education and one of Arizona’s largest and most valuable health care resources.



Key dates for Arizona sports fans to look forward to this fall

Fall brings new beginnings in different ways for Arizona’s professional sports teams like the Cardinals and Coyotes.

Dave Ramsey says: Take the bigger check, it’s quick and easy