How to repair drywall to make it look new again

Apr 7, 2022, 3:00 PM | Updated: Apr 8, 2022, 2:10 pm

(Shutterstock Photo)...

(Shutterstock Photo)

(Shutterstock Photo)

Other than dings with the vacuum, moving things around, or mounting art and fixtures, drywall damage will occur. Water damage, stress cracks, and settling also cause drywall damage.

Stress cracks are caused by the movement of the structure. These cracks are characterized by several things; they grow longer and wider over time, they are wider than a pencil lead, and they emanate most often off the corners of doors and windows.

These cracks ought not to be repaired until a foundation repair specialist does a complete analysis. It will do no good to repair the cracks if the house is still moving.

Repairing drywall

The age and condition of the paint on your wall and stored paint from when it was applied are really the key factors in how quickly you will finish drywall repair projects. But it’s the quality of the patchwork that is critical to restoring drywall walls to look like new.

The paint will only look as good as the surface it’s applied to. A poor patch with a poor texture match will stand out more than you’d expect, even the best paint coating won’t cover a poorly matched repair.

Nail holes in a wall where a picture used to hang can be filled with spackling paste, let it dry and sand down before repainting. For really small holes, caulk can be used — just make sure it’s a paintable caulk. The college dorm trick of using toothpaste won’t be covered here.

For dents or holes larger than a quarter, drywall texture and drywall tape or mesh will be required to complete the project. Anything over a 2-inch square will require a scrap drywall piece to cut a filler piece along with the following tools:

Tool list:
Utility knife or drywall saw. Having both can come in handy, but you won’t need both if you only own or have access to one.
• 12-inch straight edge
• A level
• Drywall knives (4-inch knife, pictured, best used for small touchups)

“I generally start out with knives ranging from 6 to 12 inches and sometimes use 1-4-inch knives for very small/difficult areas that other knives won’t reach. You can’t coat around a patch with a 4-inch knife. It’s not wide enough to do anything,” says Rick Thompson, Thompson’s Drywall Services, LLC, a Rosie-Certified Partner.

• Coarse sponge or sandpaper


• Acrylic caulk if the patch is matched up to another material/surface such as a countertop, shower, tile finish, etc.
• Drywall pan if a large amount of mud will be required.
• Texture spray for orange peel finishes.
• Mesh tape
• Fast-drying joint compound (hot mud).

“Quick set mud can be tricky. I wouldn’t recommend it for your first drywall repair, it can be a bit unforgiving,” says Thompson.

Regular patch with backing

For a regular patch without backing, you will need to place a piece of wood that is a bit bigger than the hole behind it so you have something to screw into.

For a doorknob size hole, simply cut a 4-inch long piece of 1×2, insert it into the hole, and while holding it tight to the backside of the drywall, set one screw through the drywall on either side of the hole. Now you have the backer piece in to screw the drywall patch to.

In a real bind, you can use thick paint stir sticks. This backing trick of the trade saves you from having to cut a hole all the way to studs.

In the case there is no room to mount a backer piece, drywallers use a trick called tear patching, but this technique is not for the beginner drywaller.

Water-damaged drywall

Water-damaged drywall can be identified in a few different ways. You may notice ripples or blisters in the paint on ceilings and walls. If the blisters don’t feel solid or if the paint starts flaking off as soon as you touch it, you likely have a water issue.

You may even find water in the paint blisters which makes your investigation easy! Other common signs are the drywall is soft to the touch and water stains/discoloration appear. Before repairing the drywall, identify and fix the source of the water intrusion.

If water is getting into the wall from rain, a sprinkler that’s too close to your house, or there’s a plumbing leak, you will probably see patches of damage on your walls near the spot of the intrusion. That’s because drywall has a paper backing, so when it gets wet, it can bubble and wrinkle, sort of like a sheet of paper does.

To diagnose ceiling leak damage, place a four-foot level across the damaged area. If the sheetrock has sagged more than 3/8 of an inch, the structural integrity of the drywall is probably ruined, and the whole section should be replaced.
If there is no sagging, use an awl to randomly push into the sheetrock. You should feel substantial resistance, and the awl shouldn’t be able to penetrate the sheetrock any more than 1/8 of an inch without excessive force. However, if the awl goes through the sheetrock much deeper than 3/16 of an inch, consider replacing the section.

Repairs to areas of major water damage are best left to the pros. There could be mold, and that is best left to a professional mold remediation expert.

How to replace a section of drywall

Use a utility knife to cut out the damaged area, leaving a square or rectangle so it’s easy to match up with a new patch of drywall. Look in the hole to see if the damage goes deeper than the drywall (to the studs, for example) and find the source of the leak so you can stop it before you fix the wall. Set up a fan near the hole you created and thoroughly dry the area before continuing.

Cut a new piece of drywall to fit tightly into the hole you have created. You may have to back it with a piece of wood. Then attach the drywall and use a good-quality drywall tape to cover the seams.

Prime, paint and keep a close eye on it in case the damage returns. That could signal a more serious water problem than you suspected.

How to repair the damage

If the damage is superficial, you may not have to replace the drywall. Dry the area thoroughly, sand the blisters from the wall, and prime the spot with a pigmented lacquer product called KILZ. This product will keep the stain from bleeding through a new coat of paint. Pick it up at any home improvement store.

If the damage is severe and you need to replace a large section of drywall with a new sheet, click these links for sheetrock installation.

How Do I Tape Sheet Rock Part 1
How Do I Tape Sheet Rock Part 2

Thompson’s Drywall Services, LLC is a small company which can provide a more affordable and personal working relationship. Although Rick is an Arizona native, he has acquired several different drywall finishing and texture techniques from one coast of the U.S. to the other. Rick has worked on many large and small projects throughout his 25+ years in the drywall industry. Rick takes great personal pride in each and every project. His work includes: acoustic (popcorn) removal, stress crack repair, patio ceiling refinishing, entertainment centers, repair to drywall damaged by water, and drywall repairs left behind from other service trade contractors.

Join Rosie on the House every Saturday morning from 8 a.m. to 11 a.m. on KTAR News 92.3 FM. If you’d like to send us questions or comments, email Follow us on Twitter and “Like” us on Facebook. For more do-it-yourself tips, go to An Arizona home building and remodeling industry expert since 1988, Rosie Romero is the host of the syndicated Saturday morning Rosie on the House radio program. Call 888-767-4348 with questions and comments.

Rosie On The House

image shows opened cabinet in what appears to be a kitchen...

Rosie Romero, Host and Owner of

What’s the difference between new and refreshed cabinets?

There are many things to consider when doing a home makeover, and the decision between new or refreshed cabinets is one of them!

2 days ago

Choosing the right Christmas tree can be a fun activity for the whole family. (Shutterstock Photo)...

Rosie Romero, Host and Owner of

Here’s a history of Christmas trees and tips on how to pick the right one

In America, the Christmas tree started becoming a fixture in the early 1800s, having been introduced by German immigrants.

16 days ago

image shows type of glass that can be used for a project...

Rosie Romero, Host and Owner of

Here’s how to choose the right glass for your next project

Because choosing between which glass to use in a project can become so difficult, Rosie on the House put together an easy guide to help.

23 days ago

Outdoor fire pit. (Shuttershock photo)...

Rosie Romero, Host and Owner of

Cozy up and stay warm by an outdoor fire this winter in Arizona

Winter is coming soon! Even on the coldest of desert days, it is possible to enjoy the out-of-doors with the help of a warm fire!

1 month ago

There are some simple electrical projects that a homeowner can do themselves. Let’s take a look....

Rosie Romero, Host and Owner of

A homeowner can help maintain their electrical system without touching the wires

We often caution homeowners not to mess with the electrical systems in their homes. However, there are some simple electrical projects that a homeowner can do themselves. Let’s take a look.

1 month ago

rosie on the house gives security tips to protect from hackers...

Rosie Romero, Host and Owner of

Internet safety and security tips for email and shopping online

Cyber security for your home computer and even your cell phone is as essential as security for your brick-and-mortar home.

1 month ago

Sponsored Articles

Follow @iamdamonallred...

Avoid a potential emergency and get your home’s heating and furnace safety checked

With the weather getting colder throughout the Valley, the best time to make sure your heating is all up to date is now. 

Follow @KTAR923...

The 2023 Diamondbacks are a good example to count on the underdog

The Arizona Diamondbacks made the World Series as a surprise. That they made the playoffs at all, got past the Milwaukee Brewers in the NL Wild Card round, swept the Los Angeles Dodgers in the NLDS and won two road games in Philadelphia to close out a full seven-game NLCS went against every expectation. Now, […]

Follow @KTAR923...

West Hunsaker at Morris Hall supports Make-A-Wish Foundation in Arizona

KTAR's Community Spotlight this month focuses on Morris Hall and its commitment to supporting the Make-A-Wish Foundation in Arizona.

How to repair drywall to make it look new again