MONICA LINDSTROM

Legally Speaking: Phoenix City Council has viable argument for rideshare fee

Jan 13, 2020, 8:17 AM | Updated: 8:25 am
(AP Photo)...
(AP Photo)
(AP Photo)

I hate to say it, but I think they will win.

Since October, KTAR News 92.3 FM’s Larry Gaydos and I have been railing against what he calls the “evil Phoenix City Council” about its decision to charge a fee on all Uber and Lyft rides to and from the airport.

Unfortunately, after reading the letter written by attorney Jean-Jacques Cabou to Attorney General Mark Brnovich, I believe the council has a leg to stand on.

Back in October 2019, the Phoenix City Council voted 7-2 to impose pickup and drop-off fees on all rideshare trips to and from Sky Harbor.

After the vote, Lyft threatened it would no longer operate at the airport if the fees were actually imposed.

The public found out the vote had to be redone because some technical requirements were not met with the vote. As such, the revote was scheduled for December.

For two months, Lyft, and eventually Uber, tried to negotiate with the council and others tried to convince the council not to vote for the increase.

The Goldwater Institute even informed the council the fee would be unconstitutional and a lawsuit could result. Nothing worked.

The Phoenix City Council stood its ground. At the December vote it again approved the fees 7-2.

Opponents claim the fee is really an illegal “tax” or surcharge and cite to Proposition 126.

Passed in November 2018, Proposition 126 added language to the Arizona Constitution and, according to the letter, “prohibits cities from imposing or increasing (1) ‘any sales tax,’ (2)’transaction privilege tax,’ (3) ‘luxury tax,’ (4) ‘excise tax,’ and (5) ‘use tax.’”

It also states that cities “shall not impose or increase any…other transaction-based tax’ or ‘fee’ … on the privilege to engage in … any service performed in this state.”

The letter makes numerous arguments that attempt to show the action taken by the council is legal.

Here, I address the two most influential ones.

First, it points out the city is entitled to operate the airport as a private business. Just like a private business, it is allowed to make money off of others using its property.

In other words, it is allowed to take a cut.

Rideshare companies like Uber and Lyft use the airport roads and curbs to make money and the airport is entitled to have a share of that income.

Just like every restaurant and store in the airport has to pay rent to use the airport property, the rideshare companies should have to pay rent for the time they use the roads and curbs.

This amounts to a substantial amount of money since they account for two-thirds of all ground transportation pick-ups at the airport.

Second, Uber and Lyft agreed to pay the fees. “Like all other transportation providers, [Uber and Lyft] are required to have permits to operate at the [a]irport.”

As part of obtaining that permit, they contractually agreed to pay the fees. So, it would be a breach of contract to now refuse to make that payment.

Regardless of the two strong legal arguments above, I, like many, do not like the fees.

It will be a $4 fee per drop-off and per pickup at the airport. No, not $4 total, but $4 each way.

This is more than what cabs and buses have to pay for the same roads and curbs and I think they should all be the same. Unfortunately, #legallyspeaking, the arguments in this letter are strong and will be hard to overcome.

Monica Lindstrom

Arizona State Courts Building (Arizona Governor's Office Photo)...
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: Brnovich appeal to Arizona Supreme Court makes sense

KTAR legal analyst Monica Lindstrom thinks it's a good move by Attorney General Mark Brnovich to petition the Arizona Supreme Court to hear his appeal in a case about laws that were ruled unconstitutional.
22 days ago
(File Photo by Matthew Hatcher/Getty Images)...
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: Why judge rejected Arizona ban on mask mandates

KTAR legal expert Monica Lindstrom explains the reasons behind a judge's decision to strike down Arizona's ban on face mask mandates.
23 days ago
(Facebook File Photo/Phoenix Police Department)...
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: Police may need to be part of Phoenix oversight office

Phoenix's requirement that no current or former law enforcement be part of a new police oversight office appears to be in direct conflict with recently signed Arizona laws, writes KTAR News legal expert Monica Lindstrom.
5 months ago
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: Arizona employees could be required to get virus vaccine

With coronavirus vaccines on the horizon, Arizona employers could require their employees to get the virus vaccine but there would be exceptions.
11 months ago
(AP Photo/Matt York)...
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: Maricopa County ballot lawsuit could have merit

KTAR legal expert Monica Lindstrom says the Maricopa County ballot lawsuit could have merit, whether it's for affecting ongoing races or correcting a procedural issue for the next election.
12 months ago
(KTAR News Photo/Kevin Stone)...
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: Why Arizona’s voter registration deadline was extended

A judge conducted a balancing test before ruling that Arizona's voter registration deadline should be extended, writes KTAR legal expert Monica Lindstrom.
1 year ago

Sponsored Articles

...
Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Why fall maintenance is important for your heating system and A/C

It’s easy to ignore your heater and air conditioner when they’re working but the moment something breaks, you will likely regret not keeping up with maintenance. After all, if something goes wrong, you may be stuck with a repair that will take longer and be more expensive than simple maintenance.
...
PNC Bank

3 cool tips to turn everyday moments into learning experiences for your child

Early brain development has a crucial impact on a child’s ability to learn and succeed in school and life. Research has shown that 90% of a child’s brain is developed by age five.
...
Sweet James

Best fall road trips to take on a motorcycle

Autumn in Arizona brings the beauty of color-changing leaves and a relief from summer heat. It’s one of the most pleasant times to explore the outdoors, especially on a motorcycle.
Legally Speaking: Phoenix City Council has viable argument for rideshare fee