Arizona’s Immigration Crisis: Finding a solution at the US-Mexico border

Apr 18, 2019, 4:26 AM | Updated: 11:12 am

KTAR News 92.3 continues to cover the situation at the Arizona-Mexico border. This week is a special series on Arizona’s Immigration Crisis. This is part four. Here are parts one, two and three.

PHOENIX – Build the wall. Expand the ports. Change asylum laws. Find more immigration judges.

To the U.S. Border Patrol agents, U.S. Customs and Border Protection officers, city mayors and business leaders, volunteer workers and other stakeholders, these solutions seem simple to stop the Central American migrant surge impacting communities in Arizona and across the country.

It’s up to the U.S. Congress and President Donald Trump to change the laws and expand facilities and resources to deal with migrants claiming asylum and reasonable fear of returning to their home countries.

That’s where things become difficult, and perhaps impossible.

Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey believes politics get in the way.

“I would say, unfortunately, outside of Arizona and inside the United States Congress, the 2020 presidential campaign has already kicked off and this is wrong. These election cycles last way too long,” Ducey added, referring to candidates trying to get more votes based on how they would vote on solutions to the current border crisis.


Elected officials for Arizona, both Democrats and Republicans, agree there is a “humanitarian” crisis at the border.

“In Tucson, Arizona, the major providers of shelter and support are at capacity, if not over,” said Rep. Raul Grijalva (D-District 3). “A community like Lukeville is not prepared to deal with 393 kids and parents.”

Grijalva was referring to the group that surrendered to Border Patrol agents near the Lukeville Port of Entry on Tuesday.

Rep. Debbie Lesko (R-District 8) said the situation is not only a problem for Arizona cities and towns, but the migrants themselves.

“This is not only a crisis for the United States, it’s a humanitarian crisis for the migrants that are traveling here and are being exploited by the cartels,” Lesko said.

On Wednesday, Customs and Border Patrol tweeted that it has already surpassed last fiscal year’s total apprehensions along the Southwest border: 414,000.

Rep. Andy Biggs (R-District 5) says people who don’t believe this is a crisis only see “a trickling” of migrants. But they add up.

“It’s kind of like the frog and the boiling water,” Biggs said. “You put a frog in cool water and then let the temperature rise and they don’t notice it. We’re kind of in that state.”

Phoenix City Councilman Michael Nowakowski sees a crisis, as migrants are increasingly left to fend for themselves upon release from Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

He wants ICE to modify its policy to coordinate transportation for migrants to their families and friends already in the U.S.

“Instead of just throwing them on the street and saying, ‘Good luck, find your sponsor.’ That’s wrong. Very wrong,” Nowakowski said.

Tuesday night, Yuma mayor Doug Nicholls signed an emergency declaration, asking for federal dollars to help public and private agencies provide food and temporary shelter to newly released migrants. Phoenix is not considering an emergency declaration, according to Nowakowski.

Along the border, politicians on both sides want to give more money for law enforcement to catch drugs and violent criminals among the migrants.

“You have to incentivize people to stay and get trained and remain Border Patrol agents,” Biggs said. “Right now, we have thousands of vacancies.”

Like the representatives and councilman, Ducey fears the generosity of nonprofits helping newly released migrants could run out at any moment.

“It’s time to quit playing politics on this and to actually take action like we have in Arizona,” he said.


Lesko said she co-sponsored a bill last year that would have provided funding for a border fence, tightened asylum laws to discourage migrants from traveling thousands of miles to enter the U.S. and also give recipients of DACA, the Obama-era executive order that protects migrants who came to the U.S. as children from deportation, legal status.

“Unfortunately, the Democrats who have always said that they want to help the DACA recipients, not one of them voted for it,” she said.

In March, a group of Democrats in the House introduced the American Dream and Promise Act of 2019. Rep. Greg Stanton (D-District 9) co-sponsored the bill, which would allow DACA recipients and immigrants with temporary humanitarian protections to apply for permanent legal status. However, this bill did not include funding for a border fence.

Meanwhile, Grijalva wants no changes to asylum laws.

“Our asylum law is based on international law,” he claimed. And he believes Trump’s threat to punish Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala — especially by cutting U.S. funding and resources there — will only exacerbate the crisis.

“Refugee status application centers were established under the Obama administration in those countries,” Grijalva recalled. “People could go there and go through the credible fear process. Those were one of the first things the Trump administration closed.”

Biggs put forth a bill last year to tax remittance payments — when U.S. families wire money to relatives in Mexico — in order to get that country to stop allowing migrants to freely move to the border.

He claims it’s a $30 billion industry annually.

“The threat of doing it makes Mexico stand up and pay attention,” Biggs said.

Grijalva would rather invest more U.S. dollars in Mexico.

“For them to be able to begin the credible fear process … for them to be able to provide relief (for migrants) at their ports of entry,” he said. “They have less infrastructure than we do.”

And even if Congress changed asylum laws to, for example, allow ICE to detain migrant families longer than 20 days for investigation, Grijalva doesn’t believe they’ll stick.

The 20-day limit refers to the Flores Agreement, the 1997 settlement which prevents family units from being detained for more than 20 days.

“You’ve had judges, time and time again, that have rejected any effort on the part of those laws being changed unilaterally of this administration,” he said.

Rep. Paul Gosar (R-District 4) says Congress must still try, especially when it comes to children being trafficked with adults who are not their parents.

“Even if you have a person that is a criminal, we can’t incarcerate them until we have rectification of that minor,” he said.


For hundreds of miles, a border wall divides the U.S. from Mexico. It also divides Republicans from Democrats.

“I think that the Democrats are a coordinated concerted effort to undermine the president of the United States and giving him any money for a border fence,” Lesko said. “They view the wall as a win for the president, but it’s actually a win for the country.”

Ducey says strengthened ports mean economic security.

“But my higher concern and higher purpose is always going to be around public safety,” he said. “And a good way to solve this issue is to focus on border security.”

Grijalva claims the president cannot get beyond building a border wall and closing ports of entry to curb the surge of migrants.

And he accused the president of creating the crisis by abusing federal law enforcement resources and policies.

“Taking 600 or 700 personnel from the ports of entry and reassigning them, the indefinite detention of minors if they’re separated from their families,” Grijalva listed.

In his office atop the executive tower at the state Capitol, KTAR News asked Ducey what comes first: the wall, ports of entry or legal reform. He said all of it.

“So, let’s see some leadership in the House of Representatives. So let’s see some leadership in the Senate,” Ducey said. “You can combine these things. You can prioritize these things. You can do them one at a time.

“But there should be action now.”

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

Rabies warning issued after rabid fox bites two victims in Arizona...

Balin Overstolz McNair

Arizona wildlife agency talks rabies infection risk and prevention as temps increase

Arizona health officials are issuing a rabies warning as rising temperatures draw more animals out of hiding.

17 minutes ago

AZ Political Podcast: Garrett Archer talks election integrity...

Jim Sharpe

AZ Political Podcast: Election analyst Garrett Archer with ABC15 talks election integrity

On this episode of the AZ Political Podcast, Garrett Archer, a data analyst with ABC15, sits down with Jim Sharpe to talk about elections.

28 minutes ago

Johnny Was, a bohemian-inspired brand developed in California, is set to open in Scottsdale Fashion...

SuElen Rivera

Johnny Was relocates to Scottsdale Fashion Square from Kierland Commons

Johnny Was, a bohemian-inspired brand developed in California, is set to open in Scottsdale Fashion Square on Friday after relocating from Kierland Commons.

37 minutes ago

The exterior of the El Dorado Tech Center in Gilbert. PipShip, an ecommerce solutions company, sign...

Kevin Stone

E-commerce solutions company PipShip moving operations from Tempe to Gilbert

PipShip is relocating its distribution and e-commerce operations from Tempe to Gilbert, a move of about 8 miles.

47 minutes ago

Iram Quintana...

Phoenix police make arrest in 9-year-old cold case murder

The Phoenix Police Department arrested Iram Quintana, the main suspect of a 2014 cold case murder, on Tuesday.

7 hours ago

Live music and DJ sets are one of the main attractions during the Whoopee Daze Festival this weeken...

David Veenstra

Whoopee Daze Festival arrives in Tolleson this weekend

The Whoopee Daze Festival returns to Tolleson this weekend. The three-day festival features a parade, carnival rides, food trucks and crafts.

9 hours ago

Sponsored Articles


Fiesta Bowl Foundation

The 51st annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade is excitingly upon us

The 51st annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade presented by Lerner & Rowe is upon us! The attraction honors Arizona and the history of the game.


Collins Comfort Masters

Avoid a potential emergency and get your home’s heating and furnace safety checked

With the weather getting colder throughout the Valley, the best time to make sure your heating is all up to date is now. 

(KTAR News Graphic)...

Boys & Girls Clubs

KTAR launches online holiday auction benefitting Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley

KTAR is teaming up with The Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley for a holiday auction benefitting thousands of Valley kids.

Arizona’s Immigration Crisis: Finding a solution at the US-Mexico border