GOP lawsuit settled, letting all Arizona counties verify ballots

Nov 9, 2018, 3:00 PM | Updated: 8:21 pm

PHOENIX – All 15 of Arizona’s counties can work to verify ballots that have signature irregularities after a Republican lawsuit was settled Friday afternoon without a hearing.

The lawsuit was filed Wednesday night in the midst of the drawn-out process of counting votes after Tuesday’s election and with the contentious U.S. Senate race between Democrat Kyrsten Sinema and Republican Martha McSally in the national spotlight.

As a result of the settlement, which was finalized in Maricopa County Superior Court, county recorders have until 5 p.m. Wednesday to “cure” early ballots that were submitted with signatures that didn’t match the voter registration signatures, using the same methods they used before the election.

“In other words, everybody just keep doing what you were doing before,” KTAR legal analyst Monica Lindstrom told KTAR News 92.3 FM’s Mac & Gaydos.

Up until now, only Maricopa and Pima counties had continued verifying signatures since polls closed Tuesday night.

Only a few thousand votes would be affected by the issue, but every one counts in the razor-close Senate race.

Maricopa County Recorder Adrian Fontes told Mac & Gaydos that the settlement was an “affirmation” of his office’s practices.

“It’s what I proposed early on. I am very glad we are all on the same sheet of music,” he said.

State Election Services Director Eric Spencer tweeted that it was “A great result for Arizona voters.”

McSally released the following statement supporting the settlement:

Equal protection under the law is a fundamental constitutional right for American voters. As a combat veteran, I fought to protect it. And today, we won an important battle to preserve that right for rural voters in Arizona. I will continue fighting until every ballot is counted.

The suit was filed before Thursday’s batch of votes moved Sinema ahead of McSally, who led by around 17,000 votes after Election Day.

Democrat Kathy Hoffman also surged ahead of her Republican opponent, Frank Riggs, in the superintendent of public instruction race.

The suit alleged that the state’s county recorders weren’t following a uniform standard for allowing voters to address problems with their early ballots, and that Maricopa and Pima counties were improperly allowing the fixes for up to five days after Election Day.

The Republican position was that it was unfair for voters in rural counties, which are GOP heavy, that conflicts weren’t resolved on all of their ballots.

“We believe that every single lawful vote in Arizona should be counted, including those from rural areas,” state GOP Chairman Jonathan Lines said during a press conference outside the downtown Phoenix court building before the hearing was scheduled to be held.

“The Democrats’ legal strategy is clear, as it is troubling. They want to disenfranchise 11 counties they can’t win.”

On Thursday, Maricopa Superior Court Judge Margaret R. Mahoney said it was too soon to require counties to stop contacting voters to verify signatures on mail ballots. She also declined to order the counties to temporarily separate mail ballots that have been verified by that process after Election Day.

County registrars said that would cause chaos and slow the long vote-counting process even more.

Friday morning, the Arizona GOP alleged that Fontes has deliberately destroyed evidence to cover up “voting irregularities.”

Lines issued a statement claiming Fontes “directed his office to mix the disputed ballots in with the undisputed ballots — thereby ensuring that there could be no review of voting irregularities.”

In response to the accusation, Fontes told Mac & Gaydos, “Mr. Lines and his hyperbole are bad for our democracy.”

Even President Donald Trump weighed in on the Arizona vote count, suggesting “electoral corruption” in a Friday tweet without supplying any evidence.

The state’s Republican secretary of state, Michelle Reagan, said in a statement that in order to ensure against voter fraud, mail ballots dropped off Election Day — which totaled 320,000 — are double-checked with votes cast at the polls to confirm no one voted twice.

“Arizona takes elections seriously – from the poll workers to the county elections officials, and the Secretary of State’s office,” Reagan said in a statement Friday. “Everybody is working diligently to tabulate all of the election results in a manner that Arizonans can be proud of and, most importantly, trust the results.”

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

A freeway sign on a poll says South Loop 101. Part of the southbound Loop 101 in Tempe will be clos...

Kevin Stone

East Valley closure tops list of metro Phoenix freeway restrictions this weekend

A full closure in the East Valley tops the list of metro Phoenix freeway restrictions this weekend.

1 hour ago

A conservative lawmaker, Austin Smith, halted his reelection campaign for the Arizona House of Repr...

Associated Press

Arizona GOP lawmaker drops reelection campaign after forgery allegations

Republican Arizona state Rep. Austin Smith halted his reelection campaign after being accused of forging signatures on his petitions.

3 hours ago

Arizonans should make sure their pets and livestock have up-to-date rabies vaccinations, health off...

Balin Overstolz McNair

Arizona wildlife officials warn about rabies threat as temperatures rise

Arizona wildlife officials are issuing a rabies warning as rising temperatures draw more animals out of hiding.

4 hours ago

AZ Political Podcast: Garrett Archer talks election integrity...

Jim Sharpe

AZ Political Podcast: Election analyst Garrett Archer with ABC15 talks election integrity

On this episode of the AZ Political Podcast, Garrett Archer, a data analyst with ABC15, sits down with Jim Sharpe to talk about elections.

5 hours ago

Johnny Was, a bohemian-inspired brand developed in California, is set to open in Scottsdale Fashion...

SuElen Rivera

Johnny Was relocates to Scottsdale Fashion Square from Kierland Commons

Johnny Was, a bohemian-inspired brand developed in California, is set to open in Scottsdale Fashion Square on Friday after relocating from Kierland Commons.

5 hours ago

The exterior of the El Dorado Tech Center in Gilbert. PipShip, an ecommerce solutions company, sign...

Kevin Stone

E-commerce solutions company PipShip moving operations from Tempe to Gilbert

PipShip is relocating its distribution and e-commerce operations from Tempe to Gilbert, a move of about 8 miles.

5 hours ago

Sponsored Articles



Here are 5 things Arizona residents need to know about their HVAC system

It's warming back up in the Valley, which means it's time to think about your air conditioning system's preparedness for summer.


Midwestern University

Midwestern University Clinics: transforming health care in the valley

Midwestern University, long a fixture of comprehensive health care education in the West Valley, is also a recognized leader in community health care.


Collins Comfort Masters

Here’s 1 way to ensure your family is drinking safe water

Water is maybe one of the most important resources in our lives, and especially if you have kids, you want them to have access to safe water.

GOP lawsuit settled, letting all Arizona counties verify ballots