Peoria police close hazing investigation into Liberty High wrestling program

Peoria police have closed their investigation into alleged sexual hazing within the Liberty High School wrestling program without filing criminal charges, the department announced Tuesday.

The investigation focused on allegations involving members of the wrestling program during the 2024-2025 school year. Detectives were unable to establish probable cause for criminal charges, police said.

The first report of possible hazing within the program came in February 2024. Earlier investigations did not substantiate sexual hazing claims.

“Additionally, no disclosures were made during the investigation that would support moving forward with a criminal prosecution,” the department said in a statement.

Police indicated the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office is aware of the investigation and its findings.

“With all leads and investigative avenues exhausted, MCAO does not expect a submittal on this matter,” the department said.

Detectives conducted numerous interviews, followed up on tips and worked with forensic interviewers trained to communicate with minors, according to a news release. Investigators sought to speak with people who may have had knowledge of or involvement in the reported incidents, many of whom are now adults.

“We recognize that allegations of this nature can be painful and unsettling, especially for those directly involved, their families and the wider community,” the department said.

Peoria Police reopened the case with new information

The case was reopened in 2025 after a former wrestler’s parent told police her now-adult son may have been a victim.

Former Liberty wrestler Ryder Fortenberry, who came forward with hazing allegations, previously told KTAR News’ The Chris & Joe Show that he reported the abuse to protect his younger brother and change the program’s culture.

“I can’t protect my little brother, you know, that’s my job,” Fortenberry said in September.

Fortenberry, who said the hazing affected him beginning his freshman year, captured two videos as evidence and reported the incidents to his parents and the coaching staff.

Head coach Eric Brenton was placed on paid administrative leave last year but was reportedly reinstated this year, according to the Arizona Republic.

“The department remains committed to conducting thorough, unbiased investigations and to supporting the safety, dignity, and well-being of all members of the community, especially minors,” police said.

Liberty High’s wrestling program finished as state runner-up in Division I for five consecutive years.

KTAR News 92.3 FM’s Senior Editor Kevin Stone contributed to this report.

Related

Police reopen hazing investigation of powerhouse Valley high school wrestling programLiberty High School wrestler says he came forward to protect his little brother from hazing‘We know it’s gonna be close,’ Gov. Katie Hobbs says as likely Andy Biggs matchup loomsLive updates for Arizona’s 2026 primaries: Supervisor explains technical issueTechnical issues disrupt a small number of Maricopa County voters on Election DayElection changes could lead to quicker results in Maricopa County, Adrian Fontes says