UNCATEGORIZED

Legally Speaking: Phoenix City Council has viable argument for rideshare fee

Jan 13, 2020, 8:17 AM | Updated: 8:25 am

(AP Photo)...

(AP Photo)

(AP Photo)

I hate to say it, but I think they will win.

Since October, KTAR News 92.3 FM’s Larry Gaydos and I have been railing against what he calls the “evil Phoenix City Council” about its decision to charge a fee on all Uber and Lyft rides to and from the airport.

Unfortunately, after reading the letter written by attorney Jean-Jacques Cabou to Attorney General Mark Brnovich, I believe the council has a leg to stand on.

Back in October 2019, the Phoenix City Council voted 7-2 to impose pickup and drop-off fees on all rideshare trips to and from Sky Harbor.

After the vote, Lyft threatened it would no longer operate at the airport if the fees were actually imposed.

The public found out the vote had to be redone because some technical requirements were not met with the vote. As such, the revote was scheduled for December.

For two months, Lyft, and eventually Uber, tried to negotiate with the council and others tried to convince the council not to vote for the increase.

The Goldwater Institute even informed the council the fee would be unconstitutional and a lawsuit could result. Nothing worked.

The Phoenix City Council stood its ground. At the December vote it again approved the fees 7-2.

Opponents claim the fee is really an illegal “tax” or surcharge and cite to Proposition 126.

Passed in November 2018, Proposition 126 added language to the Arizona Constitution and, according to the letter, “prohibits cities from imposing or increasing (1) ‘any sales tax,’ (2)’transaction privilege tax,’ (3) ‘luxury tax,’ (4) ‘excise tax,’ and (5) ‘use tax.’”

It also states that cities “shall not impose or increase any…other transaction-based tax’ or ‘fee’ … on the privilege to engage in … any service performed in this state.”

The letter makes numerous arguments that attempt to show the action taken by the council is legal.

Here, I address the two most influential ones.

First, it points out the city is entitled to operate the airport as a private business. Just like a private business, it is allowed to make money off of others using its property.

In other words, it is allowed to take a cut.

Rideshare companies like Uber and Lyft use the airport roads and curbs to make money and the airport is entitled to have a share of that income.

Just like every restaurant and store in the airport has to pay rent to use the airport property, the rideshare companies should have to pay rent for the time they use the roads and curbs.

This amounts to a substantial amount of money since they account for two-thirds of all ground transportation pick-ups at the airport.

Second, Uber and Lyft agreed to pay the fees. “Like all other transportation providers, [Uber and Lyft] are required to have permits to operate at the [a]irport.”

As part of obtaining that permit, they contractually agreed to pay the fees. So, it would be a breach of contract to now refuse to make that payment.

Regardless of the two strong legal arguments above, I, like many, do not like the fees.

It will be a $4 fee per drop-off and per pickup at the airport. No, not $4 total, but $4 each way.

This is more than what cabs and buses have to pay for the same roads and curbs and I think they should all be the same. Unfortunately, #legallyspeaking, the arguments in this letter are strong and will be hard to overcome.

Array

This image provided by Coors Light shows the Coors Light 2025 Super Bowl NFL football spot. (Coors ...

Associated Press

Super Bowl commercials rely on comedy and nostalgia to avoid potential missteps

Most of the commercials airing during this year’s Super Bowl are going for laughs, with advertisers betting that America could use a brief diversion. As the Philadelphia Eagles and the Kansas City Chiefs hit the field in New Orleans, a parade of silly ads will hit airwaves on Sunday. Many companies put their ads online […]

20 minutes ago

Elon Musk reacts as President-elect Donald Trump speaks at a rally ahead of the 60th Presidential I...

Associated Press

Elon Musk dodges DOGE scrutiny while expanding his power in Washington

Elon Musk made a promise after Trump decided to put him in charge of making the government more efficient. It hasn't worked out that way so far.

41 minutes ago

Two Valley freeway ramps will be closed for the next two months....

Kevin Stone

2 Valley on-ramps closing for 2 months as part of freeway improvement projects

A couple of metro Phoenix freeway ramps are closing for the next two months as part of ongoing improvement projects.

2 hours ago

FILE - Donald Trump shakes hands with Herschel Walker in New York after agreement on a 4-year contr...

Associated Press

A presidential first: Trump at the Super Bowl, latest chapter in a complicated legacy with football

WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. (AP) — As a student, Donald Trump played high school football. As a business baron, he owned a team in an upstart rival to the NFL and then sued the established league. As president, he denigrated pros who took a knee during the national anthem as part of a social justice […]

3 hours ago

This combination photo shows Tulsi Gabbard, nominee for Director of National Intelligence, left, pi...

Associated Press

How Republican skeptics in the Senate got to ‘yes’ on RFK Jr. and Gabbard

WASHINGTON (AP) — Republican skepticism in the Senate of President Donald Trump’sCabinet nominees has been worn down, putting his unconventional choices for some of the most powerful positions in the federal government on the verge of confirmation. Floor votes are expected this week on Robert F. Kennedy Jr., in line to be the nation’s health […]

3 hours ago

Honeywell Aerospace...

Collin Huguley and Jeff Gifford/Phoenix Business Journal

Phoenix-based Honeywell Aerospace to go its own way amid company split

Phoenix-based Honeywell Aerospace Technologies is going to become a separate entity now that Honeywell International Inc. plans to follow through with a major shake-up.

3 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...

Fiesta Bowl Foundation

Join us for the 52nd annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade

The 52nd annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade presented by Lerner & Rowe returns on Saturday, December 28, at 10 a.m.

...

Bright Wealth Management

How to save money on retirement planning following 2024 election

PHOENIX -- With the 2024 election over, economic changes could impact how people plan for retirement as 2025 is on the horizon.

...

Sanderson Ford

Sanderson Ford’s Operation Santa Claus: Spreading holiday cheer through pickleball

Phoenix, AZ – Sanderson Ford, a staple in the Arizona community, is once again gearing up for its annual Operation Santa Claus charity drive.

Legally Speaking: Phoenix City Council has viable argument for rideshare fee