Supreme Court lets ruling stand that Arizona man can sue medical maker

Jun 24, 2014, 12:47 PM | Updated: 12:48 pm

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court rejected an appeal Monday from medical device manufacturer Medtronic challenging an Arizona man’s lawsuit that claimed the company’s pain-medication pump left him paralyzed below the waist.

Medtronic argued that federal rules pre-empt Arizona law, which should have prevented Richard and Mary Lou Stengel from suing the company under state law. But the high court, without comment, declined to hear the case and let a lower court ruling against Medtronic stand.

Thomas Cotter, the Stengels’ attorney, was not immediately available for comment. But Scott Nelson, an attorney with the Public Citizen Litigation Group, who helped prepare the Stengels’ case to the Supreme Court, said he was pleased with Monday’s decision and hopes other courts will now be willing to hear cases of injuries caused by medical devices.

Medtronic’s attorneys declined to comment, but the company said in an emailed statement that it was disappointed with the denial. The company still maintains that exclusive Food and Drug Administration oversight is necessary to maintain safe and effective medical devices.

“Without pre-emption, there would be no central standard for device safety, effectiveness, testing, labeling and marketing,” the statement said.

The case began in 2000, when Richard Stengel had a Medtronic medication pump surgically implanted, according to court records. In 2005, he began to suffer paralysis in his lower limbs caused by a granuloma, a type of inflammation that he said formed in his spine at the tip of the pump, according to court documents.

Doctors removed the pump, but Stengel eventually lost the use of his legs. He has since died.

The Stengels charged that Medtronic knew about the risks associated with the pump, but did not reveal that information until the FDA inspected its facilities in 2006 and 2007 and issued a warning letter to Medtronic. The company recalled the device in March 2008.

The Stengels sued in 2010, alleging strict liability, breach of warranty and negligence. They subsequently claimed the company had violated Arizona’s negligence law by failing to warn the FDA about the pump’s risks.

A district court found that federal law pre-empted the state-law claim, since the pump had met the FDA’s pre-market approval. That ruling was upheld by a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in 2012.

But the full circuit court unanimously reversed that decision in 2013, writing that Arizona law “parallels” federal laws and that Stengel deserved a chance to sue.

In its petition to the U.S. Supreme Court, Medtronic argued that the FDA regulations are exclusive to the federal government and cannot be enforced by states.

“Private enforcement … would jeopardize the public health by permitting lay juries to second-guess the FDA’s expert regulatory judgment,” the company said in its petition to the high court.

That was echoed in several briefs in support of Medtronic. The Defense Research Institute said the Supreme Court should weigh in to clarify the case’s pre-emption issues and the extent of federal control over manufacturers.

Eric Magnuson, who co-wrote the institute’s brief, said he was disappointed by the high court’s denial, but would not speculate on what it means.

“It’s kind of like reading tea leaves,” he said. “When they say no, you can think of a hundred different ways they may justify that.”

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

(Facebook Photo/Mesa Police Department, File)...

Damon Allred

Police investigating overnight homicide shooting in Mesa

Police are investigating an overnight incident in which they found a male individual unresponsive in Mesa, authorities confirmed.

37 minutes ago

File photo of a sign at the University of Arizona entrance in Tucson. Students and faculty members ...

David Veenstra

ABOR to hold University of Arizona presidential search town hall

The Arizona Board of Regents will hold a town hall so community members can share their input on the next University of Arizona president.

3 hours ago

(Photo provided by Evolve Public Relations and Marketing.)...

Arizona Animal Welfare League to waive most adoption fees from May 1-15

National Adopt A Shelter Pet Day, which is coming up on April 30, is a perfect day to adopt a pet.

4 hours ago

Stock photo of a worker hammering at a construction site. A dallas-based homebuilder recently close...

Angela Gonzales/Phoenix Business Journal

Landsea plans 90-home gated community on newly purchased Mesa land

Dallas-based Landsea Homes Corp. just closed on a 14.5-acre parcel in Mesa, with plans to create a gated community with 90 homes.

5 hours ago

woman holds money and types into computer...

Arizona street gang indicted after alleged involvement in pandemic assistance fraud scheme

Members of the Arizona Mexican Mafia received a 50-count indictment after fraudulently filling for Pandemic Unemployment Assistance funds.

14 hours ago

Image of a thermometer measuring high heat. The heat dome that's been baking Texas is inching towar...

Chandler to begin heat relief services on May 1

With summer seemingly coming fast, the City of Chandler plans to open a day respite center and eight cooling locations starting on May 1.

16 hours ago

Sponsored Articles


Midwestern University

Midwestern University Clinics: transforming health care in the valley

Midwestern University, long a fixture of comprehensive health care education in the West Valley, is also a recognized leader in community health care.


DISC Desert Institute for Spine Care

Sciatica pain is treatable but surgery may be required

Sciatica pain is one of the most common ailments a person can face, and if not taken seriously, it could become one of the most harmful.

(KTAR News Graphic)...

Boys & Girls Clubs

KTAR launches online holiday auction benefitting Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley

KTAR is teaming up with The Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley for a holiday auction benefitting thousands of Valley kids.

Supreme Court lets ruling stand that Arizona man can sue medical maker