UNITED STATES NEWS

California voters consider controversial vacation homes tax in iconic Lake Tahoe area

Oct 30, 2024, 9:12 PM

Homeowner Kelly O'Hare stands on her balcony overlooking South Lake Tahoe, Calif. on Friday, Oct. 1...

Homeowner Kelly O'Hare stands on her balcony overlooking South Lake Tahoe, Calif. on Friday, Oct. 18, 2024, where voters will decide whether to approve Measure N, which will mandate a tax to homeowners who leave their homes vacant for more than half the year. (AP Photo/Haven Daley)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(AP Photo/Haven Daley)

SOUTH LAKE TAHOE, Calif. (AP) — Owners of vacation homes in Northern California’s South Lake Tahoe could face a significant tax increase if voters in the mountain resort town approve a measure on Tuesday’s ballot that pits affordable housing against private property rights.

South Lake Tahoe, which sits on the shores of the iconic alpine lake, has about 7,000 vacant homes — 44% of the city’s estimated housing units — according to the 2022 American Community Survey. Measure N would levy a flat $3,000 tax on homes that are vacant 182 days within a calendar year.

The tax would increase to $6,000 for every subsequent year the home remains empty for half the year.

The town is the latest across the United States with a growing debate about the impact of vacation properties. Critics say vacant second homes have worsened the nation’s housing crisis by contributing to a shortage of affordable rental properties, especially in pricey resort places like South Lake Tahoe.

Supporters of the measure say they want to encourage homeowners to rent to workers or pay into a fund for housing, roads and transportation projects. They say the city is shedding families as businesses struggle to hire staff in a region with little land available for housing development.

Kelly Bessem works at least 50 hours a week at multiple jobs as a hydrology and land management field scientist and a snowboard instructor. She’s currently sleeping in her car to buy a house in Markleeville, which is a 40-minute drive to South Lake Tahoe.

“I’ve done all the things I’m supposed to, but it’s still to the point where I just squeeze by,” Bessem said.

Nancy Dunn, a homeowner who has lived part-time in South Lake Tahoe since 2018, opposes the measure as unfair and un-American.

“This is my home, and I want to be able to come back to it when I want to, and come and go as I feel,” Dunn said as she stocked her house with firewood earlier this month. “The American way is to have the right to own property, and to do with it as you please.”

The California Association of Realtors and the National Association of Realtors have contributed a combined $1 million to defeat the measure in a town with only 12,000 registered voters.

While still rare in the U.S., more places are considering an empty homes or vacant homes tax to address workforce housing shortages by tapping underused homes to expand the long-term rental market.

In Hawaii, the Honolulu City Council is trying to pass an empty homes tax, its third attempt since 2018, while the Colorado Association of Ski Towns is seeking legislation allowing cities and counties to ask voters to approve vacant homes taxes.

Margaret Bowes, the Colorado group’s executive director, said resort towns have few options in where they can build. The lack of housing “has reached a crisis level” affecting basic services and commerce “from ski resort companies to local, small businesses,” she said.

Perhaps the best known example is Vancouver, Canada, which in 2017 imposed a 1% tax on an empty home’s assessed taxable value. The tax is now 3% and the city says it has generated $142 million for affordable housing projects.

In California, San Francisco and Berkeley approved taxes on vacant properties in 2022.

Vacancy taxes can work to a limited degree in larger cities, but an empty homes tax could make a huge difference in smaller towns like South Lake Tahoe, said Shane Phillips, who manages the Randall Lewis Housing Initiative at the University of California, Los Angeles.

He did not know enough about the proposed tax to weigh in, but generally supports vacancy taxes on vacation homes in regions where housing is short. Taxes can be used to discourage harmful behavior, he said, such as taxes on cigarettes.

“And I think there’s a similar argument to be made here, that people consuming multiple homes and not living in them in communities like South Lake Tahoe … it’s actually doing harm to other people,” Phillips said.

Measure N has roiled the tiny community, which with about 21,000 year-round residents is the most populous city ringing Lake Tahoe and a popular weekend destination. It is 188 miles (300 kilometers) northeast of San Francisco.

The city has a median household income of $68,000, lower than the $95,000 median in California. The median sales price of a home was $750,000 in September — up from $427,000 five years ago, according to Redfin.

Modeled on Berkeley’s empty homes tax, the city projects that the proposed tax will raise up to $8 million in its first year and up to $20 million a year afterwards.

Amelia Richmond, co-founder of Locals for Affordable Housing, the group that collected the signatures to get the issue on the ballot, said it is an opportunity to ensure South Lake Tahoe does not go the way of other mountain towns with even higher vacancy rates.

Property owners would self-report each year, although documentation may be required. There are exceptions to the occupancy requirement, such as homes undergoing renovation.

To avoid the tax, owners of vacation homes could sell their property, lease to a tenant year-round, or rent to seasonal travelers or workers. They can’t list their homes as short-term rentals after the city voted to curtail rentals of fewer than 30 days, citing noise and the housing shortage.

Opponents say many of them scrimped and saved for modest second homes and they shouldn’t be punished for the region’s lack of affordable housing. They’re also upset because as part-time residents, they cannot vote on the measure.

Tom Fields, 85, splits his time between a three-bedroom house that he describes as nothing special other than its location on Lake Tahoe and a place in central Oregon.

“This is crazy and I don’t even know if it’s constitutional,” he said. “When you purchase the land and they start taking away rights, that’s when people get upset.”

—-

Har reported from San Francisco.

United States News

Palestinians gather to receive bags of flour distributed by UNRWA, the U.N. agency helping Palestin...

Associated Press

Middle East latest: Israel ends agreement with UN agency providing aid in Gaza

Israel said Monday it had terminated the agreement facilitating the work of the U.N. agency for Palestinian refugees, the main aid provider in Gaza, in what appeared to be a step to implement legislation passed last month that would sever ties with the agency and prevent it from operating in Israel. Israel says the agency, […]

4 hours ago

Miami-Dade residents wait in line to vote at the Joseph Caleb Center during the "Souls to the Polls...

Associated Press

Florida will vote on marijuana, abortion in an election that will test GOP’s dominance

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. (AP) — Florida’s election will test whether the state maintains its new reputation as a Republican stronghold, or whether Democrats make some gains by tapping into the support for abortion and marijuana ballot questions and the new energy Vice President Kamala Harris brings to the race. Gone are the days when Florida was […]

6 hours ago

Federal Reserve Board Chairman Jerome Powell speaks at lecturn...

Associated Press

Federal Reserve is set to cut rates again while facing a hazy post-election outlook

The Federal Reserve's move two days after Election Day is much easier to predict than the future president: With inflation continuing to cool, the Fed is set to cut interest rates for a second time this year.

8 hours ago

Associated Press

Stock market today: Asian shares are mostly higher as China begins major economic meeting

Shares were mostly higher in Asia on Monday as China’s leaders began a major meeting expected to bring fresh pledges of help for the world’s second-largest economy. Oil prices gained more than $1 a barrel after the OPEC+ oil producing nations said they would extend production cuts until the end of the year. No reason […]

9 hours ago

A Boeing employee looks at informational pamphlets before heading in to vote on a new contract offe...

Associated Press

Boeing machinists are holding a contract vote that could end their 7-week strike

Unionized factory workers at Boeing are voting Monday whether to accept a contract offer or to continue their strike, which has lasted more than seven weeks and shut down production of most Boeing passenger planes. A vote to ratify the contract would clear the way for the aerospace giant to resume airplane production and bring […]

11 hours ago

Democratic presidential nominee Vice President Kamala Harris speaks to reporters after delivering r...

Associated Press

Harris won’t say how she voted on California measure that would reverse criminal justice reforms

DETROIT (AP) — Vice President Kamala Harris on Sunday declined to say how she voted on a key ballot measure in her home state of California that would reverse criminal justice reforms approved in recent years. Harris punted on a question about the ballot initiative in comments to reporters while campaigning in the battleground state […]

16 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...

Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Why a Heating Tune-Up is Essential Before Winter

PHOENIX, AZ — With cooler weather on the horizon, making sure your heating system is prepped and ready can make all the difference in staying comfortable this winter.

...

Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

It wouldn’t hurt to get your AC checked after Arizona’s excruciating heat wave

A well-maintained air conditioning unit is vital to living a comfortable life inside, away from triple-digit heat in Arizona.

...

Sanderson Ford

3 storylines to get you revved up for the 2024 Arizona Cardinals

Arizona Cardinals training camp is just a couple weeks away starting on July 25, and Sanderson Ford is revved up and ready to go.

California voters consider controversial vacation homes tax in iconic Lake Tahoe area