ARIZONA NEWS

Researcher calls DOJ’s analysis of Phoenix Police Department’s use of force incidents ‘misleading’

Aug 29, 2024, 2:00 PM | Updated: 2:02 pm

civil rights violations Phoenix police department DOJ...

A new report released on Aug. 25, 2024, called the DOJ's analysis of the Phoenix Police Department "misleading." (Phoenix Law Enforcement Association File Photo/via Facebook)

(Phoenix Law Enforcement Association File Photo/via Facebook)

PHOENIX — A researcher involved in a new study said the Department of Justice’s claims about civil rights violations by the Phoenix Police Department are misleading.

Travis Yates, a former Tulsa police officer and author with the Courageous Police Leadership Alliance, has thoroughly examined the DOJ report.

The June 13 report accused Phoenix Police of a pattern of using excessive force against crime suspects.

However, many of the department’s findings need to be challenged, Yates told KTAR News 92.3 FM’s The Mike Broomhead Show on Wednesday.

Yates was a key researcher in a detailed 97-page report released over the weekend. The paper analyzed 36 use-of-force cases the DOJ cited in its report.

“I took a look at the narrative from the DOJ,” Yates said. “Then I went and I looked at the actual incidents. So 34 of those weren’t even close.”

The other two were partly accurate, but exaggerated, he added.

“The department actually took action on those incidents,” Yates said.

Yates based his conclusions on evidence he found from an interactive website the city of Phoenix launched in the wake of the DOJ report.

The city made the website in order to give the public access to videos and information on various incidents detailed in the report.

Phoenix PD’s alleged civil rights violations ‘misleading,’ he says

He said the DOJ report seemed to misunderstand the difference between constitutional and unconstitutional force. Yates also said the report left pertinent facts out of its analysis of use of force incidents.

He cited an assault case that took place near 43rd Avenue and McDowell road in Phoenix on April 16, 2020. A victim called police for help after a man jumped out of a car and chased her into the parking lot.

Four officers restrained him, one holding hands on his neck while another fired a taser into his back, the DOJ report said. The department characterized the suspect as experiencing a behavioral health crisis and not presenting a risk to anyone.

“They said, ‘Well, he was just suffering a behavioral crisis.’ Well, that may have been true, but they left out the part about kidnapping and the fights and the violence and everything that went on during that incident,” Yates said. “They selectively left things out.”

Yates said he believed the DOJ may have been biased when analyzing use of force incidents. The DOJ has pushed for Phoenix to enter into a consent decree, which cost some police departments millions of dollars in annual payments.

In fact, Yates said Phoenix officers often go above and beyond to avoid using deadly force.

“I was completely blown away and so impressed by what I read,” he said. “I don’t know whether it was lazy work or they just had a bias going into it.”

Overall, he found the DOJ’s analysis concerning.

“I’m extremely troubled at the picture they tried to paint,” Yates said. “I think the public deserves some answers here.”

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

(Facebook Photo/Tempe Police Department)...

Dave Neil

Man reportedly shot and killed by police in Tempe on Friday night

A 32-year-old man was killed and a police officer suffered injuries as part of a shooting in Tempe on Friday night.

33 minutes ago

Mesa Asian District...

Danny Shapiro

Urban Air 1st to lease space in Mesa Asian District center set to undergo renovations

Urban Air is the first company to lease space at a retail center in the Mesa Asian District that is set to undergo renovations.

3 hours ago

Endangered red squirrels: 233 of the Arizona animals counted...

Serena O'Sullivan

Endangered Mount Graham red squirrel population increases substantially in Arizona

The population of a species of endangered red squirrels unique to southeast Arizona's Mount Graham has risen slightly, according to wildlife officials.

4 hours ago

US 93 closed near Interstate 40 crash...

Payne Moses

Northbound US 93 reopens near Interstate 40 after crash

Both northbound lanes of U.S. 93 were reopened near Interstate 40 on Friday night after a crash, authorities said.

11 hours ago

Desert Diamond Arena in Glendale has released details on a $42 million transformation from a sports...

Bailey Leasure

ADOT continues work on Interstate 40, US 93 Kingman interchange

ADOT provided an update on its $106 million project connecting U.S. Route 93 and Interstate 40 in Kingman.

13 hours ago

Ground ambulance service program in Scottsdale to begin January 2025...

David Veenstra

Scottsdale Fire launching ground ambulance service

The Scottsdale Fire Department is launching a new ground ambulance service, the department announced on Friday.

14 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...

The UPS Store

How The UPS Store is giving back to the community

PHOENIX -- As 2024 nears a close, The UPS Store is looking to give back to the Arizona community with the holiday season approaching.

...

Sanderson Ford

Sanderson Ford’s Operation Santa Claus: Spreading holiday cheer through pickleball

Phoenix, AZ – Sanderson Ford, a staple in the Arizona community, is once again gearing up for its annual Operation Santa Claus charity drive.

...

Midwestern University

Midwestern University Clinics – Providing Comprehensive, Thorough and Unrushed Healthcare to the Valley Community

With so many options for healthcare in the Valley, why should you choose a clinic that has graduate medical students integrated into the patient experience?

Researcher calls DOJ’s analysis of Phoenix Police Department’s use of force incidents ‘misleading’