Judge rejects Arizona Sen. Wendy Rogers’ restraining order against reporter

May 10, 2023, 7:30 PM | Updated: 8:26 pm

(Facebook Photo/Wendy Rogers)...

(Facebook Photo/Wendy Rogers)

(Facebook Photo/Wendy Rogers)

PHOENIX (AP) — A judge dismissed Arizona state Sen. Wendy Rogers’ restraining order against a reporter Wednesday, saying that the investigative journalist’s conduct did not rise to the level of harassment.

“I don’t think there is a series of events directed at Sen. Rogers that would cause a reasonable person to be seriously alarmed, annoyed or harassed even if she in fact was,” Judge Howard Grodman said after a hearing in Flagstaff Justice Court. “The strongest point is investigative reporting is a legitimate purpose. lt just is.”

A different judge approved the Republican lawmaker’s request for an injunction last month against reporter Camryn Sanchez, sparking an outcry from journalists and First Amendment advocates. The hearing was held without any notice given to Sanchez.

Christopher Hennessy, the attorney representing Sanchez, said in a statement that the newspaper was pleased with the ruling.

“We stand firmly behind Ms. Sanchez and all our reporters in the exercise of their rights under the First Amendment and we are pleased that the court recognized that this injunction was improper,” the statement said. “We look forward to continuing in our work reporting the news and are glad to put this issue behind us.”

Will Fischbach, the lawyer for Rogers, did not respond to phone and email messages seeking comment.

During the hearing, Fischbach had argued this was not a First Amendment case.

“Journalists go around knocking on doors asking questions, sure they do,” Fischbach said. “But this was an instance that Ms. Sanchez was told specifically not to have contact with Ms. Rogers at her desk.”

Hennessy accused Rogers of using an injunction as a tactic to keep Sanchez from doing her job.

“What Sen. Rogers decided to do is take something that is intended to be a shield and turned it into weapon,” Hennessy said.

Dr. Joseph Russomanno, a journalism and mass communication professor at Arizona State University’s Cronkite School, said upholding Rogers’ injunction would have put journalists and basic news gathering in danger.

“The bigger picture here is thank goodness this ruling happened today,” Russomanno said. “There’s a reason we have the First Amendment and guaranteed freedom of the press. Is it carte blanche? No. There are reasonable restrictions. That was not happening at all in this situation.”

The senator filed a petition for an injunction after Sanchez, who covers the Senate for the Arizona Capitol Times, began investigating whether Rogers’ primary residence was in her legislative district.

The district encompasses a portion of northern Arizona, including Flagstaff. Financial disclosure forms state Rogers lives in a mobile home in Flagstaff. Sanchez found public property records indicating Rogers and her husband bought a home in the Phoenix suburb of Chandler in January, according to the newspaper. They also signed a trust document stating she lives in nearby Tempe.

Sanchez approached both Chandler and Tempe homes last month to inquire if Rogers or anyone in her family was present and to talk to neighbors.

Rogers cited the interactions and an instance in February when Sanchez approached her on the Senate floor with questions as evidence of harassment. It is common practice for journalists covering statehouses to go up to lawmakers on the floor. She claimed Sanchez had been verbally warned last year not to go up to her there.

Sanchez said in testimony that nobody gave her such a warning last year.

Based solely on Rogers’ testimony, a judge rejected banning Sanchez from the Senate but granted a request she stay away from Rogers’ homes for one year. At the time, the judge asked Rogers if she knew whether it was common practice for journalists to approach a person’s home.

Russomanno, the journalism professor, found that problematic.

“That the judge would place credibility in Sen. Rogers and her ability to determine what is a standard practice of journalism, which is in effect what the judge was asking her, it was ridiculous,” Russomanno said.

Rogers opted for an injunction rather than waiting to hold a hearing where Sanchez could be present.

“The idea here is for the person to learn their lesson and then leave the situation alone, correct?” Rogers told the judge at the time, according to audio from the hearing. “I assure you; we’ve tried to be diplomatic and reasonable up to this point. When someone comes to your house, that’s just over the top.”

Knocking on someone’s door if there’s no barrier or “no trespassing” sign is not unreasonable, said Judge Grodman, citing kids trick-or-treating and his own election campaigning as examples.

“You’re certainly free, Sen. Rogers, to advise anybody that they’re not welcome to your house,” Grodman said. “Then it becomes a criminal trespass. You can protect your home that way.”

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

Republican presidential candidate former President Donald Trump gestures at a campaign rally Saturd...

Associated Press

Donald Trump wins Missouri and Idaho caucuses, sweeps Michigan GOP convention

Trump continued his march toward the GOP nomination, winning caucuses in Idaho and Missouri and sweeping the convention in Michigan.

8 hours ago

Maine man, 79, dies while hiking Pyramid Trail in Sedona...

Damon Allred

Gov. Katie Hobbs announces Extreme Heat Preparedness Plan, establishes chief heat officer

Gov. Katie Hobbs announced the state's first Extreme Heat Preparedness Plan, creating the country's first state level heat officer.

8 hours ago

Kacey Musgraves, center, performs at the Billboard Music Awards at the MGM Grand Garden Arena on Su...

Kacey Musgraves to play Glendale concert in September

Seven-time Grammy Award-winning singer/songwriter Kacey Musgraves is scheduled to perform at Desert Diamond Arena in Glendale on Sept. 27.

10 hours ago

Jose Andres Guerrero Talamantes...

Arrest made in fatal hit-and-run case in Carefree from December

Police arrested a man on Friday on felony hit-and-run charges involving death as part of an investigation into a crash that occurred in Carefree.

12 hours ago

Traffic is backed up on Interstate 10 near State Route 347 south of metro Phoenix...

Report lists Phoenix, Tucson among U.S. cities with worst drivers

Two Arizona cities have landed in the top 10 of a national ranking of places with the worst drivers in the nation.

14 hours ago

Caution tape in front of police car....

2 police officers injured in crash with suspected impaired driver in Phoenix

Two police officers suffered minor injuries in a two-vehicle crash in central Phoenix early Saturday morning.

16 hours ago

Sponsored Articles


DISC Desert Institute for Spine Care

Sciatica pain is treatable but surgery may be required

Sciatica pain is one of the most common ailments a person can face, and if not taken seriously, it could become one of the most harmful.


Collins Comfort Masters

Avoid a potential emergency and get your home’s heating and furnace safety checked

With the weather getting colder throughout the Valley, the best time to make sure your heating is all up to date is now. 


Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Valley residents should be mindful of plumbing ahead of holidays

With Halloween in the rear-view and more holidays coming up, Day & Night recommends that Valley residents prepare accordingly.

Judge rejects Arizona Sen. Wendy Rogers’ restraining order against reporter