Battles rage in Arizona courts over 3 voter initiatives

Aug 16, 2022, 2:00 PM

(Photo by Oleg Nikishin/Newsmakers)...

(Photo by Oleg Nikishin/Newsmakers)

(Photo by Oleg Nikishin/Newsmakers)

PHOENIX (AP) — Proponents of three voter initiatives who each turned in hundreds of thousands of signatures last month to qualify them for the November ballot are trying to beat back legal challenges that could prevent them from going before voters.

Two of the measures — one requiring disclosure of who is funding political campaigns and another rolling back or blocking efforts by Republicans to tighten voting rules — are being challenged by pro-business groups. They alleged that paid petition circulators made errors or omitted required information on their registrations with the secretary of state or petitions.

The third measure, backed by a California-based employee union, would protect residents from predatory bill collection and raise the amount of assets shielded from bill collectors. It faces a similar challenge from a newly formed group funded by Arizona debt collection agencies, who say the description voters see when they are asked to sign was illegally misleading.

Lawyers for challengers and the initiative proponents have spent the past two weeks in court, and three Phoenix judges will decide separately who is correct. Whichever sides lose are are expected to appeal directly to the state Supreme Court.

The challenge to the Predatory Debt Collection Protection Act is being weighed by a judge who heard arguments last week. The committee that backs the initiative turned in more than twice the nearly 238,000 signatures required for it to make the ballot, although a review to determine if that initiative and the other two filed enough to make the ballot is ongoing.

The challengers told Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Frank Moskowitz that part of the summary that specifically says that the measure “does not change existing law regarding secured debt” is inaccurate and that it should be blocked for that reason.

Attorney Kory Langhofer told the judge that a major part of the initiative increases the amount of equity of a home protected under the homeowner’s exemption, directly contradicting the part about secured debt not being affected.

Backers of the law say that is twisting the language and the public was told of the “Homestand Exemption” expansion.

“I just need more time to think about it,” Moskowitz said last week. “I think it can go both ways.”

The initiative, would raise homeowners’ homestead exemption from $150,000 to $400,000 and boost the value of autos and cash shielded from creditors and limits interest rates on medical debts.

Rodd McLeod, the spokesman for committee backing the measure, Healthcare Rising, said they believe they’ll win.

“We think these folks are afraid to face us on the ballot so they’re trying to play word games and use technical arguments to deny the people right to make their own choice,” McLeod said.

Amber Russo, spokeswoman for a group called Protect Our Arizona and president of a Tucson debt collection firm, said that the initiative could make it harder for average Arizonans to access credit if it passes.

“The same group of people that Healthcare Rising is trying to protect, they’re actually going to end up hurting them in the long run,” she said Monday.

The debt initiative is also being challenged based in allegedly deficient paperwork and registrations by petition circulators, as are other other two initiatives.

The Arizona Free Enterprise Club, which advocates for lower taxes, fewer regulations and limited government, is part of a coalition trying to kick the “Voters Right to Know” measure off the ballot. Scot Mussi, the group’s president, said it opposes the measure because it would require donors to his or any other nonprofit group that spends money on elections to be identified.

“The practical implications of it is that this information will be used to dox, harass and intimidate anyone for supporting various organizations,” Mussi said Monday. He pointed to a U.S. Supreme Court decision from last year that rejected California’s effort to have nonprofits identify their major donors.

Former Arizona Attorney General Terry Goddard, a Democrat who paired with Republican former Phoenix Mayor Paul Johnson to get the measure on the ballot, said the case Mussi points to is completely different than his measure requiring political spending to be made public.

And he said there are strong protections for people fearful of harassment and that people deserve to know who is behind political messages. This is their fourth try to qualify their “Outlaw Dirty Money” measure on the ballot.

“All I would say that that is that every voter in Arizona that gives more than $50 to a candidate has to disclose their name, their home address and their employer,” he added. “Why does the Free Enterprise Club think they’re any different?”

Mussi’s group also is suing to stop the measure that would block election law changes enacted by the Republican-controlled Legislature and expand access to voting.

“This ballot initiative is a 25-page measure that makes over 60 different changes to Arizona law,” Mussi said. “Many of these changes and radical reforms they are doing are not supported, and they are trying to sneak in their confusing measure and see if they can get it passed.”

Proponents argued that Mussi is himself trying to confuse voters, and that the there are no changes to voter ID laws and that its main focus is protecting election fairness.,

“The opposition is already trying to manipulate the process and the facts surrounding this measure,” said Stacy Pearson, a spokeswoman for Arizonans for Fair Elections.

“Ultimately, it keeps the Legislature from overturning the results of an election, installing electors fraudulently like they did in Arizona and hiring lunatics to audit the process.’

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

A girl posing with another girl and a boy holds a cellphone to take a selfie in what appears to be ...

Kevin Stone

Arizona Gov. Katie Hobbs vetoes school cellphone ban, says it’s unnecessary

Arizona Gov. Katie Hobbs vetoed a proposed student cellphone ban, saying "schools are already addressing" the issue.

25 minutes ago

Split image showing the mugshot of Annie Anderson on the left and a deputy frisking her while she p...

Kevin Stone

Suspect in ‘Baby Skylar’ case extradited to Phoenix to face murder charge in newborn’s death

A woman who allegedly left her newborn baby in a Phoenix airport garbage can in 2005 has been extradited to Arizona.

2 hours ago

Javier Lopez was taken into custody on April 12, 2024. He was wanted for questioning in an Arizona ...

Man wanted for questioning in Arizona homicide case taken into custody

A man wanted for questioning in an Arizona homicide case has been taken into custody, authorities said Friday.

2 hours ago

Split image with a mugshot of Donald Franklin Huegel on the left and a rose on the right. Huegel wa...

Kevin Stone

California man sentenced to 4 years for defrauding 2 elderly Arizona women in romance scams

A California man was recently sentenced to four years in prison for his role in romance scams that targeted two elderly Arizona women.

3 hours ago

Bridgework as part of the the Broadway Curve Improvement Project, which is remaking 11 miles of Int...

Kevin Stone

Drivers should watch for multiple freeway closures in metro Phoenix this weekend

Drivers should be on the lookout for multiple disruptive freeway closures in metro Phoenix this weekend.

4 hours ago


KTAR Video

Video: What do Americans currently agree on ahead of 2024 election?

Jim Sharpe reads a poll about what Americans agree on during his Sharper Point commentary. Video: Jeremy Schnell and Felisa Cárdenas/KTAR News

5 hours ago

Sponsored Articles


Fiesta Bowl Foundation

The 51st annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade is excitingly upon us

The 51st annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade presented by Lerner & Rowe is upon us! The attraction honors Arizona and the history of the game.

(KTAR News Graphic)...

Boys & Girls Clubs

KTAR launches online holiday auction benefitting Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley

KTAR is teaming up with The Boys & Girls Clubs of the Valley for a holiday auction benefitting thousands of Valley kids.


Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Valley residents should be mindful of plumbing ahead of holidays

With Halloween in the rear-view and more holidays coming up, Day & Night recommends that Valley residents prepare accordingly.

Battles rage in Arizona courts over 3 voter initiatives