Arizona House panel OKs major overhaul of K-12 funding

Mar 28, 2022, 8:05 PM
(Pexels Photo)...
(Pexels Photo)
(Pexels Photo)

PHOENIX (AP) — A major overhaul of large parts of Arizona’s K-12 school funding formula backed by a school choice group and the Republican leader of the House Education Committee got last-minute approval in the House Appropriations Committee on Thursday.

The party-line vote on the newly-revealed proposal drew major opposition from some school funding experts, some school districts and minority Democrats, who said rolling out large changes to the system that funds education for 1.1 million public school students at the last minute is a recipe for disaster.

Public charter schools would be major winners, while traditional district schools would see a mixed bag of funding increases and cuts, depending on their current funding situation.

The proposal was introduced as a “strike-everything” amendment to unrelated legislation, a maneuver often used for last-minute proposals that avoids multiple steps and public hearings.

The proposal from Republican Rep. Michelle Udall, who chairs the education committee and is running for Superintendent of Public Instruction, would eliminate the current results-based funding system that allocates extra money to district schools whose students perform well on standardized tests.

Also cut is extra cash that goes to experienced teachers and another pot of money that helps boost teacher pay. Charter schools do not get that extra money, so will see no cuts.

In exchange, the state will add $170 million per year to the basic funding formula for all schools, but distribute the money in a different way. The overhaul also changes how district schools are paid for running bus routes, increasing available funding by $120 million but eliminating extra funding that goes to some schools over five years.

All told, the state’s traditional district and charter schools would see an additional $215 million per year in money. This budget year, traditional district and charter schools are receiving $5.9 billion in state funding, by far the largest segment of the $12.9 billon budget.

A financial analysis showed 121 of the state’s more than 600 school districts would lose money under the plan.

District schools would have to give up the ability to ask voters to approve bonds and budget overrides that allow them to spend above set limits. Charter schools can’t do bonds or overrides.

Matt Simon, a vice president with the school choice advocacy group Great Leaders, Strong Schools, said the proposal is about equaling out funding for charter and district schools.

“This proposal is about strengthening what is already fair in our current system and provide a student-centered approach, eliminating formula components that aren’t fair, reinforcing our state’s commitment to expanding excellent schools and creating a glide path to a single formula,” Simon told the appropriations committee.

But Chuck Essigs, government relations director for the Arizona Association of School Business Officials and a top expert on the state’s complicated and decades-old school funding formula. said he see lots of issues with Udall’s proposal.

“School districts are facing the most difficult year that I can remember, with inflation running well above the 2% that’s in the formula, trying to make up the learning losses during Covid,” Essigs said. “The one additional problem they don’t need is trying to figure out how to balance their budget.”

He also noted that school funding task force Gov. Doug Ducey commissioned did not identify any of the items in Udall’s proposal as major to include in its 2016 report. Top issues instead were boosting special education funding and adding new funding to help low-income students succeed.

Kevin McCarthy, president of the Arizona Tax research Association, said years of efforts to reform the system have led nowhere and that Udall’s proposal will be a good start.

“If we can’t talk about doing this, we can’t talk about fixing school finance,” said Kevin McCarthy, president of the Arizona Tax Research Association, “Because this is a small bite of the apple.”

Udall said she’s held months of meetings with “stakeholders” to come up with her plan, which she said is still evolving.

“This is a huge step towards a more equitable school funding system where we pay the same amount for each child,” Udall said.

But Democrats said they first heard about it in recent weeks and only got the language of the 101 page bill and a financial impact analysis from the Legislature’s budget analysts last week.

Scott Thompson, an assistant superintendent at Mesa Public School, the largest district in Arizona, said school officials just learning details of the proposal are worried.

“A lot of confusion, a lot of misinformation, very difficult to deal with this in a ‘striker’ moment,” Thompson said, referring to the strike everything process. “We’re just asking for some kind of seat at the table at this point.”

Lifetime Windows & Doors

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

(Pexels Photo)...
Danny Shapiro

Phoenix temperatures expected to dip as Memorial Day weekend unfolds

After a toasty start, temperatures in metro Phoenix are expected to dip over the course of Memorial Day weekend, according to weather experts.
12 hours ago
(Pexels Photo)...

Maricopa County approves additional $35M for affordable housing units

The Maricopa County Board of Supervisors this week approved another $35 million in federal relief funding to develop more affordable housing units in the area. 
12 hours ago
Firearms on display at the Legendary Guns store in Phoenix in 2018. (File photo by Daria Kadovik/Cr...
Neetish Basnet | Cronkite News

Arizona gun sales expected to surge, again, after mass shootings

Gun sales in Arizona have surged in recent years and experts say they could jump again after recent mass shootings.
12 hours ago
A man is in custody after more than 1,200 catalytic converters were recovered from a storage unit i...

Man arrested after 1,200 catalytic converters found in Phoenix storage unit

A man was arrested Thursday after police recovered over 1,200 catalytic converters in a Phoenix storage unit.
12 hours ago
(Facebook File Photo/Lake Pleasant Regional Park...
Luke Forstner

Valley expert shares lake safety tips for Memorial Day weekend

People looking to cool off at a lake this Memorial Day weekend are asked to do so safely after a string of drownings.
12 hours ago
VR equipment and a version of the TASER 7 that utilizes VR technology for training, is demonstrated...
Taylor Tasler

Phoenix Police use virtual reality headsets to train for calls in the field

The Phoenix Police Department is one of the first law enforcement agencies in the country to use virtual reality to provide officers training in the field. 
12 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

Carla Berg, MHS, Deputy Director, Public Health Services, Arizona Department of Health Services

Update your child’s vaccines before kindergarten

So, your little one starts kindergarten soon. How exciting! You still have a few months before the school year starts, so now’s the time to make sure students-to-be have the vaccines needed to stay safe as they head into a new chapter of life.
Christina O’Haver

Stroke month: Experts call attention to stroke prevention

Every 40 seconds—that’s how often someone has a stroke in the United States. It’s the fifth leading cause of death among Americans, with someone dying of a stroke every 3.5 minutes.
Canvas Annuity

The secret to guaranteed retirement income

Annuities aren’t really a secret, but they are so misunderstood that they might as well be. Once you understand what an annuity is and how it can benefit you, you could decide this “secret” is the perfect supplement to your retirement plan.
Arizona House panel OKs major overhaul of K-12 funding