State Supreme Court: ‘Civil death’ law is unconstitutional

Mar 2, 2022, 2:19 PM | Updated: 2:22 pm

An archaic Rhode Island law that says prison inmates serving life sentences are considered civilly dead in terms of their civil rights is unconstitutional, the state Supreme Court ruled in a landmark decision released Wednesday.

The 1909 law says inmates serving a life term at the state prison, the Adult Correctional Institutions, are deemed dead “with respect to property rights, the bond of matrimony and other civil rights, ” as if they had actually died when convicted.

The court in a 4-1 ruling said the statute denies inmates of a fundamental right.

“The civil death statute deprives those persons imprisoned at the ACI for life of their right to bring civil actions in our state courts,” the majority opinion written by Justice Erin Lynch-Prata said. “It is clear to us that the right infringed upon by the civil death statute is the right to seek redress for any type of injury or complaint, thereby unconstitutionally denying the plaintiffs the very right to gain access to the courts.”

The challenge to the law was brought by inmates Cody-Allen Zab and Jose Rivera, represented by attorney Sonja Deyoe, and backed the American Civil Liberties Union of Rhode Island. The ACLU said it believes Rhode Island is the only state still enforcing such a law.

“Today’s decision from the court affirms the basic principle of our judicial system that the doors to justice shall remain open to all,” Deyoe said in a statement.

Deyoe, who has spent nearly a decade challenging the law, said in a telephone interview she cried for the first time in years when she read the opinion.

“The very basis of our system is the ability to go to court to challenge the government,” she said.

Zab was sentenced to life in prison after pleading guilty to first-degree murder and arson. Rivera received a life sentence plus 16 years after he was convicted of sexually assaulting three developmentally disabled women.

They both sued the Department of Correction in 2017, alleging they suffered injuries while behind bars due to the department’s negligence. Zab alleged that he suffered a severe burn and permanent disfigurement on his arm when he made contact with an exposed hot water pipe located adjacent to telephones used by inmates.

Rivera claimed he broke his ankle when he slipped on an untreated icy walkway after being ordered by prison employees.

A Superior Court judge concluded that the civil death statute barred their claims, so they appealed to the high court.

The Department of Corrections maintained that the law was constitutional, furthering the goals of punishment and deterrence.

“Above all, we are charged with the safety and security of those under our custody, and just like with any other decision, we respect and follow the ruling of the Court, and the State’s legislative mandates,” J.R. Ventura, a spokesperson for the department said in a statement.

Justice Maureen McKenna Goldberg wrote the dissenting opinion, saying changing the civil death law should be up to the state legislature, not the court.

Another Rhode Island inmate went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court to challenge the law, but the court in March 2020 declined to hear the case

It was not the first time the law had come up in a case involving Zab. The state Supreme Court in 2019 rejected an appeal from Zab who asked for his marriage record to be sealed because he’s considered dead under state law.

He argued his record should be expunged because as someone considered “civilly dead” he can’t get married. The court ruled that he has no right to litigate this issue.

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Associated Press

Three Chinese corporate giants leaving NY stock exchange

BEIJING (AP) — Three state-owned Chinese corporate giants announced plans Friday to remove their shares from the New York Stock Exchange amid a dispute between Washington and Beijing over whether U.S. regulators can see records of their auditors. PetroChina Ltd., China Life Insurance Ltd. and China Petroleum & Chemical Co. cited the small trading volume […]
4 hours ago
U.S. and Indonesian soldiers take their positions during Super Garuda Shield 2022 joint military ex...
Associated Press

US, Indonesia, Australia hold drills amid China concerns

BATURAJA, Indonesia (AP) — Soldiers from the U.S., Indonesia and Australia joined a live-fire drill on Friday, part of annual joint combat exercises on Sumatra island amid growing Chinese maritime activity in the Indo-Pacific region. A total of more than 5,000 personnel from the U.S., Indonesia, Australia, Japan and Singapore are participating in this year’s […]
4 hours ago
FILE - Travelers wait in long lines to check in and board flights at Amsterdam's Schiphol Airport, ...
Associated Press

Amsterdam’s Schiphol compensating air travelers hit by chaos

THE HAGUE, Netherlands (AP) — Amsterdam’s Schiphol Airport has launched a compensation program for travelers who missed their flights because of lengthy delays that have plagued the busy European hub for months. Schiphol’s announcement Thursday night heads off a possible mass claim for compensation by passengers who saw their holiday plans evaporate amid hourslong queues […]
4 hours ago
German Health Minister Karl Lauterbach arrives for a press conference in Berlin, Germany, Friday, A...
Associated Press

Germany: EU could OK combined COVID vaccines next month

BERLIN (AP) — Germany’s health minister said Friday that European Union drug regulators may authorize the use of vaccines that are each effective against two variants of the coronavirus. German Health Minister Karl Lauterbach said he expected the European Medicines Agency to meet Sept. 1 to consider a vaccine that would provide protection against the […]
4 hours ago
Russian Ambassador to the United Nations Vasily Nebenzya, center, speaks to reporters after a Secur...
Associated Press

Grain ship to dock in Ukraine, leave for Africa

KYIV, Ukraine (AP) — Expectations were raised Friday that the first U.N. grain transport ship could soon be leaving Ukraine for Africa, while more Russian shelling struck the east of the country — shifting the war between hope and despair on Friday. Closing in on the half-year mark, the war has sent food prices sky-high […]
4 hours ago
Shoppers walks through London's biggest shopping street, Oxford Street, in London, Thursday, Aug. 4...
Associated Press

UK economy shrinks in 2nd quarter, sharpening recession fear

LONDON (AP) — The United Kingdom’s economy shrank in the three months to June, figures released Friday showed — a smaller-than-expected contraction that nevertheless added to jitters about the rocky months ahead. The Office for National Statistics said Britain’s gross domestic product fell by 0.1% between April and June, down from 0.8% growth in the […]
4 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

Dr. Richard Carmona

Great news: Children under 5 can now get COVID-19 vaccine

After more than two years of battle with an invisible killer, we can now vaccinate the youngest among us against COVID-19. This is great news.
Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Most plumbing problems can be fixed with regular maintenance

Instead of waiting for a problem to happen, experts suggest getting a head start on your plumbing maintenance.

Best retirement savings rates hit 4.30%

Maximize your retirement savings with guaranteed fixed rates up to 4.30%. Did you know there is a financial product that can give you great interest rates as you build your retirement savings and provide you with a paycheck for life once you retire? It might sound too good to be true but it is not; this product is called an annuity.
State Supreme Court: ‘Civil death’ law is unconstitutional