ARIZONA NEWS

Judge sides with Flagstaff in minimum wage fight with the state

Oct 11, 2021, 5:00 PM
(Pexels photo)...
(Pexels photo)
(Pexels photo)

PHOENIX (AP) — A judge has blocked Arizona from collecting $1.1 million from the city of Flagstaff to compensate for its minimum wage that is higher than the state’s rate, ruling that the state missed a deadline for the assessment and was stretching a law targeting higher voter-approved city wages to collect its indirect costs.

But the ruling from Maricopa County Superior Court Judge James Smith released on Monday sidestepped the question of whether the assessments are unconstitutional.

The state minimum wage reached $12 an hour in 2020 with inflation adjustments after that and now stands at $12.15 an hour. Flagstaff voters in 2016 phased in higher city minimum wages, which hit $15 per hour this year with annual increases thereafter.

Smith’s ruling said a law enacted by the Republican-controlled Legislature in 2019 targeting higher city minimum wages set a July 31 deadline for setting the yearly assessment. The state missed that deadline.

The judge also said the state can’t charge for the indirect costs of Flagstaff’s higher minimum wage, which is what it did in coming up with the $1.1 million figure. The state is specifically exempt from paying the higher minimum wage the city’s voters approved in 2016, and the law authorizing assessments does not specifically say the state can calculate the indirect costs of paying contractors.

“When the Legislature wants to capture direct and indirect costs/expenditures, it uses those words,” Smith wrote. “It would be unusual to interpret the words’ absence from (the 2019 law) as also capturing direct and indirect costs/expenditures.”

Attorneys for the city Flagstaff had argued that the Voter Protection Act barred the state from penalizing cities for their higher minimum wages because they are specifically authorized by a 2006 voter initiative.

But they also said the judge could rule in the city’s favor if he found the state missed the deadline or wasn’t authorized to collect for higher indirect costs.

When Smith ruled for the city on the deadline and indirect costs issues, he was able to avoid deciding whether the assessment was unconstitutional. He wrote that judges generally prefer to sidestep such constitutional questions if they can.

But he warned that if he accepted the state’s argument that its undefined indirect costs for higher pay for contractors and other expenses, it could trigger the Voter Protection Act. That constitutional provision bars the Legislature from changing voter approved laws.

“That is difficult to reconcile with Proposition 202, which allowed municipalities to set higher minimum wages,” he wrote. “The State’s interpretation would let municipalities do so only if they agreed to pay assessments that they cannot contest and that may have only the foggiest connection to the minimum wage.

“That could be repugnancy that the VPA prohibits,” the ruling said.

Republican Gov, Doug Ducey signed the assessment law and the 2021 budget bill that levied the $1.1 million fee. His spokesman, C.J. Karamargin, said his office had no immediate comment on the ruling. A spokeswoman for Attorney General Mark Brnovich, who defended the case, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The state could appeal the preliminary injunction prohibiting the assessment collection. Or the Legislature could come back next year and pass a new law changing the deadlines and specifically allowing the collection of indirect costs.

But the ruling puts it in a conundrum, said Roopali Desai, Flagstaff’s attorney, especially because calculating indirect costs is a complex process and because of Smith’s concern over it violating the constitution.

“Our hope is that they realize that no matter which way they go about doing this, it’s going to be a problem and violates the law,” Desaid said.

The state assessment was based on a review of higher costs by state agencies. They looked at prices contractors charge for services like home health aides who help the developmentally disabled are paid through the state social services agency, the Department of Economic Security.

Arizona voters first passed a state minimum wage law in 2006 and raised rates again in 2016. In the 2006 initiative voters allowed cities to set higher rates.

Tucson voters are scheduled to consider their own higher minimum wage in November. Monday’s ruling removes, at least for now, the argument that the city may face higher costs if it passes its own higher wage law.

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

(Getty Images Photo/Roberto Machado Noa)...
KTAR.com

Police investigate death of 45-year-old woman shot in Phoenix

Police are investigating the death of a woman who died from a gunshot wound in Phoenix Friday night.
16 hours ago
FILE - In this Wednesday, May 27, 2020 file photo, Medical personnel adjust their personal protecti...
KTAR.com

Arizona reports 2,482 new COVID-19 cases, 9 more deaths Saturday

Arizona health officials on Saturday reported 2,482 new COVID-19 cases and nine additional deaths from the disease.
16 hours ago
(Facebook Photo/Phoenix Police Department)...
KTAR.com

Woman dies after being struck by vehicle in Phoenix

An adult woman was killed after getting struck by a vehicle near the intersection of East McDowell Road and North 26th Street in Phoenix on Friday night.
16 hours ago
(Facebook photo/City of Phoenix, AZ USA)...
KTAR.com

Phoenix adopts roadmap to cut emissions, reach net-zero goal by 2050

The city of Phoenix Tuesday approved a climate action plan with the goal of reaching net-zero by 2050 while also reducing 50% of emissions by 2030. 
16 hours ago
(Facebook photo/Special Olympics Arizona)...
KTAR.com

Special Olympics Arizona to kick off fall games next weekend

More than 1,000 Special Olympics athletes across the state will head to the Valley next weekend to compete in the 2021 Fall Games presented by Casino Arizona.
16 hours ago
(Facebook photo/Holiday Light Experience - Salt River Fields)...
KTAR.com

Tickets for Holiday Light Experience at Salt River Fields go on sale

People can begin buying their tickets now to the Holiday Light Experience at Salt River Fields in Scottsdale which is set to get underway in November.
16 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...
PNC Bank

3 cool tips to turn everyday moments into learning experiences for your child

Early brain development has a crucial impact on a child’s ability to learn and succeed in school and life. Research has shown that 90% of a child’s brain is developed by age five.
...
Sweet James

Best fall road trips to take on a motorcycle

Autumn in Arizona brings the beauty of color-changing leaves and a relief from summer heat. It’s one of the most pleasant times to explore the outdoors, especially on a motorcycle.
...
Chris Kennedy

My Special Aflac Duck® taking flight in Arizona

For more than 65 years, Aflac has had the extraordinary opportunity and privilege to help provide peace of mind to individuals who have our supplemental insurance policies.
Judge sides with Flagstaff in minimum wage fight with the state