Judge: Gov. Lee’s mask opt-out can endanger disabled kids

Sep 17, 2021, 10:10 AM | Updated: 3:53 pm

MEMPHIS, Tenn. (AP) — A federal judge has indefinitely blocked Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee from allowing parents to opt out of school mask requirements in Shelby County, saying Friday that evidence shows Lee’s order prevents children with health problems from safely going to school during the coronavirus pandemic.

U.S. District Judge Sheryl Lipman issued the preliminary injunction after parents of students with health conditions argued that the Republican governor’s executive order endangered their children and hurt their ability to attend in-person classes by allowing others to opt-out of a mask mandate.

“It is that unmasked presence that creates the danger to these Plaintiffs,” the judge wrote Friday.

Meanwhile, two families in Williamson County, just south of Nashville, sued in federal court Friday, also challenging Lee’s order, news outlets reported.

In Shelby County, Lipman had already issued a temporary restraining order on Sept. 3 stopping schools from allowing parents to opt-out. It was set to expire Friday. The preliminary injunction continues blocking Lee’s order as the federal lawsuit proceeds.

“Plaintiffs offered sufficient evidence at this stage to demonstrate that the Executive Order interferes with Plaintiffs’ ability to safely access their schools,” the judge wrote.

The injunction applies to all seven public school districts in Shelby County, which began classes Aug. 9 under a universal mask requirement issued by the Shelby County Health Department. Shelby County Schools includes Memphis and is Tennessee’s largest school system, with 100,000 students. Six other districts serve the suburbs of Arlington, Bartlett, Collierville, Germantown, Lakeland and Millington.

The parents’ lawsuit claims Lee’s order violates the Americans with Disabilities Act, which prohibits the exclusion of students with disabilities from public educational programs and activities. Children with certain disabilities are more vulnerable to serious illness or death if they get COVID-19, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has said.

Lee has resisted implementing a statewide mask mandate for schools, and he initially left the decision to local officials before signing an order on Aug. 16 allowing parents to opt their children out for nonmedical reasons. Many students have been attending classes without masks ever since.

Local decision-making is important, but “individual decision-making by a parent on issues regarding the health and well-being of their child is the most important,” Lee said then.

The lawsuit, which seeks class-action status, cites three students in Collierville and Germantown.

Emily Tremel testified that her 11-year-old daughter suffers from a chromosomal abnormality that can cause an intense loss of balance and coordination, and has trouble with online learning. But being surrounded in a classroom by unmasked children is dangerous for her — in fact, she tested positive a week after Lee’s order, following her exposure to a maskless student who got COVID-19, Tremel said.

“The Governor has put the parents of medically vulnerable students in the position of having to decide whether to keep their children at home where they will likely suffer continued learning loss or risk placing them in an environment that presents a serious risk to their health and safety,” the lawsuit states.

Public health agencies say indoor mask-wearing is a key coronavirus-prevention tool. The CDC says masks don’t pose health risks for children older than toddlers, and recommends them for schools since vaccines still aren’t authorized for children younger than than 12.

COVID-19 cases in children have risen significantly during the surge that coincided with the start of the current school year, making it difficult for some Tennessee school districts to provide in-person education. Some schools have closed classrooms, while others have temporarily switched to virtual learning as students are forced to quarantine or isolate.

The Tennessee attorney general’s office has argued that the parents could have sought other relief individually instead of filing a federal lawsuit, a point attorney Jim Newsom sought to make before the judge.

Newsom questioned parents about whether they sought help from the state education department with their children’s Individualized Education Programs, which address the instructional needs of students with health conditions. He also argued that schools can adjust to the needs of vulnerable students by changing schedules so that they can avoid unmasked people in hallways.

The judge said during a Sept. 9 court hearing that universal masking may be more cost-efficient than measures such as moving classrooms or adjusting schedules.

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

AP

In this photo taken by a drone, boats lie scattered amidst mobile homes after the passage of Hurric...
Associated Press

Live Updates: Strong winds in SC ahead of Hurricane Ian

The Latest on Hurricane Ian: CHARLESTON, S.C. — Strong winds were blowing early Friday morning in Charleston, South Carolina, with powerful gusts bending tree branches and sending sprays of the steadily falling rain sideways as Hurricane Ian approached. Streets were largely empty, an ordinarily packed morning commute silenced by the advancing storm. Flash flood warnings […]
5 hours ago
Marina Aina, a 21-year-old student majoring in American Studies at Pomona College, poses for photos...
Associated Press

Unpaid internships face new scrutiny as barriers to careers

The value of an internship is unmistakable. It teaches marketable skills, it builds professional networks, and it helps students test-drive careers. But the benefits are not available to all: Close to half of all internships are unpaid, putting them out of reach for students who need wages to keep up with their bills, even if […]
5 hours ago
FILE - Visitors look at cars produced by Geely at the Auto China 2020 show in Beijing on Sept. 27, ...
Associated Press

China’s Geely buys 7.6% stake in Aston Martin Lagonda

BEIJING (AP) — Geely Holding Group, one of China’s biggest independent automakers, has bought a 7.6% stake in British luxury brand Aston Martin Lagonda and said Friday it looks forward to potential opportunities to collaborate. Geely declined to give details, but Aston Martin Lagonda announced Friday it raised 654 million pounds ($730 million) from investors […]
5 hours ago
In this photo provided by the Armed Forces of Denmark, the crew in a helicopter of the Armed Forces...
Associated Press

Swedes don’t know if pipeline ruptures damaged power cable

COPENHAGEN, Denmark (AP) — Swedish officials do not yet know if an undersea power cable that runs between southern Sweden and Poland was damaged when the Nord Stream gas pipelines some 500 meters (547 yards) away ruptured from what Western and Russian officials both claimed was intentional tampering. “Since the cable is not in service, […]
5 hours ago
FILE - The TikTok app logo appears in Tokyo on Sept. 28, 2020. TikTok may be the platform of choice...
Associated Press

TikTok politics: Candidates turn to it ‘for better or worse’

Wade Herring didn’t know the teenage voter who approached him at a restaurant over the weekend. But she knew Herring, a Democrat running for Congress in Georgia, from his campaign videos on TikTok. To Herring, a 63-year-old Savannah attorney, it was proof of TikTok’s precision-guided ability to reach young voters — the very reason why […]
5 hours ago
FILE - Medical staff prepare syringes with vaccination against the coronavirus and the COVID-19 dis...
Associated Press

Germany warns of rise in COVID-19 cases going into fall

BERLIN (AP) — Germany’s health minister warned Friday that the country is seeing a steady rise in COVID-19 cases as it goes into the fall, and urged older people to get a second booster shot tweaked to protect against new variants. Other European countries such as France, Denmark and the Netherlands are also recording an […]
5 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...
Quantum Fiber

How high-speed fiber internet can improve everyday life

Quantum Fiber supplies unlimited data with speeds up to 940 mbps, enough to share 4K videos with coworkers 20 times faster than a cable.
...
Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Ways to prevent clogged drains and what to do if you’re too late

While there are a variety of ways to prevent clogged drains, it's equally as important to know what to do when you're already too late.
...
Dr. Richard Carmona

Great news: Children under 5 can now get COVID-19 vaccine

After more than two years of battle with an invisible killer, we can now vaccinate the youngest among us against COVID-19. This is great news.
Judge: Gov. Lee’s mask opt-out can endanger disabled kids