Ala judge: Death row inmate got ‘raw deal’ in murder trial

May 30, 2015, 7:30 AM
FILE - In this undated file photo provided by the Alabama Department of Corrections shows death row inmate Donnis Musgrove. Musgrove, who been on death row for 27 years but says he is innocent, is asking a federal judge to overturn his case. Jefferson County Circuit Judge Tommy Nail says he believes Donnis George Musgrove and another man were wrongly convicted of capital murder in 1988, and he hopes a federal court now reviewing Musgrove's appeal corrects the error. (Alabama Department of Corrections via AP, file)
(Alabama Department of Corrections via AP, file)

BIRMINGHAM, Ala. (AP) — An Alabama inmate who has spent almost 30 years on death row for a murder he denies committing has an unusual supporter in his bid for freedom: A state judge who once represented the man’s co-defendant while working as a defense lawyer.

Jefferson County Circuit Judge Tommy Nail told The Associated Press in an interview this week he believes Donnis George Musgrove and another man were wrongly convicted of capital murder in 1988, and he hopes a federal court now reviewing Musgrove’s appeal corrects the error.

“I really think they got a raw deal and I’ve always felt they were not guilty of this offense,” Nail said during an interview in his office.

A judge since 1999, Nail represented David Rogers when Rogers and Musgrove were convicted in the 1986 gunshot killing of Coy Eugene Barron. Both men received the death sentence.

Rogers and Musgrove were best friends and career car thieves, Nail said, but both always denied having any role in Barron’s shooting.

Nail said he believed their claims of innocence then and still believes them today, particularly after learning of “eerie” similarities between their trial and the case of Anthony Ray Hinton, another Alabama death row inmate who was freed recently after proclaiming his innocence for years.

The same judge, prosecutor and forensic expert were involved in the cases against Musgrove and Rogers and Hinton, he said. Each case also involved questionable weapons analysis, defendants with solid alibis and allegations of prosecutorial overreach, he said.

“I would hope somebody would see all of these things and try to correct these things,” Nail said. “But it’s a very tough process.”

Rogers died of natural causes on death row, but Musgrove, 66, is currently asking a federal judge in Birmingham to overturn his conviction and death sentence. He has been on death row for 28 years.

Prosecutors haven’t filed written responses to Musgrove’s claims, and Attorney General Luther Strange’s office declined comment on Nail’s remarks. But the state has defended the conviction since Musgrove’s earliest appeals.

A federal judge has given prosecutors until June 8 to respond to Musgrove’s arguments that he was wrongly convicted.

Barron was shot to death on Sept. 27, 1986. Prosecutors said two men entered his home in the middle of the night and opened fire.

The state’s main witness, Barron’s wife Libby, initially told police she couldn’t identify the killers from the darkened home, and at first she failed to select Rogers and Musgrove out of a lineup, Nail said. She even wrongly identified two plainclothes police officers as the killers, Nail said.

“Then, 10 minutes later when the detective talks to her, they bring her back and she positively IDs both of them,” said Nail, calling the identification “shaky.”

Forensic evidence also was important in the trial.

Prosecutors said a 9 mm shell casing found at the scene of Barron’s slaying was linked to a pistol Musgrove used in an assault three months earlier. But later testing showed that the shell casing found at the murder scene was planted and not linked to the crime at all, Musgrove’s current attorneys contend.

Jurors heard from a supposed jailhouse informant who claimed Rogers told him about Barron’s killing and implicated Musgrove, but the informant later recanted and said he’d been put up to the testimony by police and the late Bob McGregor, an assistant district attorney who also prosecuted Hinton.

Given all the questions, Musgrove’s federal petition “raises a pretty strong presumption” of innocence, Nail said.

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

United States News

Keanu Reeves, the star of "John Wick: Chapter 4," wears a blue ribbon on his lapel in tribute to hi...
Associated Press

‘John Wick’ stars honor late co-star Lance Reddick

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Keanu Reeves and Laurence Fishburne were among the died unexpectedly last week, at the film’s Los Angeles premiere. “We lost our brother, and in a really sort of very shocking way. I think we’re all still in shock. “Life is,” the visibly-shaken Fishburne said, pausing briefly before continuing, “hard sometimes.” Many […]
1 day ago
FILE - Gwyneth Paltrow arrives at the 26th annual ELLE Women in Hollywood Celebration at the Four S...
Associated Press

Gwyneth Paltrow to stand trial for Deer Valley ski crash

PARK CITY, Utah (AP) — Gwyneth Paltrow is scheduled to stand trial on Tuesday in a lawsuit filed by a retired optometrist who said that the actress-turned-lifestyle influencer violently crashed into him in 2016 while skiing in Utah at one of the most upscale ski resorts in the United States. Terry Sanderson, 76, said Paltrow […]
1 day ago
Indiana's Mackenzie Holmes (54) shoots against Miami's Kyla Oldacre (44) during the first half of a...
Associated Press

Miami shocks top-seed Indiana in March Madness

BLOOMINGTON, Ind. (AP) — Destiny Harden made a shot in the lane with 3.5 seconds left to send ninth-seeded Miami past top-seeded Indiana 70-68 on Monday night, lifting the Hurricanes to their first Sweet 16 since 1992. The Hoosiers (28-4) became the second No. 1 seed to be eliminated in two nights. Stanford was upset […]
1 day ago
(AP Photo/Bernat Armangue)...
Associated Press

World on ‘thin ice’ as UN climate report gives strong warning

Humanity still has a chance to prevent the worst of climate change’s future harms, a top United Nations panel of scientists said Monday.
1 day ago
Sylvia Garcia, from Bassett Street Elementary, talks as she and other teachers attend a Los Angeles...
Associated Press

Los Angeles schools to close as district workers plan strike

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Tens of thousands of workers in the Los Angeles Unified School District planned to walk off the job Tuesday over stalled contract talks, and they will be joined in solidarity by teachers in a three-day strike that will shut down the nation’s second-largest school system. Demonstrations are expected at schools across […]
1 day ago
FILE - The Tennessee state Capitol in Nashville, Tenn., is shown on Jan. 8, 2020. Tennessee Republi...
Associated Press

Tennessee House OKs narrow abortion exemption bill

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — Tennessee’s GOP-dominant House on Monday advanced legislation that would add a narrow exemption to the state’s strict abortion ban, despite concerns raised by Democrats and medical experts that the bill does not go far enough to protect doctors and pregnant patients. The legislation was drastically reworked from its original version that […]
1 day ago

Sponsored Articles

Quantum Fiber

How high-speed fiber internet edges out cable for everyday use

In a world where technology drives so much of our daily lives, a lack of high-speed internet can be a major issue.
Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Prep the plumbing in your home just in time for the holidays

With the holidays approaching, it's important to know when your home is in need of heating and plumbing updates before more guests start to come around.
Quantum Fiber

Stream 4K and more with powerful, high-speed fiber internet

Picking which streaming services to subscribe to are difficult choices, and there is no room for internet that cannot handle increased demands.
Ala judge: Death row inmate got ‘raw deal’ in murder trial