School mask mandate ban challenged in new Utah lawsuit

Aug 23, 2021, 12:55 PM | Updated: 1:42 pm
Stefanie Plothow home schools her children Cameron, 9, in the 3rd grade, and Ainsley, 5, in kinderg...

Stefanie Plothow home schools her children Cameron, 9, in the 3rd grade, and Ainsley, 5, in kindergarten, Friday, Aug. 20, 2021, in Lehi, Utah. A group of Utah parents is suing the state over a law that bans school districts from approving mask mandates. It's the latest U.S. legal challenge over rules for face coverings in the classroom. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)

(AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)

SALT LAKE CITY (AP) — A ban on school districts requiring masks is forcing parents of vulnerable kids to wrestle with the painful choice of whether to risk coronavirus infections at school or keep them at home yet again, according to a lawsuit filed Monday in Utah.

Parents like Jessica Pyper say a Utah law that blocks districts from passing mandates wrongly prevents children from getting a safe education. She wants her 10-year-old son Ryker to join his fifth grade classmates this year, but his Type 1 diabetes puts him at serious risk.

“It just sort of seems like nobody cares,” she said. “Kids with disabilities often get left behind. They don’t get considered when these types of decisions are being made.”

The case filed by a group of nine parents is the latest U.S. lawsuit of its kind from families and educators concerned about school without masks as the highly contagious delta variant surges. Similar cases have been filed in Arizona, Texas and Florida, where thousands of students have already been sent home in rapidly spreading outbreaks.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention guidelines call for universal masking in schools, but amid contentious anti-mask protests, several conservative-leaning states are blocking mask mandates.

Officials, mostly Republican, contend that there are downsides to kids being masked all day and parents should have the power to decide whether to put them on children, who tend to be less vulnerable to the virus than older adults.

The lawsuit was filed against Republican Utah Gov. Spencer Cox, whose office didn’t immediately respond to messages requesting comment, and Republican Attorney General Sean Reyes, who declined comment.

Utah schools were open for in-person learning with a statewide mask mandate last year, but after the mandate ended the GOP-dominated Legislature decided individual school districts couldn’t require face coverings on their own.

Without masks and other protective steps, coronavirus infections could spread rapidly among kids who are too young to get vaccinated and could bring it home to their families, experts have said. Masks are an effective tool against the spread of the coronavirus, but work best when everyone uses them, research has found.

Even as the delta variant has surged in Utah, filling hospitals beyond capacity, just one small school district has navigated the legal hurdles to require masks in the southern Utah tourist mecca of Grand County. An attempt to require masks in Salt Lake County was overturned by the Republican-controlled county council.

Many schools are encouraging students to wear masks, though, and in some parts of the state many are doing so.

But in Brad Plothow’s conservative community of Lehi, south of Salt Lake City, few students except his own children have been wearing them in the classroom, he said. He and his wife home-schooled all four of their children last year, but his older children especially missed their friends and pined for school milestones like getting lockers for the first time.

So they sent their older children to school, both wearing masks. They installed air purifiers and filters at home in hopes of protecting their younger children, one of whom has fairly severe asthma.

Plothow said it was frustrating to watch state leaders abandon steps he said largely worked to keep schools open and safe last year.

“We’re not activists, we’re not political, we’re not partisan … where we draw the line is when you mess around with the kids,” he said. “This should not be a political football.”

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


              Brad and Stefanie Plothow home school their children Cameron, 9, in the 3rd grade, and Ainsley, 5, in kindergarten, Friday, Aug. 20, 2021, in Lehi, Utah. A group of Utah parents is suing the state over a law that bans school districts from approving mask mandates. It's the latest U.S. legal challenge over rules for face coverings in the classroom. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)
            
              Stefanie Plothow home schools her children Cameron, 9, in the 3rd grade, and Ainsley, 5, in kindergarten, Friday, Aug. 20, 2021, in Lehi, Utah. A group of Utah parents is suing the state over a law that bans school districts from approving mask mandates. It's the latest U.S. legal challenge over rules for face coverings in the classroom. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)
            Brad and Stefanie Plothow look on as their children, Cameron, 9, in the 3rd grade, and Ainsley, 5, in kindergarten, are seen in the background, during home schooling, Friday, Aug. 20, 2021, in Lehi, Utah. A group of Utah parents is suing the state over a law that bans school districts from approving mask mandates. It's the latest U.S. legal challenge over rules for face coverings in the classroom. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer) Stefanie Plothow home schools her children Cameron, 9, in the 3rd grade, and Ainsley, 5, in kindergarten, Friday, Aug. 20, 2021, in Lehi, Utah. A group of Utah parents is suing the state over a law that bans school districts from approving mask mandates. It's the latest U.S. legal challenge over rules for face coverings in the classroom. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer) Stefanie Plothow home schools her children Cameron, 9, in the 3rd grade, and Ainsley, 5, in kindergarten, Friday, Aug. 20, 2021, in Lehi, Utah. A group of Utah parents is suing the state over a law that bans school districts from approving mask mandates. It's the latest U.S. legal challenge over rules for face coverings in the classroom. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer) Jessica Pyper poses for a photograph with her children Ryker, 10, and Sage, 3, on Friday, Aug. 20, 2021, in West Jordan, Utah. A group of Utah parents is suing the state over a law that bans school districts from approving mask mandates. It's the latest U.S. legal challenge over rules for face coverings in the classroom. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)

AP

Associated Press

Judge dismisses lawsuit over US utility’s long-term deals

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit by environmental groups that challenged how the nation’s largest public utility signs up local power providers for two-decade contracts. On Wednesday, a ruling by U.S. District Judge Thomas L. Parker in Memphis sided with the Tennessee Valley Authority, agreeing that the environmental groups don’t […]
18 hours ago
Associated Press

Authorities: Woman sent to Iowa funeral home was alive

A continuing care home in suburban Des Moines, Iowa, has been fined $10,000 after a funeral home discovered a woman sent to it in a body bag was still alive. The Iowa Department of Inspection and Appeals said in a report filed Wednesday that the 66-year-old woman was declared dead at the Glen Oaks Alzheimer’s […]
18 hours ago
Associated Press

Kohl’s names Tom Kingsbury as permanent CEO

NEW YORK (AP) — Kohl’s said Thursday it has named acting CEO Tom Kingsbury as its permanent leader. Kingsbury, a Kohl’s board member with more than 40 years experience in retail, has served as an interim CEO since early December, when Michelle Gass left the department store chain to become president of jeans maker Levi […]
18 hours ago
CORRECTS THAT PLANTS ARE FORMERLY OWNED BY FIRSTENERGY -  Former Ohio House Speaker Larry Household...
Associated Press

‘Boom’: FirstEnergy exec text revels in landing state plane

CINCINNATI (AP) — New details emerged Thursday at the trial of former Ohio House Speaker Larry Householder on the use of the state plane scheduled to bring state lawmakers back to Columbus to vote on the now-tainted nuclear bailout legislation at the heart of Ohio’s largest ever corruption case. Text messages presented to jurors in […]
18 hours ago
FILE - Republican Gov. Tate Reeves outlines his priorities during his State of the State address on...
Associated Press

Doctor, GOP governor clash over private Medicaid discussion

JACKSON, Miss. (AP) — Mississippi’s Republican Gov. Tate Reeves said in a private conversation that expanding Medicaid to people working low-wage jobs would be in the best interest of the state, but that he refuses to support the policy for political reasons, a former chancellor of the University of Mississippi said Thursday. Dr. Dan Jones […]
18 hours ago
FILE - This Wednesday, July 24, 2019 photo shows an Apple Store in Chicago is seen. Apple reports f...
Associated Press

Apple suffers 1st quarterly sales decline in nearly 4 years

Apple on Thursday posted its first quarterly revenue drop in nearly four years after pandemic-driven restrictions on its China factories curtailed sales of the latest iPhone during the holiday season. The company’s sales of $117 billion for the October-December period represented a 5% decline from the same time in the previous year, a deeper downturn […]
18 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...
Fiesta Bowl Foundation

Celebrate 50 years of Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade magic!

Since its first production in the early 1970s, the Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade presented by Lerner & Rowe has been a staple of Valley traditions, bringing family fun and excitement to downtown Phoenix.
(Desert Institute for Spine Care photo)...
DESERT INSTITUTE FOR SPINE CARE

Why DISC is world renowned for back and neck pain treatments

Fifty percent of Americans and 90% of people at least 50 years old have some level of degenerative disc disease.
(Photo via MLB's Arizona Fall League / Twitter)...
Arizona Fall League

Top prospects to watch at this year’s Arizona Fall League

One of the most exciting elements of the MLB offseason is the Arizona Fall League, which began its 30th season Monday.
School mask mandate ban challenged in new Utah lawsuit