Judge rejects 1 of many challenges to voter-approved Prop 208 tax

Jan 14, 2021, 5:00 PM
(Facebook Photo/Invest in Education)...
(Facebook Photo/Invest in Education)
(Facebook Photo/Invest in Education)

PHOENIX (AP) — A judge on Thursday rejected one of several constitutional challenges to a new voter-approved tax on the wealthy to fund education but put off deciding on several other legal arguments brought by opponents.

The challenge to a provision of Proposition 208 that opponents said limited the Legislature’s authority to adjust school funding failed because it only applies to schools themselves, Maricopa County Superior Court Judge John Hannah Jr. wrote in a ruling.

That provision says school districts must use the money provided by the tax to boost teacher and support staff pay and can’t use it to replace other funding.

The groups that sued — including the Republican leaders of the state Senate and House — argued that the section limited lawmakers’ budgeting and appropriation authority. Hannah said that wasn’t the case.

“Simply put, the ‘no supplant’ clause is directed at the school districts and charter schools that receive the Proposition 208 funds,” Hannah wrote. “It does not limit or affect what the legislature does with general fund revenues.”

Proposition 208, which voters passed in November, imposes a 3.5% tax surcharge on income above $250,000 for individuals or above $500,000 for couples. Supporters say it could raise about $940 million a year for schools, although the Legislature’s budget analysts estimate it will bring in $827 million a year.

The measure was an outgrowth of a 2018 teacher strike that resulted in educators getting a 20% pay raise over three years but fell short of their demands.

Those challenging the proposition had asked the judge to block it on several grounds while the case works its way through the courts, but Hannah said the provision he ruled on was the only pressing matter requiring an expedited decision. He promised to issue rulings on the remaining issues as soon as possible.

They include opponents’ claims that only the Legislature can impose a new tax because a constitutional amendment requires a two-thirds vote of the Legislature to impose a new tax.

Roopali Desai, an attorney who represents the groups that proposed the ballot measure and worked to defend it in court, said the judge’s ruling is significant for two main reasons: Hannah noted that courts are required to find laws constitutional if at all possible, and he said the right of residents to initiate laws and for those laws to have meaning is primary.

“This idea that if there’s a dispute between certain members of the Legislature, and they don’t like the fact that people are passing laws, that is not a dispute that the court is going to arbitrate,” Desai said. “That is not a constitutional claim — that’s you guys have a disagreement here.”

No matter what the judge rules, it’s the beginning of what is sure to be a lengthy legal process. Hannah’s initial rulings are likely to be appealed, and when those appeals are over, a full trial is expected on the remaining issues.

Lifetime Windows & Doors

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

(Facebook File Photo/Lake Pleasant Regional Park...
Luke Forstner

Valley expert shares lake safety tips for Memorial Day weekend

People looking to cool off at a lake this Memorial Day weekend are asked to do so safely after a string of drownings.
6 hours ago
VR equipment and a version of the TASER 7 that utilizes VR technology for training, is demonstrated...
Taylor Tasler

Phoenix Police use virtual reality headsets to train for calls in the field

The Phoenix Police Department is one of the first law enforcement agencies in the country to use virtual reality to provide officers training in the field. 
6 hours ago
(Facebook Photo/Phoenix Fan Fusion,  Alexander Tamargo/Getty Images for The Latin Recording Academy...

Weekend guide: Here are the biggest events around the Valley for May 27-29

Need something to do? Here's a look at some of the biggest events happening around the metro Phoenix area for the weekend of May 27-29.
6 hours ago
(ADOT Flickr Photo)...

No Valley freeway closures planned for Memorial Day weekend

Drivers won't have to worry about scheduled closures on metro Phoenix freeways this Memorial Day weekend, ADOT said.
6 hours ago
Marcos Anthony Herrera and Anthony Michael Murray (Scottsdale Police Department Photo)...

Scottsdale police arrest 2 men in string of robberies, burglaries

Scottsdale police arrested two men who are allegedly responsible for at least 12 separate crimes across metro Phoenix, authorities said Thursday.
6 hours ago
Jose Dioicio Buelna. (Arizona Attorney General's Office Photo)...

Arizona man sentenced to 5 years for selling fentanyl

An Arizona man was sentenced to five years in prison last week for his role in a drug trafficking organization, authorities said. 
1 day ago

Sponsored Articles

Carla Berg, MHS, Deputy Director, Public Health Services, Arizona Department of Health Services

Update your child’s vaccines before kindergarten

So, your little one starts kindergarten soon. How exciting! You still have a few months before the school year starts, so now’s the time to make sure students-to-be have the vaccines needed to stay safe as they head into a new chapter of life.
Arizona Division of Problem Gambling

Arizona Division of Problem Gambling provides exclusion solution for young sports bettors

Sports betting in Arizona opened a new world to young adults, one where putting down money on games was as easy as sending a text message.

Key dates for Arizona sports fans to look forward to in April

April brings new beginnings in different ways for Arizona’s professional sports teams like the Suns and Diamondbacks.
Judge rejects 1 of many challenges to voter-approved Prop 208 tax