Supreme Court decision on SB 1070: The good and the bad

Jun 25, 2012, 9:02 PM | Updated: Jun 26, 2012, 7:39 pm

In an odd twist of fate, both opponents and supporters
of SB 1070 are calling the Supreme Court decision a

Opponents claim this because much of the teeth of the law
have been ruled invalid. The Court ruled the state of
Arizona cannot charge illegal immigrants with a state
misdemeanor simply because they are here in the state
without papers or because they have applied for a job.
The nation’s highest Court said the federal penalties must
remain the law of the land. Those penalties include
deportation. In the majority opinion, Justice Anthony
Kennedy wrote removal from this country is a civil matter,
not a criminal one. Where SB 1070 erred was attempting to
make it a criminal offense.

Despite these major law enforcement implications being
removed, supporters of SB 1070, including Arizona Governor
Jan Brewer and SB 1070 author Russell Pearce also claim
the decision is a victory because it upholds the ‘heart’
of the law.

The heart is Section 2(b), more commonly known as the
‘show me your papers’ clause. This section, as the only
portion of SB 1070 to be upheld, allows police officers to
conduct immigration status checks during lawful stops.

Here’s what’s good about the ruling:

Like it or not, the country’s immigration policy is a bit
clearer today than it was yesterday. States cannot add
additional criminal penalties to existing federal statutes
regarding illegal immigration. With SB 1070, Arizona
attempted to enact state laws that are more aggressive
than federal laws.

The Supreme Court said no.

Now, other states know how to proceed with their own
efforts to combat illegal immigration. For instance, the
state of Arizona can continue to crack down on employers
who knowingly hire illegal immigrants with the employer
sanctions law. That law allows for the state to implement
fines and even shut down a business if they fail to
comply. States can also more aggressively pursue identity
theft charges to crack down on illegal immigrants who buy
documents to help them find employment.

What’s bad?

Immigration enforcement still hinges upon one thing:
federal enforcement. History has shown the federal
government has been selective at best when it comes to

For example, the Obama Administration has ordered the
Department of Homeland Security to stop deporting illegal
immigrants who were brought here as minors. But, on the
other hand, this administration has been very aggressive
with deporting illegal immigrants.

Last year, more illegal immigrants were deported from
America than ever before. That’s another problem. There
seems to be no clear policy when it comes to dealing with
illegal immigration.

The bottom line is this Supreme Court decision doesn’t
change much. It clearly spells out the steps local law
enforcement must take in handling suspected illegal

Basically, all immigration violations will be handled by
Immigration and Customs Enforcement, not the state of
Arizona. This has been the way law enforcement has been
operating for the last few years. So, this isn’t a
victory for either side. Not really. It’s simply a
clarification that this country needs a new approach to
illegal immigration.

Rob Hunter

Rob Hunter

New facts in Ferguson shooting may do little to change minds

Forensic pathologist Dr. Michael Baden said Michael Brown was shot six times by Ferguson, Missouri policeman Darren Wilson. Baden, who has performed over 20,000 autopsies, found that Brown has been shot four times in the right arm and twice in the head, once while his head appears to have been leaning forward. Many thought Brown […]
9 years ago
Rob Hunter

No excuses, VA, just help our veterans

It’s time to start calling the scandal at the VA by an appropriate name — a crisis. A Valley veteran suffering from PTSD after two tours in Iraq walked into the Phoenix VA on Wednesday and said, “I don’t feel well. I don’t trust myself.” He was reaching out for help and he was rejected […]
9 years ago
Rob Hunter

Rob’s 5 On It: Robin Williams’ best movie roles

Robin Williams was found dead in his Northern California home after taking his own life on Aug. 11. Here’s a look at some of his best movie roles: 1) “Good Will Hunting,” 1997
9 years ago
Rob Hunter

Mental illness, addictions likely got the best of Robin Williams

Robin Williams was incredibly, uniquely funny. He was talented actor, staring in movies and TV shows. He was also a very successful stand-up comic having last appeared in Phoenix in 2009.
9 years ago
Rob Hunter

US history fraught with baseless fear of immigration

A Reuters/Ipsos poll finds seventy percent of Americans think illegal immigrants threaten U.S. customs and beliefs. This thought has been consistent throughout the history of the country. Even the great sage Ben Franklin worried about immigration. He feared the German invasion the most. In a letter written in 1753 (when there were limited, if any, […]
9 years ago
Rob Hunter

‘Because I said so’ and other pet peeves

I’ll admit it: I have a few pet peeves. One of them is when rules are made up. Here’s an example from the security checks at Lollapalooza: Security at the three-day music festival consists of bag checks. Twenty feet beyond the bag check is the actual entrance to the festival. Let’s call it “No Man’s […]
9 years ago

Sponsored Articles

(Photo: OCD & Anxiety Treatment Center)...

Here’s what you need to know about OCD and where to find help

It's fair to say that most people know what obsessive-compulsive spectrum disorders generally are, but there's a lot more information than meets the eye about a mental health diagnosis that affects about one in every 100 adults in the United States.
Quantum Fiber

How high-speed fiber internet edges out cable for everyday use

In a world where technology drives so much of our daily lives, a lack of high-speed internet can be a major issue.
Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Prep the plumbing in your home just in time for the holidays

With the holidays approaching, it's important to know when your home is in need of heating and plumbing updates before more guests start to come around.
Supreme Court decision on SB 1070: The good and the bad