Opinion: The latest Democratic debate clarified why Trump will lose

Sep 20, 2019, 8:15 PM | Updated: Nov 1, 2019, 12:29 pm

(AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)...

(AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)

(AP Photo/Patrick Semansky)

The third Democratic presidential candidates debate, the first to feature all of the party’s top-tier 2020 contenders on one stage, is as good a time as any to take stock of the race.

While we’re still more than a year off from Election Day, the debate offered a clear contrast between what is and what will be.

What we have is a presidency in absolute chaos. A presidency wracked with almost daily scandal. A presidency with no clear agenda, except to ensure that President Donald Trump ends up wealthier at the end of his term than when he began.

I’ll get back to the Democratic candidates in a moment (and by the way, I’m an independent), but I think it’s important that we acknowledge the two things that drive President Trump: greed and narcissism, and not necessarily in that order.

Aside from his die-hard loyalists — who apparently don’t care that he’s a compulsive liar, a white supremacist and a bully — I’m convinced a substantial majority of Americans have made up their minds about the president. They, like me, think Trump has to go, and I believe the debate showed us what we have to look forward to when he’s gone.

Trump’s policies — check that, his off-the-cuff and often irrational decisions — have no rhyme or reason. He stands for nothing. He is immoral, crass, ignorant and mean-spirited. A day doesn’t go by that we are not treated to yet another shocking revelation about Trump or the sycophants who occupy his orbit.

The Trump presidency, meanwhile, is a cesspool of corruption. He hasn’t drained the swamp, as he promised to do. Instead, he’s clogged the drain with his personal toadies.

There isn’t time or space here to list all of the corrupt practices of this administration, but I have reported on Mexico for decades and find Trump to be as unscrupulous as the worst that that country’s ruling party, the PRI, ever offered over the course of its 70-plus years in power that finally ended in the late ’90s.

Today, thanks to Trump, any criticism by the United States of government corruption around the world rings hollow, a sad commentary on what the U.S. presidency and the Republican Party have become. Trump’s ascent and the likelihood that he will weather any effort to impeach him will be thanks to his Republican abettors. Not because they believe in him or even think of him as a true Republican, but because it serves their self-interests.

Enter the 10 Democrats at last week’s debate.

After three hours of sometimes contentious (and, yes, occasionally petty) back-and-forth, the biggest difference exhibited among these 10 candidates and Trump is that any one of them is eminently more qualified to be president. And the election of any one of them would go a long way to restoring the reputation of the Office of the President.

Yes, they are all ambitious. Yes, they all have big egos. No, none of their political platforms is perfect.

But to a person, they all proved themselves to be thoughtful, informed, disciplined, tireless and wholly committed to the principle that election to public office is a call to serve the will of the people, and not, as Trump apparently believes, a platform for self-aggrandizement and personal enrichment to be used as a weapon against real and imagined enemies.

While the idea of dedicating oneself to public service may seem quaint and Pollyannaish to cynical pundits and voters, I believe it is the single-most valued quality Americans want in our elected officials. It may not be what we always get, but it is what we want.

Why? Because real public service requires elected leaders to commit to do their job honestly and transparently — and that builds trust, and trust builds respect, to paraphrase the words of Arizona’s only-ever Latino governor, the late Raúl H. Castro.

It’s probably impossible for any human being to live up to that ideal all of the time. But it doesn’t change the fact that as voters we expect our elected leaders to aspire to that higher goal.

What we saw last week, no matter where the particular candidates happen to stand in the polls, was 10 people committed to serving the American electorate with dignity and dedication.

Ultimately, what each of the Democratic candidates offered up at the last debate was a vision for a future based on the belief that the American people deserve a leader dedicated to representing the will of the people and doing so with a level of respect and integrity deserving of the Office of the President.

Trump, on the other hand, believes in Trump. That’s it. He could care less if anyone respects him or the Office of the President, as long as he is feared and as long as he makes a buck.

As for who won the last debate? I think some of the candidates were more impressive than others. Most of them would make a good president. A couple of them might even be great.

While I don’t think the debate will have much effect on the latest rankings or the recent polling trends — which show Biden, Warren and Sanders pulling away from the pack — I do think there was a definite winner: the American people.

Trump is going to lose in 2020. He’s going to lose big. When he does, he’ll lose to one of the capable people we watched at work in the last Democratic debate.

More to the point: When one of these Democratic candidates wins, our country will be better off for having decisively quashed the greatest threat to democracy in modern American history, Donald J. Trump — and my guarded faith in this imperfect experiment called the United States of America may finally be restored.

Editor’s note: This column was originally published on azmirror.com.

James E. Garcia

(AP Photo/Gerry Broome)...

James E. Garcia

Opinion: Has Trumpism mortally wounded our democracy?

Has Trumpism mortally wounded our democracy? I hope not. Our system has lasted 240 years, and I’d like to think we have a few more good centuries in us.

4 years ago

James E. Garcia

Opinion: After Soleimani, who can’t President Trump kill?

The debate over whether Donald Trump was justified in killing Iranian Major General Qasem Soleimani has James Garcia wondering: Is there anyone the president can’t kill with impunity?

4 years ago

(AP Photo/ Evan Vucci)...

James E. Garcia

Opinion: Making propaganda great again

The truth is Americans have always had to navigate, or swallow, a certain measure of government propaganda. Growing up, I thought we were better than that. Turns out sometimes we’re not.

5 years ago

(AP Photo/ Evan Vucci)...

James E. Garcia

Opinion: The weight of history — and Congress — will judge Trump harshly

Trump deserves to be impeached by the House, convicted and expelled from office by the Senate and judged harshly by the weight of history.

5 years ago

President Donald Trump speaks to the media as he visits the El Paso Regional Communications Center ...

James E. Garcia

Opinion: ‘Tell him not to come here’

Veronica Escobar said someone wounded in El Paso took her by the arm during a hospital visit and said, referring to Donald Trump, “Tell him not to come here.”

5 years ago

(James Garcia Photo)...

James E. Garcia

Opinion: Puerto Rican lives matter

James Garcia explains why he thinks Americans should care about the resignation of the Puerto Rican governor and the protests leading up to it.

5 years ago

Sponsored Articles


Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Beat the heat, ensure your AC unit is summer-ready

With temperatures starting to rise across the Valley, now is a great time to be sure your AC unit is ready to withstand the sweltering summer heat.


DISC Desert Institute for Spine Care

Sciatica pain is treatable but surgery may be required

Sciatica pain is one of the most common ailments a person can face, and if not taken seriously, it could become one of the most harmful.


Collins Comfort Masters

Here’s 1 way to ensure your family is drinking safe water

Water is maybe one of the most important resources in our lives, and especially if you have kids, you want them to have access to safe water.

Opinion: The latest Democratic debate clarified why Trump will lose