US neutrality on Lugo impeachment draws criticism

Jul 7, 2012, 4:46 PM

Associated Press

ASUNCION, Paraguay (AP) – When Fernando Lugo was nearing the end of his lonely run as Paraguay’s elected president, the former priest appealed to what many followers of Latin American politics have long assumed to be a higher power: the U.S. government.

Lugo left the presidential palace and met for more than an hour with U.S. Ambassador James H. Thessin while congressmen prepared to vote to impeach him in a hasty Senate trial the next day. And while the leftist leader was lunching with the ambassador, his right-wing opponents also reached out to the embassy.

What both sides asked for during these critical hours, and what they were told in response, remains secret. Thessin told The Associated Press that he wouldn’t comment before the report by an Organization of American States’ fact-finding mission is released Tuesday.

Publicly, the U.S. State Department remained studiously neutral as Lugo’s ouster convulsed his capital and Paraguay’s neighbors sought to apply maximum pressure on their poor, landlocked neighbor to abort what they now call an “institutional coup.”

Should the U.S. have done more to defend Lugo, despite the fact that he had lost the confidence of all but a handful of lawmakers in a country where the constitution enables any leader to be removed from office for mere “poor performance” with a two-thirds vote of the Congress?

A chorus of voices around the region _ mostly leftists _ is saying yes, and some squarely blame Washington for Lugo’s downfall.

“The coup in Paraguay was being prepared for a long time and is part of a continental policy imposed by the United States against democratic governments, with the complicity of the economic and political powers,” declared Adolfo Perez Esquivel, the Argentine Nobel Peace Prize laureate. He urged the entire region to defend democracy by calling for the restoration of Lugo’s presidency.

Venezuela’s President, Hugo Chavez, went even further, claiming without presenting any evidence that Lugo’s ouster was a “decision of the Pentagon.”

Others disagree that Washington could have made a difference.

Conspiracy theories abound in Latin America, but there’s probably nothing the U.S. could have done last month to save him, said former U.S. diplomat Arturo Valenzuela. He said Lugo’s failure to cultivate political alliances made him vulnerable to impeachment throughout his presidency.

That doesn’t mean the U.S. government shouldn’t seek to influence another country’s internal affairs when it can encourage a positive outcome, Valenzuela added. He described a previous episode when he personally defended Lugo and said it was “one of the most difficult tasks I had” as the Obama administration’s top diplomat in Latin America.

“I actually spent hours, two years ago, with the leadership of the Colorado Party, primarily from Congress, trying to persuade them that it was not a good idea for them to impeach the president. And in that particular time, in fact, that did not happen,” Valenzuela said Friday at the Inter-American Dialogue in Washington.

This time, though, there was an overwhelming feeling among Paraguay’s lawmakers that the time had come to end Lugo’s enigmatic rule. The lower house voted 76-1 to put him on trial, and after a hasty impeachment the next day, senators voted 39-4 to remove him from office.

Lugo, whose election in 2008 with a 10-point lead over several rivals ended six decades of Colorado Party rule, was remote and even mysterious as a leader. He hardly ever explained his decisions and rarely spoke with the media. At the end, after nearly all his Paraguayan allies had abandoned him, it was even more difficult to understand his intentions. He reversed course several times, saying he’d accept the impeachment verdict and then challenging it.

While the U.S. stayed aloof, nations in the region did try to save Lugo, and failed.

Foreign ministers from a dozen South American nations in the UNASUR organization flew together to Asuncion to lobby Paraguayan lawmakers, and found themselves advocating much more forcefully than Lugo himself against impeachment.

Venezuela’s foreign minister huddled privately with Paraguay’s four armed forces chiefs, which has brought allegations from the new government that he urged the generals to use the threat of force to abort the impeachment. Venezuela’s government denies that.

Top diplomats from Brazil and Argentina confronted Vice President Federico Franco, allegedly threatening trade sanctions if he didn’t call on Congress to stop the trial.

The visiting foreign ministers made a last-ditch attempt to persuade senators themselves, to no avail.

“I think it’s out of place for foreign ministers to intervene to such an extent in the internal affairs of Paraguay,” said Sen. Miguel Carrizosa of the Beloved Fatherland party, calling it “an abuse of diplomacy.”

With Lugo out, the UNASUR and Mercosur groups swiftly suspended Paraguay’s membership, and Lugo called on the Washington-based OAS to suspend Paraguay as well, comparing his treatment to that of Manuel Zelaya, the Honduran president sent packing in his pajamas in a 2009 coup.

The Honduras experience proved highly problematic for U.S. diplomats, who were accused of failing to do enough to support a democratically elected leader, and Lugo’s remaining allies in Paraguay have sought to blame the U.S. again this time.

The Obama administration has continued to take a back-seat role in such political crises. In Libya, Egypt, Syria and now Paraguay, it has deferred to regional organizations and neighboring countries, letting others take the lead in describing and defending what best represents democracy.

Some Lugo supporters are furious at the U.S. for not doing more.

“No one who claims to defend democracy could have a contemplative attitude in the face of what happened in 1933 in Germany, when Adolf Hitler led a parliamentary coup, or when Honduras had another democratic rupture,” said Ricardo Canese, secretary general of Lugo’s leftist Broad Front coalition. “If the government of Barack Obama doesn’t condemn the coup-plotters who brought down Lugo, if it doesn’t condemn this dictatorship-like attitude, then it will be very serious for the United States.”

The State Department says this was no coup, and has limited its criticism to the Senate for moving so quickly against Lugo.

“We have been closely following events in Paraguay and remain deeply concerned with the speed of the process used for the impeachment,” one statement said, adding that “the United States is deeply interested in the success of Paraguayan democracy.”

The U.S. position got a key endorsement this week from the New York-based Human Right Foundation, a nonprofit group that was deeply involved in analyzing the Honduran coup for the OAS and was quite critical of the State Department back then.

“What just happened in Paraguay is not, in any way, what took place in Honduras almost three years ago,” said Javier El-Hage, the foundation’s legal director. He said the new Paraguayan government should be fully recognized.

“President Lugo was removed legally through an impeachment trial, carried out on vague but legitimate and constitutional grounds. Principle, rather than politics, should guide the judgment of the OAS and others in the international community.”


Associated Press writers Michael Warren in Buenos Aires and Luis Alonso Lugo in Washington contributed to this report.

(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

World News

People search a collapsed building following an earthquake in Azmarin town, Idlib province, norther...
Associated Press

Death toll soars after powerful earthquake rocks Turkey and Syria

A powerful 7.8 magnitude earthquake rocked wide swaths of Turkey and neighboring Syria on Monday, killing and injuring thousands of people.
1 day ago
FILE - A fuel trucks drives along a highway in Frankfurt, Germany, Jan. 27, 2023. European Union go...
Associated Press

Europe bans Russian diesel, other oil products over Ukraine

The new sanctions create uncertainty about prices as the 27-nation European Union finds new supplies of diesel from the U.S., Middle East and India.
2 days ago
(Photo by John Phillips/Getty Images for BoF VOICES)...
Associated Press

Vivienne Westwood, influential fashion maverick, dies at 81

Vivienne Westwood, an influential fashion maverick who played a key role in the punk movement, died Thursday at 81.
1 month ago
FILE - British Prime Minister Boris Johnson speaks during his first Cabinet meeting flanked by his ...
Associated Press

Rishi Sunak: UK’s ex-Treasury chief gets his shot at PM job

LONDON (AP) — Rishi Sunak ran for Britain’s top job and lost. Then he got another shot — and the chance to say “I told you so.” The former U.K. Treasury chief was runner-up to Liz Truss in the contest to replace the scandal-plagued Boris Johnson as Conservative Party leader and prime minister. But Truss […]
4 months ago
Britain's Prime Minister Liz Truss addresses the media in Downing Street in London, Thursday, Oct. ...
Associated Press

Truss quits, but UK’s political and economic turmoil persist

LONDON (AP) — British Prime Minister Liz Truss quit Thursday after a tumultuous and historically brief term marred by economic policies that roiled financial markets and a rebellion in her political party that obliterated her authority. After just 45 days in office, Truss became the third Conservative prime minister to be toppled in as many […]
4 months ago
People receive medical treatment at the scene of Russian shelling, in Kyiv, Ukraine, Monday, Oct. 1...
Associated Press

Russia unleashes biggest attacks in Ukraine in months

KYIV, Ukraine (AP) — Russia retaliated Monday for an attack on a critical bridge by unleashing its most widespread strikes against Ukraine in months, a lethal barrage that smashed civilian targets, knocked out power and water, shattered buildings and killed at least 14 people. Ukraine’s Emergency Service said nearly 100 people were wounded in the […]
4 months ago

Sponsored Articles

Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Company looking for oldest air conditioner and wants to reward homeowner with new one

Does your air conditioner make weird noises or a burning smell when it starts? If so, you may be due for an AC unit replacement.
Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Prep the plumbing in your home just in time for the holidays

With the holidays approaching, it's important to know when your home is in need of heating and plumbing updates before more guests start to come around.
Children’s Cancer Network

Children’s Cancer Network celebrates cancer-fighting superheroes, raises funds during September’s Childhood Cancer Awareness Month

Jace Hyduchak was like most other kids in his kindergarten class: He loved to play basketball, dress up like his favorite superheroes and jump as high as his pint-sized body would take him on his backyard trampoline.
US neutrality on Lugo impeachment draws criticism