Joe Arpaio mulls Supreme Court appeal of contempt of court conviction

Oct 11, 2018, 1:56 PM

Former Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio, convicted last year of criminal contempt of court and pa...

Former Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio, convicted last year of criminal contempt of court and pardoned weeks later by President Donald Trump, is fighting to have his conviction vacated.. (Cronkite News Photo/Bri Cossavella)

(Cronkite News Photo/Bri Cossavella)

WASHINGTON – Former Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio will likely appeal to the Supreme Court, his attorney said Wednesday, after an appeals court rejected his latest bid to have his contempt of court conviction vacated.

Arpaio was convicted last year for criminal contempt of court for refusing to rein in racial profiling by his department, but was pardoned weeks later by President Donald Trump.

When Arpaio sought to have his conviction vacated, the Justice Department said it would not try to stop him – leading the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in April to call for a special prosecutor to defend the conviction.

A divided appeals court refused Wednesday to reconsider that special prosecutor order, a move that dissenting judges said “not only violates the separation of powers, but is also sloppy, creates bad law, and invites reversal by the Supreme Court.”

Arpaio’s attorney Jack Wilenchik said he will likely appeal Wednesday’s decision to the Supreme Court, saying the circuit court’s move to appoint a special prosecutor showed a lack of impartiality.

“Judges are supposed to be neutral,” Wilenchik said. “Just because they disagree doesn’t mean they can replace him.”

But David Shapiro, an attorney at the MacArthur Justice Center at Northwestern University’s Pritzker School of Law, said he was pleased with the latest appeals court ruling.

Shapiro, one of a number of attorneys who had filed friend of the court briefs opposing Arpaio’s attempt to vacate his conviction, said the Justice Department took an “extraordinary posture” when it refused to defend a conviction its own attorneys had won.

“The court is well within its authority to appoint a private attorney where the Department of Justice has dropped the ball,” Shapiro said. “Arpaio very clearly violated people’s civil rights and insisted upon doing it to the point of criminal contempt.”

He said it would be it would be unusual for the Supreme Court to agree to hear Arpaio’s case while it is still before the 9th Circuit – which Arpaio’s case still is.

David Madden, the 9th Circuit’s assistant circuit executive, could not say Wednesday when a prosecutor might be appointed. But once that happens, the prosecutor would defend Arpaio’s conviction before the appeals court, while Arpaio’s attorneys argue to vacate.

In defending the appointment of a special prosecutor, Circuit Judge William Fletcher wrote that doing so was not infringing on executive prosecutorial power, calling it “an exercise of judicial rather than executive power.”

Fletcher said Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 42 allows courts to protect themselves by appointing a private attorney if the government declines to prosecute a criminal contempt of court case. In that case, the rule says courts must appoint a private attorney, Fletcher wrote, and that it applies for both the trial and any appeals.

But in a dissent, Judge Consuelo Callahan called the move to appoint a special prosecutor both unprecedented and unnecessary, noting that amici curiae, or friends of the court, had lined up to argue against Arpaio and could easily do so. There is no need, Callahan wrote, to “supplant the Department of Justice” with a special prosecutor.

“While Sheriff Arpaio and the Chief Executive who pardoned him have evoked strong feelings from those opposing political views, we abandon our role as impartial jurists by ‘wading into that (political) thicket,’ effectively firing that United States’ attorneys, and appointing a special prosecutor in their stead,” Callahan wrote.

But one of those with a strong opinion about Arpaio’s history defended the call for a special prosecutor.

Clarissa Martinez, deputy vice president of Unidos US, said her organization thinks it is important that people know what Arpaio did to receive the conviction for criminal contempt of court in the first place.

“We hope the courts do not cover up who he is and the damage he’s done,” Martinez said. “We know we’re stronger when we confront racism and do not sweep it under the rug.”

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

Mugshot of Raad Almansoori, who was indicted by an Arizona grand jury on eight felony charges...

Kevin Stone

Violent crime suspect wanted for NYC murder indicted on 8 felony charges in Arizona

Violent crime suspect Raad Noah Almansoori was officially charged with eight felony offenses in Maricopa County, officials announced Tuesday.

26 minutes ago

Group picture of ABOR members....

SuElen Rivera

Amidst UArizona’s financial challenges, Hobbs chastises university public governing board

Arizona Gov. Katie Hobbs on Monday chastised the state's public university governing board for attacking UArizona's faculty instead of addressing its failures and a $177 million deficit.

1 hour ago

A gloved hand holds a Planatome surgical blade...

Kevin Stone

Planatome, a Phoenix-based surgical blade maker, plans to double size of workforce

Planatome, a Phoenix-based medical device company that makes advanced surgical blades, announced plans to double its workforce.

3 hours ago

Jose “ET” Rivera, owner of Tres Leches Cafe, speaks during a rally against an Arizona immigrati...

Martin Dreyfuss/Cronkite News

Arizona business owners rally against bill requiring E-Verify checks for jobs, benefits

Arizona business owners rallied Monday against an immigration bill they say will drive businesses and workers out of the state.

5 hours ago

Traffic backed up near Quartzsite...

Eastbound I-10 temporarily closed near Arizona-California border due to fiery crash

Eastbound Interstate 10 near the Arizona-California border was temporarily closed after a fiery crash Tuesday morning, authorities said.

6 hours ago

Tiana Hodges mugshot...

Woman arrested in fatal Phoenix apartment complex shooting

A woman was arrested Monday for allegedly fatally shooting a man at an apartment complex in Phoenix, authorities said. 

7 hours ago

Sponsored Articles


Midwestern University

Midwestern University Clinics: transforming health care in the valley

Midwestern University, long a fixture of comprehensive health care education in the West Valley, is also a recognized leader in community health care.


Collins Comfort Masters

Here’s 1 way to ensure your family is drinking safe water

Water is maybe one of the most important resources in our lives, and especially if you have kids, you want them to have access to safe water.


Fiesta Bowl Foundation

The 51st annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade is excitingly upon us

The 51st annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade presented by Lerner & Rowe is upon us! The attraction honors Arizona and the history of the game.

Joe Arpaio mulls Supreme Court appeal of contempt of court conviction