Pope’s Mexico trip clouded by Legion victim’s book

Mar 21, 2012, 3:42 PM

Associated Press

MEXICO CITY (AP) – Pope Benedict XVI arrives in Mexico this week to a very public reminder of one of the Catholic Church’s most egregious sex abuse scandals: A new book says internal Vatican documents show the Holy See knew decades ago of allegations that the Mexican founder of the disgraced Legion of Christ religious order was a drug addict and pedophile.

The documentation has been compiled in a book “La voluntad de no saber” (“The will to not know”), which is co-authored by Jose Barba, a former Legion priest who along with other priests in 1998 brought a church trial against the Legion’s founder, the Rev. Marciel Maciel, for having sexually abused them while they were seminarians.

While details of the abuse were made public years ago, the new documents seem to solidify proof that the Vatican knew of the allegations long before taking action. Excerpts of the book were published by the Mexican magazine Proceso on Sunday.

“The importance of this book is that it documents the irrefutable evidence and proof that the Vatican has been lying about Maciel,” said Bernardo Barranco, an expert from the Religious Studies Center of Mexico and author of the prologue of the new text.

Questions about the Vatican’s handling of Maciel and his victims have grown in the lead-up to Benedict’s arrival Friday in Mexico amid speculation that the pope might meet with some of the victims. During trips to the United States, Australia, Britain, Malta and Germany, Benedict has heard firsthand the stories of sexual abuse from victims and prayed with them.

Juan Jose Vaca, 75, who was sexually abused for years by Maciel, sent a letter to the Vatican’s ambassador to Mexico on Monday asking for a meeting, and followed up Wednesday with a hand-delivered version.

“Keeping silent and letting this opportunity pass to meet with Maciel’s victims during his visit to Mexico _ a country that Maciel offended and causes so much damage to with his depraved and criminal life _ would be another affront to these victims and an inexcusable disservice to the church,” Vaca wrote, according to the text he provided The Associated Press.

But the Vatican has said no such meeting is planned. Barba and some other victims say they wouldn’t meet with Benedict anyway because of his role in the Maciel affair.

The former Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, now Benedict, headed the office that received their complaint in 1998, but it took the Vatican eight years to sanction Maciel for the crimes, while the accusers were branded as liars and discredited by the Legion.

Maciel, meanwhile, continued to enjoy Pope John Paul II’s highest regard as the founder of one of the world’s fastest-growing religious orders, able to attract money and vocations to the church despite the mounting accusations against him. John Paul admired the Legion’s orthodoxy and discipline _ qualities which set it apart from many other religious orders and made it attractive to many of Mexico’s political and financial elite who sent their children to the Legion’s schools and seminaries.

Benedict took over the Legion in 2010 after the order finally admitted Maciel had molested seminarians and fathered three children with two women. A Vatican investigation determined Maciel, who died in 2008, was a religious fraud who had built an order based on silence and obedience that allowed his double life to go unchecked.

Benedict’s envoy is now trying to reform the order amid charges from former members that they were spiritually and emotionally abused by Maciel’s rigid rules, the cult-like life he created and the religious vows they took preventing them from criticizing their superiors.

In an interview with The Associated Press, Barba said the book was based on information from some 212 documents in a Vatican archive that he said he had obtained from unnamed church officials.

The documentation, he said, demonstrates that the Vatican had information against Maciel as early as 1944 and particularly in the mid-1950s, when the Holy See launched its first investigation into the Mexican-born Maciel. The so-called apostolic visitation lasted from 1956 to 1958, during which time Maciel was suspended as the Legion’s superior, though he was subsequently reinstalled.

The documents “show with complete clarity that the Vatican knew the true nature of this man, the accusations, the opinion of experts, the revision of other experts on top of previous experts, and the opinions that the apostolic visitors gave,” Barba said.

The Rev. Richard Gill, a prominent U.S. Legion priest until he left the congregation in 2010 after 29 years, said the documents’ publication could be tumultuous for the order as the Vatican tries to steer it through a process of reform.

“The revelation of these documents, previously unknown to the great majority of Legionaries who acted in good faith, shows that there were solid grounds for the removal of Fr. Maciel more than 50 years ago,” Gill said in an email, calling anew for the Vatican to further investigate how Maciel could have hidden his behavior from public view for so long.

Over the years, damaging documentation filtered out that Legionary higher-ups and some Mexican bishops were aware of Maciel’s drug abuse and sexual predilections, and that at least the Vatican’s office responsible for religious orders had been alerted to the problems.

The Catholic blogger Cassandra Jones, for example, has cited letters sent in 1956 from the bishops of Cuernavaca, Mexico, and Mexico City to the Vatican’s office for religious orders recommending Maciel’s removal and a Vatican investigation into what Cuernavaca’s then-bishop Sergio Mendez Arceo termed “devious and lying behavior, use of narcotic drugs, acts of sodomy with boys of the congregation.”

But “La Voluntad de no saber,” which comes out on Benedict’s first full day in Mexico, promises more complete documentation from the Vatican’s own archives. While the book is only being published in Spanish in Mexico with an initial run of 6,000 copies, the documentation will be available on a website,
http://www.lavoluntaddenosaber.com, organizers said.

An excerpt published by Proceso detailed Maciel’s addiction to morphine, citing a 1954 letter by a Legion priest to the Mexico City vicar that was found in the archives of the congregation for religious orders.

The book also reproduces the 1976 letter by Vaca to Maciel denouncing the years of abuse he suffered, starting when he was a 13-year-old seminarian.

The letter, which has been reproduced elsewhere in the past, is chilling: “For me, Father, the disgrace and moral torture of my life began that night in December, 1949,” Vaca wrote. “With the excuse of your pain, you ordered me to stay in your bed.”

Vaca named 20 other Legion and ex-Legion priests who had suffered similar abuse over the years, providing damning accusations that his diocesan bishop in Rockville Center, New York, forwarded to the Vatican and Vaca repeated in letters he sent to the Vatican directly in 1978 and 1992, when he asked to be laicized, Vaca said.

Benedict himself has acknowledged Maciel was a “false prophet” but has insisted that he only learned the true nature of the allegations against Maciel in 2000. His office received Barba’s complaint in 1998 and the Vatican’s office for religious orders received the Mexican bishops’ charges in 1956. But with the Vatican’s very decentralized fiefdoms, it’s not surprising that accusations that landed in one official’s hands were never forwarded on, especially given the sensational nature of the accusations and the esteem that Maciel enjoyed in Rome.

The Vatican spokesman, the Rev. Federico Lombardi, ruled out any papal meeting with Maciel’s victims, saying Mexican bishops hadn’t requested it.

“Where these meetings have taken place, it was in a context in which the bishops asked the pope to do it because it was a problem felt in society and the church, and that it was something desired,” Lombardi told reporters. “In this case, it’s not on the program, so don’t wait for it.”

For their part, Barba and other victims have said they would never agree to a meeting with Benedict since it was his old office _ the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith _ that sat on the case for eight years while they suffered the Legion’s defamation campaign to discredit them.

“For nothing in the world would I ever meet with someone who protected Maciel when he should have been punished,” said Jose Antonio Perez Olvera, a former Legionary who was sexually abused by Maciel. “We don’t make deals with criminals, nor with those who were their protectors and accomplices.”


Associated Press writer Nicole Winfield reported from Rome.

Follow Nicole Winfield at

(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

World News

FILE - A fuel trucks drives along a highway in Frankfurt, Germany, Jan. 27, 2023. European Union go...
Associated Press

Europe bans Russian diesel, other oil products over Ukraine

The new sanctions create uncertainty about prices as the 27-nation European Union finds new supplies of diesel from the U.S., Middle East and India.
21 hours ago
(Photo by John Phillips/Getty Images for BoF VOICES)...
Associated Press

Vivienne Westwood, influential fashion maverick, dies at 81

Vivienne Westwood, an influential fashion maverick who played a key role in the punk movement, died Thursday at 81.
1 month ago
FILE - British Prime Minister Boris Johnson speaks during his first Cabinet meeting flanked by his ...
Associated Press

Rishi Sunak: UK’s ex-Treasury chief gets his shot at PM job

LONDON (AP) — Rishi Sunak ran for Britain’s top job and lost. Then he got another shot — and the chance to say “I told you so.” The former U.K. Treasury chief was runner-up to Liz Truss in the contest to replace the scandal-plagued Boris Johnson as Conservative Party leader and prime minister. But Truss […]
3 months ago
Britain's Prime Minister Liz Truss addresses the media in Downing Street in London, Thursday, Oct. ...
Associated Press

Truss quits, but UK’s political and economic turmoil persist

LONDON (AP) — British Prime Minister Liz Truss quit Thursday after a tumultuous and historically brief term marred by economic policies that roiled financial markets and a rebellion in her political party that obliterated her authority. After just 45 days in office, Truss became the third Conservative prime minister to be toppled in as many […]
4 months ago
People receive medical treatment at the scene of Russian shelling, in Kyiv, Ukraine, Monday, Oct. 1...
Associated Press

Russia unleashes biggest attacks in Ukraine in months

KYIV, Ukraine (AP) — Russia retaliated Monday for an attack on a critical bridge by unleashing its most widespread strikes against Ukraine in months, a lethal barrage that smashed civilian targets, knocked out power and water, shattered buildings and killed at least 14 people. Ukraine’s Emergency Service said nearly 100 people were wounded in the […]
4 months ago
This illustration made available by Johns Hopkins APL and NASA depicts NASA's DART probe, upper rig...
Associated Press

NASA spacecraft smashes into asteroid for defense test

A NASA spacecraft rammed an asteroid at blistering speed Monday in an unprecedented dress rehearsal for the day a killer rock menaces Earth.
4 months ago

Sponsored Articles

(Pexels Photo)...

Sports gambling can be fun for adults, but it’s a dangerous game for children

While adults may find that sports gambling is a way to enhance the experience with more than just fandom on the line, it can be a dangerous proposition if children get involved in the activity.
(Photo via MLB's Arizona Fall League / Twitter)...
Arizona Fall League

Top prospects to watch at this year’s Arizona Fall League

One of the most exciting elements of the MLB offseason is the Arizona Fall League, which began its 30th season Monday.
Children’s Cancer Network

Children’s Cancer Network celebrates cancer-fighting superheroes, raises funds during September’s Childhood Cancer Awareness Month

Jace Hyduchak was like most other kids in his kindergarten class: He loved to play basketball, dress up like his favorite superheroes and jump as high as his pint-sized body would take him on his backyard trampoline.
Pope’s Mexico trip clouded by Legion victim’s book