NRC officials doubted US claim on Japan crisis

Feb 21, 2012, 11:27 PM

Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) – Top Nuclear Regulatory Commission officials debated the accuracy of public statements made by the agency’s chairman about a pool holding spent fuel rods at a crippled Japan nuclear plant, newly released transcripts show.

NRC Chairman Gregory Jaczko told Congress the pool was dry, which would have increased the chances of a catastrophic radioactive release. The claim _ which drew immediate denials from Japanese officials and later proved to be wrong _ was a key reason for a U.S. recommendation that Americans within 50 miles of the plant leave the area.

After Jaczko’s testimony, a top NRC official in Japan told Jaczko his statement was “probably inaccurate.”

The official later said he was unsure, telling Jaczko: “It may not have been dry, but it certainly wasn’t full” of water.

The NRC on Tuesday released more than 3,000 pages of transcripts showing the agency’s response in the days following the March 11, 2011, earthquake and tsunami in Japan, which triggered the worst nuclear crisis in a quarter century. The release was made in response to requests under the Freedom of Information Act from The Associated Press and other news organizations.

The transcripts, some redacted, show what Jaczko called a “fog of war” atmosphere as officials struggled to get accurate information.

“The early hours … were very hectic,” Jaczko told reporters Tuesday in a brief conference call as his agency released the transcripts. Much of what officials learned came from counterparts in Japan and an international nuclear agency, “and a great deal came from the news media,” Jaczko said.

Jaczko did not take questions and his remarks did not address his previous claims on the spent-fuel pool. Loss of cooling water in the reactor core could have exposed highly radioactive spent fuel rods, increasing the threat of a complete fuel meltdown and a catastrophic release of radiation.

Japanese officials denied the pool was dry and reported that the plant’s condition was stable.

NRC officials later acknowledged that Jaczko spoke in error.

The transcripts released Tuesday show a worried Jaczko repeatedly asking whether his statements about the spent-fuel pool were accurate.

On March 16, for example, Jaczko asked his top-ranking aide in Japan, Charles Casto: “At this point, you no longer believe that the pool is dry?”

“I would say, as of five o’clock yesterday, the pool has some water in it,” Casto replied.

“Okay. Now I’ve said publicly the pool is dry,” Jaczko said.

“Yes, I know that,” Casto said. “I would say it’s probably inaccurate to say it’s dry.”

Later, another NRC official told Jaczko that Japanese officials who initially had indicated the pool was dry had changed their minds.

“That’s great,” Jaczko replied.

In the documents, Casto repeatedly expressed frustration at the limited information provided by Japanese officials, saying at one point they were relying on a short video of the plant made by helicopter. “So we really don’t know what the hell we looked at,” he said. “All we can tell is some feet away, there was steam coming out of the building.”

A key focus in the days after the disaster was how U.S. citizens in Japan should respond, the transcripts show.

Bill Borchardt, the NRC’s executive director for operations, assured Jaczko that he was on solid footing in recommending a 50-mile evacuation zone for U.S. citizens in Japan. The evacuation zone was five times larger than U.S. nuclear plants’ plan for in emergencies. The 50-mile zone also was greater than Japanese officials recommended for their own citizens.

“If this happened in the U.S., we would go out to 50 miles,” Borchardt told Jaczko on March 16. “That would be our evacuation recommendation.”

The transcript also shows that U.S. officials quickly recognized the scope of the disaster. “At this point I would see a worst scenario probably being three reactors eventually having, for lack of a better term, a meltdown,” Jaczko told White House officials. The statement correctly predicted the outcome of the disaster, the world’s worst nuclear crisis since Chernobyl in 1986.

The NRC has since approved a number of steps to improve safety at U.S. nuclear plants. The changes are intended to make the 104 U.S. commercial nuclear reactors better prepared for incidents they were not initially designed to handle, such as prolonged power blackouts or damage to multiple reactors at the same time, as happened in Japan.

(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)


(Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)...

Arizona man sentenced to 46 months in prison for importing drugs

A 22-year-old Arizona man was sentenced to 46 months in prison for conspiracy to import fentanyl, heroin and methamphetamine.
22 days ago
No Author

Broomhead’s Action Alliance

Sign up to make a difference! Join Broomhead's Action Alliance to learn about upcoming volunteer opportunities where you'll work side by side with Mike Broomhead in service to others.
2 months ago
Associated Press

US has over 750 complaints of Teslas braking for no reason

DETROIT (AP) — More than 750 Tesla owners have complained to U.S. safety regulators that cars operating on the automaker’s partially automated driving systems have suddenly stopped on roadways for no apparent reason. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration revealed the number in a detailed information request letter to Tesla that was posted Friday on […]
4 months ago
A destroyed window of a house is seen during a military sweep to search for possible remnants of Ru...
Associated Press

Zelenskyy: Retreating Russians leave many mines behind

KYIV, Ukraine (AP) — Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy warned his people early Saturday that retreating Russian forces were creating “a complete disaster” outside the capital as they leave mines across “the whole territory,” even around homes and corpses. He issued the warning as the humanitarian crisis in the encircled city of Mariupol deepened, with Russian […]
6 months ago
Arizona Department of Gaming

While March brings upsets and buzzer-beaters, it also needs to bring caution

In March, basketball fans around the country glue themselves in front of a television for almost 11 hours for four consecutive days.
6 months ago
Follow @KTAR923...

Some of the greatest Big Game comebacks in NFL history

The Big Game has brought some of the best and worst comebacks for not only the casual fan, but gambling fans.
8 months ago

Sponsored Articles

Mayo Clinic Orthopedics and Sports Medicine

Why your student-athlete’s physical should be conducted by a sports medicine specialist

Dr. Anastasi from Mayo Clinic Orthopedics and Sports Medicine in Tempe answers some of the most common questions.
Dr. Richard Carmona

Great news: Children under 5 can now get COVID-19 vaccine

After more than two years of battle with an invisible killer, we can now vaccinate the youngest among us against COVID-19. This is great news.
Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Most plumbing problems can be fixed with regular maintenance

Instead of waiting for a problem to happen, experts suggest getting a head start on your plumbing maintenance.
NRC officials doubted US claim on Japan crisis