Legally Speaking: What if Aaron Hernandez lived, killed and died in Arizona?

Apr 24, 2017, 6:30 PM | Updated: Apr 25, 2017, 8:44 am
FILE - In this Friday, April 14, 2017, file photo, Former New England Patriots tight end Aaron Hern...

FILE - In this Friday, April 14, 2017, file photo, Former New England Patriots tight end Aaron Hernandez turns to look in the direction of the jury as he reacts to his double murder acquittal at Suffolk Superior Court in Boston. Hernandez hung himself and was pronounced dead at a Massachusetts hospital early Wednesday, April 19, 2017, according to officials. (AP Photo/Stephan Savoia, Pool, File)

(AP Photo/Stephan Savoia, Pool, File)

Aaron Hernandez, former New England Patriots football player and convicted killer, committed suicide last week in prison. At the time of his death, he was serving a life sentence for the first-degree murder of Odin Lloyd and had just been acquitted of another murder.

However, in a weird twist of fate, the first-degree murder conviction is no more.

If you conduct an internet search on Hernandez, you will see articles about his sexuality, his gang ties, his football statistics, whether the Patriots owe him money and articles about a concept called “the doctrine of abatement ab initio.” Think: “Back to the beginning.”

Massachusetts law follows this arcane concept that basically means if you die while your case is in the appellate system, then the entire case gets thrown out.

Yes, it is as if the conviction and the case never existed. Enter Hernandez, since his conviction was in the appellate courts at the time of his death, the courts now consider him an innocent man.

Arizona had the same law — until just recently.

Arizona followed that same arcane concept until the Arizona Attorney General’s Office, and presumably others, worked to change the law. Had Hernandez been convicted, appealed and then committed suicide in Arizona prior to 2014, he would be considered an innocent man.

In 2013, the Arizona Supreme Court ruled in State v. Glassell that “death pending appeal abates the appeal and the conviction.”

Why on Earth did the Court continue to uphold this you may ask? Well, the Court wrote “the interests of society have been satisfied, the imposition of punishment is impossible, and the collection of fines or forfeiture results in punishing innocent third parties.”

In other words, since the defendant is dead then the punishment is over and no one benefits from keeping the conviction on the record especially if doing so would hurt the defendant’s innocent family members or heirs. This did not sit well with agencies and lawmakers who asked the questions: What about the victims? What about orders for restitution? 

Enter Arizona Revised Statute 13-106, Death of convicted defendant; dismissal of appellate and post-conviction proceedings. Although any pending appeal or post-conviction proceeding is still dismissed on the defendant’s death, there is no “abatement” of the conviction, sentence, restitution, fine or assessment. So, Hernandez would still be considered a convicted killer in Arizona.

Arizona is not always on the cutting edge of new laws and often times finds itself towards the bottom of various lists and polls. That being said, according to Ryan Anderson, communications director with the Arizona Attorney General’s Office, Arizona became the first state in the country to change its law to hold that a convicted person’s death does not abate the criminal conviction or any restitution orders.

So often we hear about the flaws our state has and not the proactive steps it takes to change things. I am proud to say that Arizona does work hard to champion the rights of victims, and this is a perfect example.

Monica Lindstrom

(AP Photo/Eric Gay, File)...
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: Arizona remains in state of confusion regarding abortions

Eventually, Arizona will have clarity on abortion law. For now, KTAR legal expert Monica Lindstrom says it is in a state of confusion.
7 months ago
(AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana)...
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: Abortion no longer a constitutional right, states to make decision

Roe and Casey are overturned. There is no longer a constitutional right to abortion. However, the question of whether an abortion is legal has reverted back to the states for each of them to decide on their own.
8 months ago
(AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana)...
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: It will come down to the states, not Supreme Court, to rule on abortion legality

The issue of whether an abortion will be legal and any rules regarding it will revert back to the states, not the Supreme Court, for each of them to decide on their own, writes Monica Lindstrom.
9 months ago
Arizona State Courts Building (Arizona Governor's Office Photo)...
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: Brnovich appeal to Arizona Supreme Court makes sense

KTAR legal analyst Monica Lindstrom thinks it's a good move by Attorney General Mark Brnovich to petition the Arizona Supreme Court to hear his appeal in a case about laws that were ruled unconstitutional.
1 year ago
(File Photo by Matthew Hatcher/Getty Images)...
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: Why judge rejected Arizona ban on mask mandates

KTAR legal expert Monica Lindstrom explains the reasons behind a judge's decision to strike down Arizona's ban on face mask mandates.
1 year ago
(Facebook File Photo/Phoenix Police Department)...
Monica Lindstrom

Legally Speaking: Police may need to be part of Phoenix oversight office

Phoenix's requirement that no current or former law enforcement be part of a new police oversight office appears to be in direct conflict with recently signed Arizona laws, writes KTAR News legal expert Monica Lindstrom.
2 years ago

Sponsored Articles

Quantum Fiber

How high-speed fiber internet edges out cable for everyday use

In a world where technology drives so much of our daily lives, a lack of high-speed internet can be a major issue.
(Photo via MLB's Arizona Fall League / Twitter)...
Arizona Fall League

Top prospects to watch at this year’s Arizona Fall League

One of the most exciting elements of the MLB offseason is the Arizona Fall League, which began its 30th season Monday.
Quantum Fiber

Stream 4K and more with powerful, high-speed fiber internet

Picking which streaming services to subscribe to are difficult choices, and there is no room for internet that cannot handle increased demands.
Legally Speaking: What if Aaron Hernandez lived, killed and died in Arizona?