Judge nixes Brazilian pol’s suit over NYC charges

Apr 25, 2012, 11:31 PM

Associated Press

NEW YORK (AP) – A Brazilian congressman lost a bid Wednesday to get rid of a far-flung conspiracy case that was brought in New York, though based on claims of corruption in Brazil.

Paulo Maluf and his son, Flavio, have never appeared in a New York court to fight 5-year-old charges of scheming to take more than $11 million in kickbacks from Brazilian highway contractors and shuttle the money through New York bank accounts.

Instead, they asked a civil court to order the Manhattan district attorney’s office to dismiss the charges, which the Malufs called a case of prosecutors overreaching into another continent. In a ruling filed Wednesday, a civil court judge said the men were pursuing their claims in the wrong court.

The Malufs’ “challenges to the indictment may be raised and addressed in a pre-trial motion to dismiss or at a trial” in criminal court, should they decide to show up there, state Supreme Court Justice Marcy Friedman wrote.

A lawyer for the Malufs, Sharon McCarthy, said she was evaluating the ruling to determine what move they might make next. The DA’s office declined to comment.

Paulo Maluf, a former Brazilian presidential candidate, and his son said the Manhattan DA had no place prosecuting a case derived from allegations that arose in Brazil and are also being prosecuted there. The Malufs deny the allegations in both countries.

“The Manhattan DA’s actions have stepped all over the sovereignty of Brazil,” another Maluf lawyer, Bryan C. Skarlatos, told the judge at an April 2010 hearing.

But prosecutors said they had legal grounds to go after the Malufs because the money passed through New York, and some of the cash bought watches and jewelry here.

“They had no problems using the United States and New York to commit their crimes,” Assistant District Attorney Marc Scholl told the judge at the 2010 hearing.

Manhattan prosecutors haven’t formally tried to extradite the Malufs, citing a provision in Brazil’s constitution that largely bars extradition of its citizens. But prosecutors have asked police around the world to pick up the Malufs if they leave their homeland.

The judge did say there might be questions about whether allegations underlying certain conspiracy charges against the Malufs were sufficiently tied to New York, though she didn’t call for them to be dismissed. The men also face other conspiracy counts, as well as charges of possession of stolen property.

Paulo Maluf’s political career spans four decades and includes stints as mayor of Sao Paulo and governor of the surrounding state. He was elected to congress in 2006, and later re-elected, under the conservative Progressive Party banner.

He built a reputation for effectiveness, though he has long been dogged by corruption allegations.

Some of the alleged kickback money that coursed through Manhattan helped finance Maluf’s unsuccessful 1998 campaign to return to the Sao Paulo state governorship, Manhattan prosecutors say.

The Manhattan case was unveiled in March 2007. Then-District Attorney Robert Morgenthau called it an illustration of “corruption and greed on a colossal scale”; a spokesman for Maluf denounced it as “the fruit of political persecution.”

The Manhattan DA’s office has a history of pursuing far-reaching financial cases, often based on money flowing through international banking hubs in Manhattan.


Associated Press Writer Bradley Brooks in Sao Paulo contributed to this report.


Follow Jennifer Peltz at

(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

United States News

(Airbnb Photo)...
Kevin Stone

Airbnb makes party ban policy permanent, says it had big impact in Arizona

Airbnb said Tuesday its party ban has been so effective, especially in Arizona, that the vacation rental platform is making the policy permanent.
11 hours ago
In this image provided by the New York State Police, Trooper Jimmy Rasaphone, right, poses for a ph...
Associated Press

Trooper crawls into drainage pipe to rescue missing dog

CONKLIN, N.Y. (AP) — A missing golden retriever named Lilah, discovered deep inside a culvert pipe in upstate New York, could not be lured out by her owner with peanut butter dog treats or cheese. In the end, State Trooper Jimmy Rasaphone decided to crawl about 15 feet (5 meters) into the pipe under a […]
11 hours ago
In this photo taken from surveillance video, Richard Cox slides down the back of a police van while...
Associated Press

Crump to represent Randy Cox, Black man hurt in police van

Prominent civil rights attorney Ben Crump said Tuesday he will lead the legal fight on behalf of Randy Cox, a Black man who was seriously injured in the back of a police van in Connecticut when the driver braked suddenly. Crump also called for a federal civil rights investigation into the treatment of Cox, 36, […]
11 hours ago
Associated Press

Anti-Black and Asian bias fuel California hate crime surge

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Hate crimes in California shot up 33% to nearly 1,800 reported incidents in 2021, the sixth highest tally on record and the highest since after the 9/11 terrorist attacks in 2001, the state attorney general’s office said Tuesday. Attorney General Rob Bonta said that crimes against Black people were again the […]
11 hours ago
Associated Press

Key moments in Flint, Michigan’s lead-tainted water crisis

FLINT, Mich. (AP) — A Michigan Supreme Court order that charges related to the Flint water scandal against former Gov. Rick Snyder, his health director and seven other people must be dismissed is the latest development in the crisis that started in 2014. That was when the city began taking water from the Flint River […]
11 hours ago
The entrance to the room for the House select committee investigating the Jan. 6 attack is seen aft...

Watch: Jan. 6 committee calls surprise hearing during recess

The House Jan. 6 committee announced a surprise hearing for Tuesday, saying it would present "recently obtained evidence and receive witness testimony."
11 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

Arizona Division of Problem Gambling

Arizona Division of Problem Gambling provides exclusion solution for young sports bettors

Sports betting in Arizona opened a new world to young adults, one where putting down money on games was as easy as sending a text message.
Carla Berg, MHS, Deputy Director, Public Health Services, Arizona Department of Health Services

ADHS mobile program brings COVID-19 vaccines and boosters to Arizonans

The Arizona Department of Health Services and partner agencies are providing even more widespread availability by making COVID-19 vaccines available in neighborhoods through trusted community partners.
Canvas Annuity

The secret to guaranteed retirement income

Annuities aren’t really a secret, but they are so misunderstood that they might as well be. Once you understand what an annuity is and how it can benefit you, you could decide this “secret” is the perfect supplement to your retirement plan.
Judge nixes Brazilian pol’s suit over NYC charges