Court seems split on when to apply new sentences

Apr 17, 2012, 5:34 PM

Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) – The Supreme Court seemed split Tuesday on whether criminals who were arrested but not yet sentenced for crack cocaine offenses should be able to take advantage of newly reduced sentences.

Corey A. Hill and Edward Dorsey were arrested in 2007 and 2008 for selling crack cocaine and faced mandatory 10-year sentences in Illinois. However, the men were not sentenced until after the Fair Sentencing Act went into effect in August 2010. That law reduces the difference between sentences for crimes committed by crack cocaine and powder cocaine users.

The men argued on appeal that because their sentences came after the law’s effective date, they should get its lesser prison time. The 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago disagreed, and they appealed to the Supreme Court.

Their lawyer argued to the justices that Congress would not have then expected judges to use outdated laws to sentence people, knowing it was about to change. “Why would Congress want district courts to continue to impose sentences that were universally viewed as unfair and racially discriminatory?” lawyer Stephen Eberhardt said.

Several justices questioned whether Congress made it clear when it wrote the law that the Fair Sentencing Act was intended to be retroactive. But Justice Department lawyer Michael Dreeben said there were no “magic words” for Congress to use in the law to make its intention clear.

“To impose a sentence under outmoded guidelines will foster irrationality in sentencing and would be contrary to the goal of consistency in sentencing,” Dreeben said.

The Justice Department originally argued that the men should not get the lesser sentences but changed its mind before the case made it to the Supreme Court.

Several of the justices noted how controversial the crack cocaine sentencing laws were. “I’ve been a judge for nearly 20 years, and I don’t know that there’s one law that has created more controversy or more discussion about its racial impact than this one,” said Justice Sonia Sotomayor.

But Justice Antonin Scalia said they can’t let the controversial aspect of the law weigh on their decision. “Let’s talk about text, not … about the emotions of Congress,” he said.

Lawyer Miguel Estrada, invited by the court to defend the appeal court’s decision, noted that allowing Hill and Dorsey to use the new sentencing structure and not others may not be fair.

“People who committed the same offense on the same date and may have done so with each other, we would expect to get comparable punishment if they were comparably situated as to criminal history, and the solution that’s being urged undermines that,” he said.

“But you have to draw a line someplace and that’s inevitable that some people are going to fall on one side,” Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said.

Justices will make a ruling before the end of June.

(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

United States News

Associated Press

Stock market today: Wall Street takes a breather after best trading month of the year

Wall Street is mixed early Friday after closing out the best month of the year. Futures for the S&P 500 edged 0.2% lower before the bell while the Dow Jones Industrial Average were essentially flat. Markets marched steadily higher through much of November as investors grew hopeful that the Federal Reserve is finally done raising […]

7 hours ago

Associated Press

Rep. George Santos is facing a vote on his expulsion from Congress as lawmakers weigh accusations

WASHINGTON (AP) — Rep. George Santos of New York is facing a critical vote to expel him from the House on Friday as lawmakers weigh whether his actions, fabrications and alleged lawbreaking warrant the chamber’s most severe punishment. The first-term Republican congressman is at grave risk of becoming just the sixth member of the House […]

8 hours ago

Samuel Schultz poses for a picture near his his home, Monday, Oct. 9, 2023 in New York. It took eig...

Associated Press

For a male sexual assault survivor, justice won in court does not equal healing

When Sam Schultz was sexually assaulted, it felt like a part of them died. It took eight years and the burgeoning #MeToo movement to spur them to go public and make a police report, and an additional five years for their attackers to plead guilty. Now, as much as Schultz hopes there’s a reckoning coming […]

8 hours ago

Associated Press

Warplanes hit targets in Gaza as Israel resumes its offensive and warns of attacks to come in south

DEIR AL-BALAH, Gaza Strip (AP) — Israeli fighter jets hit targets in the Gaza Strip minutes after a weeklong truce expired on Friday, as the war with Hamas resumed in full force. Black smoke billowed from the besieged territory, and Israel dropped leaflets over parts of southern Gaza urging people to leave their homes, suggesting […]

9 hours ago

FILE - This undated file photo shows the gurney in the death chamber in Huntsville, Texas. An annua...

Associated Press

Report: Belief death penalty is applied unfairly shows capital punishment’s growing isolation in US

HOUSTON (AP) — More Americans now believe the death penalty, which is undergoing a yearslong decline of use and support, is being administered unfairly, a finding that is adding to its growing isolation in the U.S., according to an annual report on capital punishment. But whether the public’s waning support for the death penalty and […]

9 hours ago

Lead water pipes pulled from underneath the street are seen in Newark, N.J., Oct. 21, 2021. (AP Pho...

Associated Press

Biden to require cities to replace harmful lead pipes within 10 years

The Biden administration has previously said it wants all of the nation's roughly 9 million lead pipes to be removed, and rapidly.

12 hours ago

Sponsored Articles


Midwestern University

Midwestern University: innovating Arizona health care education

Midwestern University’s Glendale Campus near Loop 101 and 59th Avenue is an established leader in health care education and one of Arizona’s largest and most valuable health care resources.



Key dates for Arizona sports fans to look forward to this fall

Fall brings new beginnings in different ways for Arizona’s professional sports teams like the Cardinals and Coyotes.



Importance of AC maintenance after Arizona’s excruciating heat wave

An air conditioning unit in Phoenix is vital to living a comfortable life inside, away from triple-digit heat.

Court seems split on when to apply new sentences