Court seems split on double jeopardy question

Feb 22, 2012, 8:22 PM

Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) – The Supreme Court seemed divided Wednesday on whether to allow an Arkansas man to be retried on murder charges even though a jury forewoman said in open court that they were unanimously against finding him guilty.

Alex Blueford of Jacksonville, Ark., was charged in July 2008 in the death of 20-month-old Matthew McFadden Jr. Blueford testified at trial that he elbowed the boy in the head by accident. Authorities say the child was beaten to death.

Blueford’s murder trial ended in a hung jury. The jury forewoman told the judge before he declared a mistrial that the jury voted unanimously against capital murder and first-degree murder. The jury deadlocked on a lesser charge, manslaughter, which caused the mistrial.

The Arkansas Supreme Court ruled last year that Blueford should be retried on the original charges. But Blueford’s lawyers want justices to bar a second trial on capital and first-degree murder charges, saying that would violate Fifth Amendment protections preventing someone from being tried twice for the same crime.

“A foreperson’s announcement on the record establishes acquittal,” Blueford’s lawyer Clifford Sloan said.

But Arkansas Attorney General Dustin McDaniel argued that the forewoman’s statement did not equal a verdict. “It bore none of the hallmarks of a verdict,” he said. “It wasn’t published. It wasn’t verified. It wasn’t accepted by the court. It wasn’t even accepted by the defendant’s attorney. It wasn’t a verdict.”

In Arkansas, capital murder carries a sentence of execution or life in prison without possibility of parole.

But Justice Antonin Scalia seemed doubtful that a statement in the courtroom was sufficient to render a verdict, since there was nothing stopping the jury from reconvening and reconsidering those two charges. “Unless that was absolutely clear, the verdict has not been announced,” Scalia said.

“I don’t think it gave a verdict here,” Justice Anthony Kennedy said. “It was mid-deliberation.”

Arkansas law requires juries to consider the most serious charge first, and once they unanimously decide that charge doesn’t fit, jurors can move to the next most serious charge, and so forth. For the jury to even consider manslaughter, they must have decided unanimously that he was not guilty of murder, Kagan said.

“What Arkansas seems to run is a system in which it forces juries to agree on the greater charges before going to the less, but won’t take the consequence of that, which is that sometimes they agree that on the greater charges they’re not guilty,” Kagan said.

Also, the jury instructions did not make it clear that they could go back and reconsider the greater charges, Kagan said. “There is no suggestion in what anybody said that they could go back up” the scale and reconsider murder, she said.

“Is there any suggestion that they couldn’t go back up?” retorted Scalia.

Blueford has been held without bond in the Pulaski County Jail since 2008 while his appeal has been ongoing.

The justices will rule later this year.

The case is 10-1320, Blueford v. Arkansas.

(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

United States News

Associated Press

Case against source for Trump dossier advances, barely

ALEXANDRIA, Va. (AP) — A judge is allowing prosecutors to move forward with their criminal case against an analyst who provided key details for a flawed dossier on ex-President Donald Trump, although the judge called his decision “an extremely close call.” Lawyers for Igor Danchenko asked a judge Thursday in U.S. District Court in Alexandria […]
10 hours ago
Associated Press

Case against source for Trump dossier advances, barely

ALEXANDRIA, Va. (AP) — A judge is allowing prosecutors to move forward with their criminal case against an analyst who provided key details for a flawed dossier on ex-President Donald Trump, although the judge called his decision “an extremely close call.” Lawyers for Igor Danchenko asked a judge Thursday in U.S. District Court in Alexandria […]
10 hours ago
This illustration depicts NASA's Juno spacecraft making one of its close passes over Jupiter. Juno ...
Associated Press

NASA spacecraft buzzes Jupiter moon Europa, closest in years

CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. (AP) — NASA’s Juno spacecraft has made the closest approach to Jupiter’s tantalizing, icy moon Europa in more than 20 years. Juno on Thursday zipped within 222 miles (357 kilometers) of Europa, thought to have an ocean flowing beneath its thick frozen crust, raising the possibility of underwater life. Scientists hope to […]
10 hours ago
President Joe Biden speaks during the White House Conference on Hunger, Nutrition, and Health, at t...
Associated Press

GOP states sue Biden administration over student loan plan

WASHINGTON (AP) — Six Republican-led states are suing the Biden administration in an effort to halt its plan to forgive student loan debt for tens of millions of Americans, accusing it of overstepping its executive powers. It’s at least the second legal challenge this week to the sweeping proposal laid out by President Joe Biden […]
10 hours ago
Associated Press

Buffett’s company buys nearly 6M more Occidental shares

OMAHA, Neb. (AP) — Warren Buffett’s company picked up another $368 million worth of Occidental Petroleum stock this week to give it control of nearly 21% of the oil producer. These are the first purchases Berkshire Hathaway has made since regulators gave it approval last month to buy up to 50% of Occidental, but since […]
10 hours ago
FILE - Texas Gov. Greg Abbott speaks at the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) in Dall...
Associated Press

High stakes for O’Rourke in Texas governor’s debate Friday

AUSTIN, Texas (AP) — Beto O’Rourke spent his 50th birthday this week behind the wheel of his pickup in Texas, fast approaching a big moment in his uphill climb for governor. While a road trip through college campuses showed how the Democrat continues to draw big crowds — a photo line at the University of […]
10 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...
Children’s Cancer Network

Children’s Cancer Network celebrates cancer-fighting superheroes, raises funds during September’s Childhood Cancer Awareness Month

Jace Hyduchak was like most other kids in his kindergarten class: He loved to play basketball, dress up like his favorite superheroes and jump as high as his pint-sized body would take him on his backyard trampoline.
...
Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Here are 4 signs the HVAC unit needs to be replaced

Pool renovations and kitchen upgrades may seem enticing, but at the forefront of these investments arguably should be what residents use the most. In a state where summertime is sweltering, access to a functioning HVAC unit can be critical.
...
Dr. Richard Carmona

Great news: Children under 5 can now get COVID-19 vaccine

After more than two years of battle with an invisible killer, we can now vaccinate the youngest among us against COVID-19. This is great news.
Court seems split on double jeopardy question