Court seems split on double jeopardy question

Feb 22, 2012, 8:22 PM

Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) – The Supreme Court seemed divided Wednesday on whether to allow an Arkansas man to be retried on murder charges even though a jury forewoman said in open court that they were unanimously against finding him guilty.

Alex Blueford of Jacksonville, Ark., was charged in July 2008 in the death of 20-month-old Matthew McFadden Jr. Blueford testified at trial that he elbowed the boy in the head by accident. Authorities say the child was beaten to death.

Blueford’s murder trial ended in a hung jury. The jury forewoman told the judge before he declared a mistrial that the jury voted unanimously against capital murder and first-degree murder. The jury deadlocked on a lesser charge, manslaughter, which caused the mistrial.

The Arkansas Supreme Court ruled last year that Blueford should be retried on the original charges. But Blueford’s lawyers want justices to bar a second trial on capital and first-degree murder charges, saying that would violate Fifth Amendment protections preventing someone from being tried twice for the same crime.

“A foreperson’s announcement on the record establishes acquittal,” Blueford’s lawyer Clifford Sloan said.

But Arkansas Attorney General Dustin McDaniel argued that the forewoman’s statement did not equal a verdict. “It bore none of the hallmarks of a verdict,” he said. “It wasn’t published. It wasn’t verified. It wasn’t accepted by the court. It wasn’t even accepted by the defendant’s attorney. It wasn’t a verdict.”

In Arkansas, capital murder carries a sentence of execution or life in prison without possibility of parole.

But Justice Antonin Scalia seemed doubtful that a statement in the courtroom was sufficient to render a verdict, since there was nothing stopping the jury from reconvening and reconsidering those two charges. “Unless that was absolutely clear, the verdict has not been announced,” Scalia said.

“I don’t think it gave a verdict here,” Justice Anthony Kennedy said. “It was mid-deliberation.”

Arkansas law requires juries to consider the most serious charge first, and once they unanimously decide that charge doesn’t fit, jurors can move to the next most serious charge, and so forth. For the jury to even consider manslaughter, they must have decided unanimously that he was not guilty of murder, Kagan said.

“What Arkansas seems to run is a system in which it forces juries to agree on the greater charges before going to the less, but won’t take the consequence of that, which is that sometimes they agree that on the greater charges they’re not guilty,” Kagan said.

Also, the jury instructions did not make it clear that they could go back and reconsider the greater charges, Kagan said. “There is no suggestion in what anybody said that they could go back up” the scale and reconsider murder, she said.

“Is there any suggestion that they couldn’t go back up?” retorted Scalia.

Blueford has been held without bond in the Pulaski County Jail since 2008 while his appeal has been ongoing.

The justices will rule later this year.

The case is 10-1320, Blueford v. Arkansas.

(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

United States News

FILE - In this Sept. 30, 2019, file photo, Seminole County Tax Collector Joel Greenberg talks to th...
Associated Press

Gaetz friend to be sentenced on sex crimes, other counts

ORLANDO, Fla. (AP) — A former Florida tax collector whose arrest led to a federal probe into U.S. Rep. Matt Gaetz has cooperated in investigations of two dozen people for sex trafficking and other crimes, but it may not be enough to spare him a long time in prison when he is sentenced Thursday. Joel […]
7 hours ago
FILE - Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov speaks during a meeting with governors and heads of R...
Associated Press

Russian FM: US, NATO directly involved in Ukraine conflict

MOSCOW (AP) — Russia’s foreign minister on Thursday accused the West of becoming directly involved in the conflict in Ukraine by supplying it with weapons and training its soldiers. Sergey Lavrov also said that Russia’s strikes on Ukrainian energy facilities and other key infrastructure that have left millions without power, heating and water were intended […]
7 hours ago
This aerial image courtesy of Hawaii Dept. of Land and Natural Resources shows lava flows on Mauna ...
Associated Press

Prayers? Bombs? Hawaii history shows stopping lava not easy

HONOLULU (AP) — Prayer. Bombs. Walls. Over the decades, people have tried all of them to stanch the flow of lava from Hawaii’s volcanoes as it lumbered toward roads, homes and infrastructure. Now Mauna Loa — the world’s largest active volcano — is erupting again, and lava is slowly approaching a major thoroughfare connecting the […]
7 hours ago
Britain's Prince William and Kate, Princess of Wales, watch the NBA basketball game between the Bos...
Associated Press

Racism row erupts as William and Kate visit Boston

LONDON (AP) — Prince William’s office said “racism has no place in our society” as he sought to prevent the backlash over his godmother’s treatment of a Black advocate for survivors of domestic abuse from overshadowing his trip to the United States. Lady Susan Hussey, 83, resigned Wednesday as an honorary member of the royal […]
7 hours ago
Associated Press

Iran’s national soccer team receives subdued welcome home

BAGHDAD (AP) — Iran’s national soccer team received a subdued welcome home after its World Cup defeat against the United States, a match played against the backdrop of ongoing anti-government protests in Iran. The players returned to Iran late Wednesday, a day their 1-0 loss. Anti-government protesters, considering the team a symbol of the regime, […]
7 hours ago
A woman uses her phone in front of monitors showing Japan's Nikkei 225 index at a securities firm w...
Associated Press

Asian shares gain after Fed chair signals slower rate hikes

BANGKOK (AP) — Shares advanced in Europe and Asia on Thursday after a rally on Wall Street spurred by the Federal Reserve chair’s comments on easing the pace of interest rate hikes to tame inflation. Signs that China may be shifting its approach to containing COVID-19 outbreaks to focus more on vaccinations, while some cities […]
1 day ago

Sponsored Articles

(Photo via MLB's Arizona Fall League / Twitter)...
Arizona Fall League

Top prospects to watch at this year’s Arizona Fall League

One of the most exciting elements of the MLB offseason is the Arizona Fall League, which began its 30th season Monday.
...
SCHWARTZ LASER EYE CENTER

Key dates for Arizona sports fans to look forward to this fall

Fall brings new beginnings in different ways for Arizona’s professional sports teams like the Cardinals and Coyotes.
...
Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Ways to prevent clogged drains and what to do if you’re too late

While there are a variety of ways to prevent clogged drains, it's equally as important to know what to do when you're already too late.
Court seems split on double jeopardy question