Conn. man can seek payment from child’s real dad

Feb 2, 2012, 9:58 PM

Associated Press

HARTFORD, Conn. (AP) – Over the years, Eric Fischer had grown suspicious of whether he was really the father of his youngest daughter. So he secretly got a sample of the girl’s hair, grabbed one from his own head and sent them to a lab for DNA testing.

Sure enough, he was right. The girl was the product of an affair between Fischer’s wife, Pamela Tournier, and her business partner, Richard Zollino.

Now, five years later, the State Supreme Court has ruled that Fischer can proceed with a lawsuit demanding that the girl’s biological father pay him $190,000 _ half the cost of raising her. She’s now a young woman of 19.

High-level court rulings allowing cuckolded men to seek such reimbursement are rare, though DNA tests are increasingly accessible to suspicious fathers. And when those suspicions are correct, the idea of repayment raises complicated questions about what’s best for the child caught in the middle.

It’s not clear whether Alicia Fischer knows the truth, though a ruling from 2009, when she was a minor, indicated she didn’t know at the time. The case, however, has been a matter of record for years, and the court’s decision this week was released along with the names of all the parties involved.

The nature of any current relationship with Zollino, who accompanied Fischer and Tournier home from the hospital after Alicia’s birth and attended childhood recitals, or the father who raised her isn’t clear. She, her mother and Zollino didn’t return phone messages this week. Fischer, senior director of national accounts for UnitedHealthcare, declined to comment, as did Zollino’s lawyer.

“Obviously this is a horrible situation for that child to be put in,” said Preston Britner, a professor of human development and family studies at the University of Connecticut.

Fischer’s lawyer, Gerald Sack, declined to comment on details of the case but said he was pleased with the court’s decision.

“We’re now going to study the ruling to see what the next step is,” he said.

Fischer and Tournier married in April 1986 and had two daughters. Tournier gave birth to the older daughter, Olivia, in December 1986, and Alicia in December 1992, court records show. They divorced in 2007.

Tournier, of Redding, and Zollino, a Ridgefield man who’s married and has an adult son, worked together in the late 1980s and started Focus-Productivity Inc., a consulting business, in Ridgefield in 1993, according to court documents. State records list Zollino as the company president and Tournier as vice president.

After Alicia was born, Fischer said in court documents, Tournier invited Zollino to join them on the ride home from the hospital. On his own, he also attended eight or nine of Alicia’s orchestra recitals and attended a summer camp musical in which the girl had a role, Zollino has testified.

Fischer’s lawsuit said his suspicions about Alicia’s paternity grew over the years, partly because she didn’t look anything like her sister.

With DNA testing growing widely available _ these days, Wal-Mart even sells a kit for less than $30 _ Fischer took matters into his own hands and sent the hair samples to a lab. Bingo.

Fischer, 62, of Middletown, divorced Tournier and filed the lawsuit against Zollino. A subsequent court-ordered DNA test showed a nearly 100 percent probability that Zollino was the girl’s father.

Zollino testified he had an affair with Tournier around the time Alicia was conceived, and Tournier testified in 2007 during her divorce that Zollino was the girl’s father.

A now-retired state Superior Court judge, Clarence Jones, decided in favor of Zollino in December 2009, saying the best interests of the child were more important than the financial interests of Fischer and citing similar court rulings in other states.

“Alicia is now nearly an adult and has developed a relationship with (Fischer), understanding him to be her father throughout her life,” Jones wrote. “If she were to learn that the plaintiff is not her biological father, this information could potentially be extremely damaging to Alicia’s well-being.

“This court places the utmost importance on the best interests of the child and, as such, it would be contrary to public policy to permit the plaintiff in this case to dispute his paternity of Alicia at such a late date.”

Jones went on to cite court rulings in similar cases in other states, including Alaska, Nebraska, Nevada and California, where men weren’t allowed to sue for damages after learning they weren’t their children’s biological fathers.

The reasoning in all those rulings, he wrote, “is founded on the public policy that the best interests of the child in receiving the support that he or she needs is more important than making a grown man financially whole for expenses that he incurred under a mistaken belief that he was the child’s biological father, when doing so could potentially harm the child.”

In Nebraska, Robert Day Jr. sued his former wife, Robin Heller, after he learned he was not the biological father of their son born in 1987. Day sought damages for fraud and emotional distress, but the state Supreme Court rejected his lawsuit in 2002, citing public policy.

The Nebraska court said that when forced to choose between allowing a case “that carries all the detrimental effects of a custody battle or asking a plaintiff to go uncompensated for his emotional pain, we choose the latter.”

The shock would be comparable to teenagers or adults discovering they were adopted, something that can be traumatic for all involved, said Britner, the family studies professor. Children can have feelings of abandonment by their biological parents and identity crises.

Children may also be worried because “that dad you thought was dad is now rightly very upset and might not be there for you,” Britner said.

Still, Fischer’s attempt to make his wife’s business partner pay was revived this week, when the state Supreme Court overturned Jones’ ruling in a 7-0 decision released Monday.

Connecticut Chief Justice Chase T. Rogers wrote in this week’s Supreme Court ruling that Jones’ decision was flawed. Rogers said the court questioned whether Alicia would be harmed by Fischer’s pursuit of reimbursement, because Fischer and Tournier have already said in public divorce documents that Zollino was the girl’s father.

Rogers wrote that denying Fischer “a right to seek reimbursement in order to protect the younger daughter from emotional harm likely would be an exercise in futility.”

Justices ordered the case returned to Middletown Superior Court for further proceedings. Fischer’s case will have to be assigned to a new judge because of Jones’ retirement.

(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

United States News

Former Vice President Mike Pence talks with a guest during the "Politics and Eggs" breakfast gather...
Associated Press

Pence tells GOP to stop lashing out at FBI over Trump search

MANCHESTER, N.H. (AP) — Former Vice President Mike Pence on Wednesday urged fellow Republicans to stop lashing out at the FBI over the search of former President Donald Trump’s Florida home last week. Speaking in New Hampshire, Pence was asked what went through his mind when he heard about the FBI search of Trump’s Mar-a-Lago […]
8 hours ago
FILE - Brandon Lee Toseland stands and listens to a judge during a brief court appearance Monday, F...
Associated Press

Vegas man faces death penalty in boy’s body-in-freezer case

LAS VEGAS (AP) — Prosecutors plan to seek the death penalty for a Las Vegas man accused of killing his girlfriend’s 4-year-old son and hiding the body in a freezer — where police found it when the boy’s sister gave notes to her teacher saying her mother was being held captive at the man’s home. […]
8 hours ago
This combo of images provided by the Kent County, Mich., Jail. shows Barry Croft Jr., left, and Ada...
Associated Press

Key insider: 2 men were ‘very eager’ to kidnap Gov. Whitmer

Two men charged with conspiring to kidnap Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer in 2020 were “very eager” to move forward with the plan and expressed no reluctance, a key witness testified Wednesday. Ty Garbin also downplayed the influence of two FBI informants who trained with the group, saying he couldn’t recall them suggesting that Whitmer should […]
8 hours ago
Rudy Giuliani arrives at the Fulton County Courthouse on Wednesday, Aug. 17, 2022, in Atlanta.  Giu...
Associated Press

Giuliani facing grand jury in Georgia 2020 election probe

ATLANTA (AP) — Rudy Giuliani faced a special grand jury Wednesday under a judge’s order to appear before the panel investigating attempts by former President Donald Trump and others to overturn his 2020 election defeat in Georgia. News cameras swarmed Giuliani as he stepped out of a limousine Wednesday morning with his attorney, Robert Costello, […]
8 hours ago
Police officers and other officials stand outside the Ryder Trauma Center after a Miami-Dade police...
Associated Press

Miami officer still critical as robbery suspect identified

MIAMI (AP) — A 29-year-old police officer who was shot in the head while trying to stop a robbery suspect in Miami remained in “extremely critical condition” early Wednesday, officials said. Det. Cesar Echaverry was shot Monday night as he and other officers closed in a suspect wanted for an earlier robbery in nearby Broward […]
8 hours ago
FILE - A woman wheels a cart with her purchases out of a Walmart, on Nov. 18, 2020, in Derry, N.H. ...
Associated Press

US retail sales were flat in July as inflation takes a toll

WASHINGTON (AP) — The pace of sales at U.S. retailers was unchanged last month as persistently high inflation and rising interest rates forced many households to spend more cautiously. Retail purchases were flat after having risen 0.8% in June, the Commerce Department reported Wednesday. Economists had expected a slight increase in July retail sales. Still, […]
8 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...
Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating and Plumbing

Ways to prevent clogged drains and what to do if you’re too late

While there are a variety of ways to prevent clogged drains, it's equally as important to know what to do when you're already too late.
...
Mayo Clinic Orthopedics and Sports Medicine

Why your student-athlete’s physical should be conducted by a sports medicine specialist

Dr. Anastasi from Mayo Clinic Orthopedics and Sports Medicine in Tempe answers some of the most common questions.
(Courtesy Condor)...
Condor Airlines

Condor Airlines shows passion for destinations from Sky Harbor with new-look aircraft

Condor Airlines brings passion to each flight and connects people to their dream destinations throughout the world.
Conn. man can seek payment from child’s real dad