After Obama speech, three arguments for housing

Jan 25, 2012, 10:12 PM

AP Economics Writers

WASHINGTON (AP) – President Barack Obama said in his State of the Union speech that he wanted to help struggling homeowners refinance their mortgages. The Republicans who want his job say the government should get out of the way of the housing market.

But as the housing crisis takes center stage in the campaign, a growing number of experts say neither approach is potent enough to cure falling prices, depressed construction and waves of foreclosures.

Increasingly, they advocate something much bolder to provide relief to the 11 million homeowners in the United States who owe more on their mortgages than their houses are worth.

The analysts say the market won’t heal unless lenders agree to reduce the balance of these so-called underwater mortgages, not just the interest rate that these homeowners have to pay.

“Principal forgiveness is the bazooka that will sort things out,” says Paul Diggle, a property economist with Capital Economics.

A 30 percent drop in prices has wiped out $7 trillion worth of homeowner equity since 2006. The housing collapse has left families feeling poorer and less willing to spend. A quarter of homeowners owe more than their house is worth.

Underwater homeowners find it nearly impossible to refinance or sell, meaning they can’t trade up or move for a job. Home sales are the slowest on record. Almost 8 million Americans have lost their homes to foreclosure since in 2007.

As a result, housing has been a dead weight on an economy still struggling to recover from the Great Recession. The Associated Press took a closer look at the competing ideas for fixing the housing market _ from the Obama administration, the Republican challengers and the experts.


Obama proposed a program to let homeowners refinance their mortgages at today’s historically low rates, even if their homes are worth less than they owe. The average rate for a 30-year mortgage is 3.88 percent, the eighth record low in a year.

The program would cover loans owned by government mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and by private mortgage lenders. About half of U.S. mortgages _ roughly 30 million home loans _ belong to non-government lenders.

Administration officials offered few details but estimated that borrowers would save an average $3,000 a year.

The program would be paid for by a fee, characterized by the administration as small, on large banks. Further details of the program will likely be released in the next few days. Congress would have to approve the plan, a big obstacle.

It would expand the administration’s Home Affordable Refinance Program, which allows borrowers with Fannie- and Freddie-backed loans to refinance at lower rates. About a million homeowners have used it, well short of the 4 million to 5 million the Obama administration had expected. Underwater homeowners didn’t qualify under HARP but would qualify for the plan Obama discussed at the State of the Union.

Stan Humphries, chief economist at the real estate research firm Zillow, said the expansion could allow 10 million more homeowners to refinance. By preventing foreclosures and freeing money for Americans to spend, the program could give the economy a $40 billion to $75 billion jolt.

The Federal Reserve was more cautious, estimating that 2.5 million more Americans might be eligible to refinance through the expanded program.


The GOP field is skeptical about what the government can do for the housing market. Republicans argue that government programs to encourage homeownership caused the housing bubble _ and are responsible for the housing bust.

“The best thing you can do is get out of the way because you want the prices to come down so that people will start buying them again,” Texas Rep. Ron Paul said Monday in a debate in Tampa, Fla.

In October, former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney agreed with the hands-off approach: “Don’t try to stop the foreclosure process. Let it run its course and hit the bottom.” Romney’s 59-point economic plan includes no specific housing proposals.

In Monday’s debate, Romney and former House Speaker Newt Gingrich called for revoking the 2010 financial reform law known as Dodd-Frank, which tightened regulation of banks.

They said the tougher rules were preventing banks from making loans. “If they would repeal it tomorrow morning, you would have a better housing market the next day,” Gingrich said.

Former Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum offered one specific housing proposal: giving homeowners a tax deduction if they sell their houses at a loss.


Celia Chen, senior director at Moody’s Analytics, an economic forecasting firm, says most housing analysts are starting to agree that the market won’t recover without large reductions in the principal owed by homeowners who are underwater.

Underwater homeowners are more likely to stop paying their mortgages and to end up losing their houses. As their homes go into foreclosure, the backlog of unsold homes grows, pushing prices lower and putting even more homeowners underwater.

But mortgage write-downs would impose losses on lenders, including Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Their regulator, the Federal Housing Finance Agency, estimated last week that principal forgiveness would cost taxpayers $100 billion.

The Progressive Policy Institute and others have suggested a tradeoff: In return for reducing the amount of the mortgage, the lender would get to share with the homeowner any profit when the house is sold.

Writing down mortgage amounts has been tried in modest forms. The Obama administration’s signature foreclosure prevention program, the Home Affordable Modification Program has used mortgage reductions as a way to modify loans.

The Hardest Hit Fund, a federal government-financed program for states with high foreclosure rates, has also tried to reduce some borrowers’ mortgage amounts.

But they have had little success. About 98 percent of HAMP modifications have reduced interest rates. Just 31 percent, or 32,000 loans, have had mortgage amounts reduced.

Capital Economics’ Diggle says a better-designed principal reduction program might turn the housing market around. But the options on the table now probably won’t.

Diggle calls them a choice between an Obama plan that “won’t make much difference” and a Republican plan that means “you’re willing to accept years and years of grinding your way out.”

(Copyright 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

United States News

NATO heads of state gather during a round table meeting for a signing of a letter of commitment to ...
Associated Press

Russia and China slam NATO after alliance raises alarm

MADRID (AP) — NATO faced rebukes from Moscow and Beijing on Thursday after it declared Russia a “direct threat” and said China posed “serious challenges ” to global stability. The Western military alliance was wrapping up a summit in Madrid, where it issued a stark warning that the world has been plunged into a dangerous […]
3 hours ago
FILE - Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg listens at an event in Philadelphia, on Jan. 14, 202...
Associated Press

Buttigieg launches $1B pilot to build racial equity in roads

WASHINGTON (AP) — Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg on Thursday launched a $1 billion first-of-its-kind pilot program aimed at helping reconnect cities and neighborhoods racially segregated or divided by road projects, pledging wide-ranging help to dozens of communities despite the program’s limited dollars. Under the Reconnecting Communities program, cities and states can now apply for the […]
3 hours ago
FILE - The logo of the Organization of the Petroleoum Exporting Countries (OPEC) is seen outside of...
Associated Press

OPEC+ may not be much help with high oil, gasoline prices

NEW YORK (AP) — Oil prices are high, and drivers are paying more at the pump. But the OPEC oil cartel and allied producing nations may not be much help as they decide Thursday how much more crude to send to world markets. That’s because the 23-member OPEC+ alliance, which includes Russia, is struggling to […]
3 hours ago
A currency trader walks by the screen showing the Korea Composite Stock Price Index (KOSPI) at a fo...
Associated Press

Global stocks, Wall Street down after US economy shrinks

BEIJING (AP) — Global stock markets declined Thursday after the U.S. economy contracted, fueling fears of a worldwide downturn. London and Frankfurt opened lower. Tokyo and Hong Kong declined while Shanghai gained. The future for Wall Street’s benchmark S&P 500 index was down 1.1% after data Wednesday showed the U.S. economy shrank in the first […]
1 day ago
New Zealand Police Minister Chris Hipkins during his press conference at Parliament, Wellington, Ne...
Associated Press

New Zealand designates Proud Boys a terrorist organization

WELLINGTON, New Zealand (AP) — New Zealand’s government has declared that American far-right groups the Proud Boys and The Base are terrorist organizations. The two groups join 18 others including Islamic State that have been given an official terrorist designation, making it illegal in New Zealand to fund, recruit or participate in the groups, and […]
1 day ago
Follow @KTAR923...
Sponsored Content by Arizona Department of Health Services

Great news: Children under 5 can now get COVID-19 vaccine

After more than two years of battle with an invisible killer, we can now vaccinate the youngest among us against COVID-19. This is great news.

Sponsored Articles

(Courtesy Condor)...
Condor Airlines

Condor Airlines shows passion for destinations from Sky Harbor with new-look aircraft

Condor Airlines brings passion to each flight and connects people to their dream destinations throughout the world.
Carla Berg, MHS, Deputy Director, Public Health Services, Arizona Department of Health Services

Vaccines are safe if you are pregnant or breastfeeding

Are you pregnant? Do you have a friend or loved one who’s expecting?
Arizona Division of Problem Gambling

Arizona Division of Problem Gambling provides exclusion solution for young sports bettors

Sports betting in Arizona opened a new world to young adults, one where putting down money on games was as easy as sending a text message.
After Obama speech, three arguments for housing