ARIZONA NEWS

President of group that sued to block restrictions on ballot drop box monitoring applauds his legal win

Aug 8, 2024, 12:00 PM

President of club that filed lawsuit over Arizona's elections manual...

Arizona Free Enterprise Club President Scott Mussi said he's happy a judge ruled that new provisions made to the Arizona elections manual were unconstitutional. (File Photos: AZ Liberty Network, left; Maricopa County Recorder's Office, right)

(File Photos: AZ Liberty Network, left; Maricopa County Recorder's Office, right)

PHOENIX — A conservative nonprofit that sued to block new rules in Arizona’s elections manual won support from a Maricopa County judge earlier this week.

Barring a reversal on appeal, that means the rule changes designed to deter voter intimidation tactics can’t be enforced.

Scott Mussi is the president of the group that filed the lawsuit: the Arizona Free Enterprise Club. He joined KTAR News 92.3 FM’s Arizona’s Morning News to explain his stance on Thursday.

“We filed this lawsuit because, simply put, [Secretary of State] Adrian Fontes included language in his election procedures manual that exceeded statute and was unconstitutionally overbroad,” Mussi said. “It constrains speech rights.”

Background of lawsuit over Arizona’s Elections Manual

The Arizona Free Enterprise Club filed a complaint against Adrian Fontes and his office, which produces the manual, in February.

The group argued that new rules designed to protect voters and poll workers violated free speech protections.

Some of those new rules in the manual said election officials could restrict activities that interfere with access to ballot drop-off locations. It also gave examples of actions that classify as voter intimidation or harassment, such as following someone bringing ballots to a drop box or taunting election workers.

A judge agreed with the group in a ruling issued Tuesday, saying the new provisions the secretary of state’s office made to the manual were unconstitutional and impossible to enforce.

“I think the judge was correct. I would encourage everybody to read the ruling … outlining this, because it’s very clear,” Mussi said. “These terms that he included in the election procedures manual are overly broad. They infringe on people’s constitutional rights to engage in the election process.”

Updates designed to stop voter intimidation unnecessary, he says

Mussi said the activities the manual defines as voter harassment and intimidation are already not allowed under state law.

“There’s laws against the things that he’s describing,” Mussi said. “For example, he’s talking about blocking people. … There’s already statutes against harassing other people.”

Furthermore, he said the language describing activities that aren’t allowed at voting centers is constricting.

“It includes language that says if you raise your voice or say things that are offensive, and these things are undefined,” Mussi said. “If these things are enforced, you can be not only kicked out of the polling location, but you could be prosecuted.”

Arizona Free Enterprise Club president responds to Fontes

Fontes told Arizona’s Morning News on Wednesday that he wants to file an appeal to protect voters and poll workers during the general election on Nov. 5.

During the interview, Fontes called the lawsuit against the rules intended to protect voters “wrongheaded.” He also accused the Arizona Free Enterprise Club of wanting voters to be followed to and from their vehicles at polling locations.

Mussi vehemently disagreed.

“Those comments and claims are outrageous, and only vindicates that we were correct in filing this lawsuit,” Mussi said. “We’re supposed to believe that he’s not now going to use this vague language that he included in the election procedures manual to impinge on people’s First Amendment rights?”

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Arizona News

Two Arizona Department of Economic Security Employees were convicted of receiving bribes to approv...

David Veenstra

2 state employees convicted of receiving bribes

Two Arizona Department of Economic Security Employees were convicted of receiving bribes to approve unemployment insurance claims.

7 minutes ago

pay raise for troopers Arizona Department of Public Safety 2025...

Serena O'Sullivan

Katie Hobbs says DPS troopers, who seized 2,647 pounds of fentanyl pills last year, deserve 5% raise

Democratic Gov. Katie Hobbs reiterated her desire to institute a pay raise for troopers with the Arizona Department of Public Safety on Tuesday.

1 hour ago

FILE - This undated booking photo provided by the Arizona Department of Corrections, Rehabilitation...

David Veenstra

Arizona Supreme Court grants request to carry out state’s 1st execution since 2022

The Arizona Supreme Court granted a request to carry out the state's first execution since 2022, authorities announced on Tuesday.

3 hours ago

An Arizona woman pleaded guilty in a fraud scheme that generated millions of dollars for herself an...

David Veenstra

Arizona woman pleads guilty in fraud scheme that benefited North Korea

An Arizona woman pleaded guilty in a fraud scheme that generated millions of dollars for herself and for North Korea. 

4 hours ago

A retired deputy from the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department was convicted of luring a minor i...

David Veenstra

Retired LA deputy convicted of luring a minor in Arizona

A retired deputy from the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department was convicted of luring a minor in Arizona, authorities announced on Tuesday.

6 hours ago

Man shot in head in Tempe...

KTAR.com

Man shot in head in Tempe trying to drive himself to hospital crashes into vehicles

A man who was shot in the head and attempting to drive himself to the hospital crashed into two vehicles on Tuesday afternoon, authorities said.

7 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

...

Collins Comfort Masters

Collins Comfort Masters: Your go-to plumbing experts in Arizona

Collins Comfort Masters, a trusted name in HVAC, water and plumbing since 1985, is you go-to plumbers for the residents of Phoenix and the Valley.

...

Bright Wealth Management

How to save money on retirement planning following 2024 election

PHOENIX -- With the 2024 election over, economic changes could impact how people plan for retirement as 2025 is on the horizon.

...

The UPS Store

How The UPS Store is giving back to the community

PHOENIX -- As 2024 nears a close, The UPS Store is looking to give back to the Arizona community with the holiday season approaching.

President of group that sued to block restrictions on ballot drop box monitoring applauds his legal win