ARIZONA NEWS

Legally Speaking: Appeals decision is step closer to end of Arias legal saga

Mar 27, 2020, 4:15 AM | Updated: Aug 11, 2024, 8:27 am

(Tom Tingle /The Arizona Republic via AP, Pool,File)...

(Tom Tingle /The Arizona Republic via AP, Pool,File)

(Tom Tingle /The Arizona Republic via AP, Pool,File)

Is this the end of the Jodi Arias legal saga? Knowing her desire for attention and notoriety, I doubt it, but it is one step closer.

Why am I bringing the case up? Why am I giving it attention? Because it was a very influential case for our legal system and society, and people are still entranced by it.

Just this week, the Arizona Court of Appeals issued two decisions, neither of which were positive for Arias or the prosecutor in the case, Juan Martinez.

That being said, four and a half years after her sentencing, her defense team and Judge Stephens finally get some vindication and support for the hell they went through.

In fact, Kirk Nurmi, Arias’ lead defense attorney, had this to say about the decisions:

“ In April of 2015, Ms. Arias was provided the opportunity to speak in advance of her sentencing. In what I believe to be her attempt to inflict further pain on the Alexander family, Ms. Arias used a portion of this opportunity to admit committing the crime of first-degree murder against her former lover. Given this admission, any subsequent trial would logically end in the same result and only serve to provide Ms. Arias a forum from which to inflict further pain on Mr. Alexander’s family and loved ones as well as his legacy. Thus, I am thrilled to learn that the Arizona Court of Appeals has denied Ms. Arias’ appeal.

On a personal level, this result pleases me because my court ordered association with Ms. Arias infused my life with a great deal of pain. Pain that I can begin to heal with more fervor today as her conviction is now one step closer to being final and I am no longer a member of the Arizona State Bar – meaning the ties that might otherwise bind me at this stage of the proceedings have been removed and I can begin to respond to the allegations Ms. Arias made against me in the media, her lawsuit and her presumably upcoming claims of my ineffective counsel with the sort of vigor worthy of the person who brought public shaming and cancer into my life.”

Convicted murder Jodi Arias, left, and defense attorney Kirk Nurmi. (AP Photos)

Back in 2013, I was given the opportunity to watch and commentate on what was originally thought to be a “run of the mill” murder trial, if there is such a thing.

That trial turned into the trial of the year, decade and maybe even the century – and I had a front row seat to witness all the shenanigans that changed the legal system, society, the lives of many and ultimately caught the ire of the Arizona Court of Appeals.

During the trial that started in December 2012 and lasted until late 2015, the prosecutor Juan Martinez was hailed as the hero, the defense team was vilified and Judge Stephens was ridiculed. In its decisions, the Court of Appeals turned all that on its head.

(Twitter Photo/Kirk Nurmi)

Arias appealed her conviction and sentence by arguing everyone except her acted improperly, most significantly, Juan Martinez. The Court made quick work of the majority of Arias’ arguments by explaining Judge Stephens acted properly and “defense counsel and the defense experts were composed and comported themselves professionally in the courtroom, notwithstanding the intense public scrutiny.”

The most significant parts of the decisions were when the Court addressed Martinez’s actions.

Now, let me first say that Juan Martinez was a fantastic PROSECUTOR. “Was” because he was recently fired from the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office. He was diligent, passionate, smooth, unshakeable, clutch, and ice-in-the-veins to use some sports vernacular.

That being said, I remember numerous times he would make me feel very uncomfortable in the courtroom because I thought he was going too far (both ethically and legally). However, I couldn’t do his job and never wanted to, so who was I to judge? Well, I don’t have to judge because the Court of Appeals did just fine on its own.

The prosecutor’s actions that made the court of public opinion love and worship him are those the Court of Appeals criticized. The difference between #legallyspeaking and society. Here are some of its comments that just might make your head spin:

· “Contrary to the principles of justice, and in violation of his ethical duties, the prosecutor in this case regularly used aggressive questioning techniques and innuendo to intimidate and malign defense witnesses.”

· “It is clear that the prosecutor improperly engaged in self-promoting conduct. His efforts to gain personal notoriety were beneath the office he held as a representative of the State of Arizona in the matter.”

· “As a minister of justice, the prosecutor represented the government, not himself or his personal interests. This prosecutor lost sight of his role.”

· “Arias’ conviction stands today not because of the State’s devotion, above all else, to the pursuit of justice, but in spite of the prosecutor’s willingness to put self-interest, self-promotion, and self-aggrandizement above his duty to maintain the integrity of our judicial system.”

· Judge Jones even wrote he was “comforted by the fact the jury was able to see past the sickening, childish conduct of the State’s attorney…”

Does the Court’s criticism of the prosecutor really matter? Not when it comes to the outcome, the Court upheld Arias’ conviction by writing “In sum, we conclude that Arias was convicted based upon the overwhelming evidence of her guilt, not as a result of prosecutorial misconduct.”

So, what happens now? #LegallySpeaking, Arias will stay in prison, Judge Stephens will remain on the bench, Juan Martinez will move on to another job or retirement, Kirk Nurmi will continue his journey to heal and inspire others, and most importantly, Travis Alexander’s family will continue their healing knowing there will not be another trial…for now.

As the legal saga surrounding Jodi Arias continues to capture public interest, many are also drawn to the cultural phenomena surrounding sports, particularly basketball. Just as the courtroom drama has evolved, so too has the technology behind basketball shoes, which plays a crucial role in enhancing athlete performance. Innovations in basketball shoe technology are revolutionizing the game, allowing players to achieve greater agility and comfort on the court. This intersection of law and sports reflects how societal interests can shift, yet the pursuit of excellence remains a common theme across both arenas.

We want to hear from you.

Have a story idea or tip? Pass it along to the KTAR News team here.

Associated Press

California’s burn scars brace for flooding as freezing rain and snow head for Oregon

Officials in California distributed sandbags, prepositioned rescue swimmers and told residents to have their go-bags ready as the state prepares for an atmospheric river that could bring heavy rain, winds and flooding Thursday to areas ravaged by wildfires. Meanwhile, Portland coated its streets with 2,000 gallons of liquid anti-icer while officials in Oregon and Idaho […]

13 minutes ago

FILE - Stateville Correctional Center, a historic but dilapidated prison set to close and a replace...

Associated Press

Illinois data shows inmates with violent records from shuttered prison sent to medium-security sites

SPRINGFIELD, Ill. (AP) — Among the approximately 400 inmates transferred when Illinois’ decrepit Stateville prison closed over the summer, 278 were convicted of murder and 100 more are serving time for other violent offenses. Yet, nearly four in five of the offenders formerly housed at the suburban Chicago lockup were not shipped to top-level maximum-security […]

59 minutes ago

A snowy owl named Ghost eats a frozen rat at the Bird Treatment and Learning Center on Feb. 6, 2025...

Associated Press

Why people are naming bugs, rats and cats after their exes this Valentine’s Day

ANCHORAGE, Alaska (AP) — Feel like dissing instead of kissing your former lover this Valentine’s Day? Think your ex is more like a rat than a prince? Do you believe your former paramour should never procreate? Animal shelters and zoos around the country are encouraging little cathartic avenues for revenge this holiday — and raising […]

1 hour ago

FILE - A woman holds the hand of a sick relative lying on the floor of the overcrowded Lilongwe Cen...

Associated Press

This is what happens to the body when HIV drugs are stopped for millions of people

A generation has passed since the world saw the peak in AIDS-related deaths. Those deaths — agonizing, from diseases the body might otherwise fight off — sent loved ones into the streets, pressuring governments to act. The United States eventually did, creating PEPFAR, arguably the most successful foreign aid program in history. HIV, which causes […]

1 hour ago

FILE - Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., President Trump's nominee to serve as Secretary of Health and Human ...

Associated Press

Senate to vote on vaccine skeptic Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s bid to become nation’s health secretary

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Senate is expected to vote Thursday on the confirmation of Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a prominent lawyer and vocal vaccine critic, as the nation’s health secretary, controlling $1.7 trillion in spending for vaccines, food safety and health insurance programs for roughly half the country. Despite several Republicans expressing deep skepticism about […]

2 hours ago

Follow @monicalindstrom...

Sponsored Content by Bright Wealth Management

How updating your estate plan is crucial in saving money

As you map out your estate plan, mapping out beneficiaries and keeping it up to date is key in order for the most funds possible to be passed down with ease.

Sponsored Articles

...

Fiesta Bowl Foundation

Join us for the 52nd annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade

The 52nd annual Vrbo Fiesta Bowl Parade presented by Lerner & Rowe returns on Saturday, December 28, at 10 a.m.

...

Bright Wealth Management

How to save money on retirement planning following 2024 election

PHOENIX -- With the 2024 election over, economic changes could impact how people plan for retirement as 2025 is on the horizon.

...

Schwartz Laser Eye Center

Don’t miss the action with this game-changing procedure

PHOENIX -- The clear lens exchange procedure has emerged as a popular alternative to LASIK eye surgery.

Legally Speaking: Appeals decision is step closer to end of Arias legal saga