PHOENIX — The fate of how Uber and Lyft operate in Arizona is now in the
hands of Gov. Jan Brewer.
The Arizona House of Representatives on Wednesday gave final approval to House
Bill 2262, which exempts Uber and other rideshare companies from the same
regulations that traditional taxi and limo companies have.
The 31-22 vote came after a more than hour-long debate between proponents of
the bill, who say government should stay out of the way and let new companies
like Uber innovate, and opponents, who say the lack of regulations pose a public
safety threat. The bill had opposition from several Republicans and Democrats.
“We’re so afraid of freedom. It’s like it’s the boogey man,” said Rep. Warren
Petersen, R-Gilbert, a supporter of the bill.
Added bill sponsor Rep. Tom Forese, R-Gilbert: “Support this in the name of
innovation and in the name of disruption.”
But many, including conservative Republicans, weren’t sold on the bill.
House Speaker Andy Tobin, R-Paulden, said the bill doesn’t properly address
concerns about the appropriateness of Uber’s insurance coverage. “In my view
what I asked to be resolved wasn’t resolved on this issue,” Tobin said.
Rep. Jonathan Larkin, D-Glendale, said the issue boils down to passenger
safety. “In my book, public safety comes first. If anything is questionable,
especially when it comes to safety, you just don’t do it,” Larkin said.
The bill exempts rideshare companies from the commercial insurance requirement
that affects traditional taxi, limo and livery companies by not requiring that
drivers be insured at all times on the job. It also would not require that
rideshare drivers take drug tests. It would require that Uber insure its drivers
with $1 million policies.
Uber currently insures drivers with $1 million policies, but only from the time
the driver accepts a pickup to the time the driver drops off the passenger.
That means a driver who is working on the road but has not yet received a
request for a ride is not insured by the company unless the driver’s personal
insurance denies the claim, in which case Uber provides its contingent policy.
The issue became especially heated nationwide after a 6-year-old girl was
killed in a crosswalk by a driver logged into the Uber app in San Francisco on
New Year’s Eve. The girl’s family contends Uber is financially responsible
because the driver was waiting for customers. Uber says it isn’t liable because
no passengers were in the car.
The vote comes after weeks of aggressive media campaigns by Uber, which says it
shouldn’t be subject to the same regulations as cabs because the company does
not pick up people from the street, but rather members of the service who
request a driver.
Gov. Jan Brewer has expressed concern about the bill.
“The governor’s concern has always been about balancing innovation with
consumer safety and protecting consumer safety,” said Don Hughes, deputy
director of policy. “We have told them that there should be no gaps of
Steve Thompson, general manager for Uber Arizona, urged the governor to sign
“Uber and the tens of thousands of Arizonans that support ridesharing are
grateful to the legislators who stood up for transportation equality with the
passage of this legislation. This is truly a victory for innovation over the
status quo,” Thompson said.