PHOENIX — Arizona Senators have voted down four conservative Republican
bills targeting employee unions and a set of educational standards known
nationally as Common Core.
The failure to pass those bills in the Senate was another sign of a rift
between the more conservative wing of the party and moderates. Moderate Republicans last year banded with Democrats and Republican Gov. Jan
Brewer to expand a key provision of President Barack Obama’s health care
At the Senate on Monday, legislators voted down Senate Bill 1094, which would have required school
districts to get annual authorization from employees to deduct union dues from
paychecks. Bill sponsor Sen. Chester Crandell, R-Heber,
says the bill just creates a uniform system across all state school districts.
“It becomes a good audit tool for the whole industry,” Crandell said.
Opponents say imposing this rule would be costly for school districts. They say
the bill would weaken employee unions.
“We are creating a bureaucratic nightmare for school districts. Once again the
legislature is stepping over their bounds,” Sen. Steve Gallardo, D-Phoenix,
Four Republicans voted with Democrats against the bill. The bill failed with a
16-13 vote. Legislators also voted down Senate Bill 1355, which would have
required cities and towns to get authorization to deduct union dues from
paychecks every two years.
Two anti-Common Core bills were also defeated in the Senate on Monday,
following a trend in which Republicans are joining Democrats to keep the
educational standards that Arizona adopted in 2010 in place. Five Republicans
broke rank with their party on March 5 to defeat Senate Bill 1310, which would
have banned Arizona school districts from continuing to adopt Common Core
standards. Common Core standards aim to focus learning on comprehension and real
life examples and were designed by a national, bipartisan group of governors and
education leaders to better prepare students for college and the job market.
Gov. Jan Brewer has supported Common Core and renamed the standards the Arizona
College and Career Ready Standards.
The Senate has now failed to pass two other bills that would have allowed
school districts to opt out of Common Core and to develop their own set of