PHOENIX — A one-time inmate of a metro Phoenix jail has appealed the
dismissal of her claims that her rights were violated when officers restrained
her before and after she gave birth at a hospital.
A judge ruled last month that Miriam Mendiola-Martinez failed to demonstrate a
clear constitutional-rights violation and explained there was no law at the time
that would have put Maricopa County on notice that restraining a pregnant inmate
The judge concluded Mendiola-Martinez wasn’t restrained while she was in labor
at the hospital or while she was delivering her son.
But after giving birth, she was brought to a recovery room and a leg restraint
was put on her ankle.
Sheriff Joe Arpaio maintained the restraint policy in his jails was fair and