PHOENIX — A judge has thrown out a lawsuit by a former jail inmate in
metro Phoenix who claimed her constitutional rights were violated when officers
restrained her before and after she gave birth at a hospital.
U.S. District Judge David Campbell ruled Wednesday that Miriam
Mendiola-Martinez failed to demonstrate a clear constitutional rights violation.
The judge explained that there was no law at the time that would have put the
county on notice that restraining a pregnant inmate was unconstitutional.
Mendiola-Martinez filed the lawsuit against Maricopa County, Sheriff Joe Arpaio
and a county health care district that operates a hospital where inmates are taken for medical treatment.
She claimed that they showed deliberate indifference to her serious medical