PHOENIX — A jury deliberating the case of a man charged with killing nine
people at a Buddhist temple in suburban Phoenix in 1991 has completed its first
day of work without reaching a verdict.
The jury considering the charges against 39-year-old Johnathan A. Doody will
return Wednesday morning.
Doody’s lawyer told jurors they should not believe the key witness against him.
But prosecutor Jason Kalish told jurors only Doody and the accomplice who
testified against him were responsible and the accomplice told the truth.
Attorney Maria Schaffer told jurors the state made a “deal with the devil”
when it offered a plea agreement with Allesandro “Alex” Garcia.
Doody is being re-tried after a federal appeals court threw out his 1993
conviction. Six monks, a nun and two helpers were killed.