WASHINGTON – A federal appeals court denied claims by a death-row inmate Wednesday that evidence was doctored and suppressed in his trial for the 1986 kidnapping, robbery and murder of an elderly Las Vegas man near Kingman.
The evidence tampering was just one of several claims by Graham Henry that were flatly rejected by a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which upheld lower court decisions in the case.
Henry’s attorney, Robin Konrad, said Wednesday that she was disappointed by the decision but that the defense team was still determining its options.
The case began in June 1986 when Henry and another man, Vernon Foote, set out on a road trip from California to Arizona. Their car broke down outside Las Vegas and was towed to Henderson, Nev., where the two men, who had been drinking along the way, headed to a bar.
There, they met Roy Estes, an older man who agreed to drive the two to Arizona for $50, according to the court opinion. Henry claimed he slept in the back of Estes’ truck while Foote drove and woke up two hours later when he heard Foote and Estes arguing.
Henry said he saw Foote hit Estes, pull him out of a truck and stab him, at which point Henry said he got out and dragged Estes away from Foote.
But prosecutors said Henry was the driver and that he and Foote worked together, dragging Estes to a bush off the side of the road where they stabbed and left him.
The two drove away, but Henry was pulled over a short time later for driving on the wrong side of the highway. He gave police a false name and was arrested for drunken driving.
Henry was still being held several days later when detectives learned his real name and asked him about Estes, at which point Henry led them to the body and told police Foote had killed Estes.
Henry and Foote were tried separately. Foote ultimately pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 15 years in prison, but Henry went to trial and lost. He was sentenced to death in March 1988.
On appeal, Henry raised multiple challenges.
He said prosecutors did not use a drawing by Foote that Henry claims showed Foote’s tracks on either side of Estes’ and Henry’s footprints running from the vehicle to scene of the stabbing. Henry said that buttressed his version of the story.
But the court said the drawing would have done little to help Henry: “The drawing is practically indecipherable, and its source – an individual who was also charged with the murder of Estes – is not particularly trustworthy,” Judge Raymond Fisher wrote in the opinion.
The court also rejected Henry’s claim that crime-scene photos were omitted and altered, as well as his claims that jurors engaged in misconduct and that courts did not give enough weight to mitigating evidence in his sentencing. It also denied his argument that his lawyer did not present mitigating evidence at a rehearing.
Henry’s lawyers could ask for a rehearing by the full circuit court and, ultimately, to the Supreme Court but Konrad said Wednesday that no decisions have been made.
Arizona Assistant Attorney General Jonathan Bass, who argued the case, said his office was pleased by the decision – 25 years after sentence was imposed.
“It’s a shame that the victim’s family and that the people of Arizona have had to wait for justice in this case,” Bass said.
- See how top CFOs feel about economic growth in the Valley
- Migraine myths that keep patients from effective treatments
- Here’s why Gaydos went tankless with his water heater
- 12 things to watch before the Oscars
- Bocce ball and basketball: How you can help Arizona's Special Olympics athletes
- Tips on building the best wine room in Arizona
- Avoid the nightmare: 6 tips to choose a great contractor
- Breast cancer: Improved testing and treatments means more survivors
- Best and worst of Super Bowl commercials
- Failed back surgery: New hope for patients living in pain
- Ticking time bombs: Telltale signs your water heater is about to explode
- Reading glasses could be a thing of the past
- 6 cool ways teachers are using technology in the classroom
- Emerging tech jobs in Phoenix and how to get one in 2017
- 4 top treatments athletes use for pain
- Emergency! What to do when bathrooms flood
- Operation Santa Claus needs holiday help
- This college bowl season is likely to be epic
- Arizona kids in crisis: How you can help
- 11 holiday classics for the ultimate movie marathon
- New treatment offers hope for migraine sufferers
- 11 stadiums to watch your favorite football team
- Shopping for a TV? Best models for 2016
- The new beer pairing guide for holiday foods
- Avoid this holiday plumbing disaster in your home
- 7 tips to avoid holiday weight gain
- New treatments mean better prostate cancer survival rates
- 5 of the scariest things found in drains
- 6 tips to create the best family movie night
- New bone marrow procedure holds promise for healing pain