PHOENIX — A bill that would make it more difficult for recently unemployed
people in Arizona to collect unemployment benefits is likely to land on
Republican Gov. Jan Brewer’s desk.
The state House approved legislation Tuesday that would require unemployed
workers to present documents showing they were fired before they can receive
benefits. Under current law, the burden is on employers to fight fraudulent
The 34-24 vote came a week after the Senate passed the proposal along party
lines. Republicans control the Senate and House.
The proposed change follows complaints from business leaders about workers who
walk off jobs and then file for benefits.
Democrats slammed Republicans for making it harder for struggling families to
seek assistance while also doing little this to promote job creation. They said
it would be nearly impossible for workers to prove they were let go because
employers often don’t provide documentation informing workers of their
“They are already going through a hard enough time as it is,” said Democratic
Rep. Jonathan Larkin.
Minority Leader Chad Campbell said workers might not be able to prove they were
fired if the company they worked for shut its doors. He blasted Republicans for
“creating more problems for the people who don’t need more problems in their
“Those are the people we should be helping,” he said. “We should be down
here trying to create jobs.”
Republicans countered that the bill would create jobs because it would protect
businesses from devoting hours to fighting fraudulent claims instead of filling
“They are begging for workers,” said Republican Rep. Steve Montenegro. “They
need people employed, but sometimes, unfortunately, not everybody, but there are
people who chose to be on unemployment rather than take some of those jobs.”
Republican Rep. Eddie Farnsworth said too often state unemployment assistance
workers err on the side of jobless workers over businesses “because they have
deep pockets and the person who quit has no responsibility.”
“You have the responsibility to show that and not the business,” Farnsworth
The U.S. Department of Labor initially raised concerns about the legality of
the bill. Under federal law, applicants who have lost a job through no fault of
their own and are able to work are eligible to receive benefits. The burden of
proof is not on the employee.
“It is the state’s responsibility to make reasonable efforts to obtain the
information necessary to determine whether an individual is eligible,” federal
officials wrote to lawmakers in early March.
In the Senate, lawmakers amended the bill to address those federal concerns.
The legislation now requires the state to make a final determination based on
all submitted evidence.
Under the measure, employers would be allowed to claim that the employee
submitted a resignation orally to prove the worker voluntarily left the job.
Employers also could challenge claims if they say the worker skipped work.
Thousands of people could be impacted by the proposed change. The number of
people claiming benefits in Arizona was about 75,000 in January, according to
the state Department of Economic Security.
Arizona is already tougher than many other states when it comes to unemployment
claims. The maximum weekly unemployment benefit in Arizona is $240. The national
average has been $300 since 2010, according to the Center on Budget and Policy
Priorities in Washington, D.C. sequester
Cristina Silva can be reached at http://www.twitter.com/cristymsilva