PHOENIX — A routine final vote on an Arizona Senate bill granting
anonymity to lottery winners was delayed Tuesday by a developing battle between
Gov. Jan Brewer and legislative leaders over her stalled priorities of Medicaid
expansion and an overhaul of the state’s sales tax collection system.
The lottery bill was set for a final vote after being approved last month by
the House, and if passed it would have been sent to Brewer for her signature.
But Senate President Andy Biggs pulled it from consideration because Brewer has
asked leaders to slow down on sending her bills and work instead on her
Brewer spokesman Matthew Benson confirmed the governor told Biggs and House
Speaker Andy Tobin late last week she wanted them to focus on her proposals for
Medicaid expansion, a sales tax collection overhaul and education reform. But he
said she didn’t tell them to stop sending her additional bills.
“The governor is just asking for some focus on those priorities and they’ll be
time for those issues as well,” Benson said. “We’ve now been in session
50-plus days _ so we’re just looking for some movement on these key
Although the word “veto” was apparently never used, it brought up memories of
a 2009 budget standoff. Brewer vetoed the budget and forced lawmakers to return
for a special session. And Brewer used the same tactic last year, issuing an
actual veto threat for bills that reached her desk because lawmakers hadn’t sent
her a budget.
“We’re not trying to cut everything off, but I think members do have some
concerns, you know, do you stick a bill up there that might not be signed, if I
can put it that way,” Biggs told reporters Tuesday.
Tuesday’s delays come a day before Brewer’s Medicaid expansion proposal gets
its first hearing before a House committee and a Senate panel hears the sales
tax bill after it was delayed in the House.
Brewer has touted Medicaid expansion as a boon for hospitals, patients and the
state because it will bring in $1.8 billion in new federal funds a year, ease
uncompensated care delivered by hospitals and provide insurance for about 300,0
more people. But after a two-month charm offensive where the governor rounded up
business and hospital leaders, its fate remains unclear as Republican opponents
“I’m half way between `no’ and `hell no,”’ on Medicaid, Rep. John Kavanagh,
who chairs the committee hearing the bill, said Tuesday.
The overhaul of the state’s complex sales tax, formally called the Transaction
Privilege Tax, has been held up because cities and towns are worried it will
cost them tens of millions in revenue annually.
The current system is based on where the building is done, so developing areas
get added revenue. Brewer wants it shifted to where the materials are sold and
to eliminate taxes on overhead and profit, a prospect that municipalities
believe would cost them millions.
Ongoing negotiations between lawmakers, cities and the governor’s office have
made substantial progress in recent weeks, with the governor now proposing to
leave some construction taxes in place and making other concessions. Other
issues included who does audits of businesses, which cities now handle but the
state will take over.
But the bill was moved from the House to the Senate Monday without the former
taking action, a move that Brewer’s policy director Michael Hunter told the
cities in a letter was only to avoid a deadline and didn’t mean negotiations
The current proposals as laid out by Hunter to the cities have bridges and
highways still be assessed a construction tax, allows cities to tax construction
and allows cities to agree to help with local audits, among other proposed
An actual Medicaid expansion bill has yet to be introduced. A lot of that can
be laid on Brewer, who didn’t provide draft legislation until early last week
after announcing her plan in early January. Since then, she’s rallied supporters
at a variety of press conferences around the state, and most recently at the
House Speaker Andy Tobin hasn’t assigned her plan a bill number, leaving
Wednesday’s action before Kavanagh’s committee “an informational hearing.”