PHOENIX — Voters will decide Tuesday whether to give the self-proclaimed
toughest sheriff in America a sixth term as he faces his most serious political
Republican incumbent Joe Arpaio faces a challenge from Democrat Paul Penzone
and independent Mike Stauffer in Maricopa County sheriff’s race.
The themes of cracking down on crime and illegal immigration have been popular
with voters in the past, but that narrative was turned against him this year.
The two retired officers challenging Arpaio have accused metro Phoenix’s
longtime sheriff of focusing too heavily on investigations that bring him
publicity and ignoring many of the law enforcement duties he was hired to do.
The county to the immediate south of metro Phoenix also is voting on its
sheriff’s race Tuesday. Republican incumbent Paul Babeu is vying against
Democrat Kevin Taylor and independent Ty Morgan in his bid to win a second term.
Babeu was forced to acknowledge he is gay after stories emerged of a falling
out with a former lover and shirtless photos of him on a gay dating website came
to light. Babeu pulled out of the race for a congressional seat after the news
The 80-year-old Arpaio has been dogged by revelations that his office failed to
adequately investigate hundreds of sex-crimes cases — including dozens of
alleged child molestations — and allegations that his deputies have racially
profiled Latinos in his trademark immigration patrols.
The sheriff’s office reopened more than 400 sex-crimes cases that were reported
to the agency but were inadequately investigated or not investigated at all
after they were reported over a three-year period ending in 2007.
A city that had contracted with Arpaio’s office for police services had
concluded there were many cases in which sheriff’s investigators wrote no
follow-up reports, collected no additional forensic evidence and made zero
effort after the initial report of the crime was taken. The city concluded some
cases were no longer viable, in part, because victims had either moved away or
otherwise moved on.
The sheriff’s has said it has moved to clear up the inadequately investigated
cases and have taken steps to prevent the problem from happening again.
While the sheriff’s immigration enforcement has made him popular among some
voters, it has led to two lawsuits that alleged racial profiling in his
A federal judge heard of one of the lawsuits this summer and hasn’t yet issued
his ruling. The lawsuit filed by a small group of Latinos will serve as a
precursor for a similar yet broad civil rights lawsuit against Arpaio by the
U.S. Department of Justice.