PHOENIX — A judge on Thursday dismissed the final challenge to Arizona’s congressional and legislative district maps drawn by an independent commission in 2012.
Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Roger Brodman dismissed the challenge to the congressional map brought by a group of voters following the adoption of the maps. The U.S. Supreme Court has previously upheld the legality of the Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission itself and the legislative district maps.
Brodman rejected arguments that commissioners used improper procedures and illegally made decisions behind closed doors. He noted that it was important for him to rule because the appeals will likely take years and there are only two more general elections before the next mapmaking effort by a new commission.
“Even if the appeal could be completed and the commission ordered to redo the process, the court cannot imagine that the process would be finished in time for the 2018 elections,” Brodman wrote. “Indeed, the court doubts that the process could be finished in time for the 2020 elections.”
The commission was embroiled in legal issues since it began making the maps after the 2010 census. After they were adopted in January 2012, former Gov. Jan Brewer and other Republicans immediately denounced the maps as being drawn to favor Democrats.
Brewer had removed Colleen Mathis as chairwoman of the five-member panel in November 2011, but the state Supreme Court restored her to the post two weeks later, saying Brewer had no grounds to remove her. The attorney general’s office also sued over open meeting violations, but the commission prevailed.
One of the voters who sued in the challenge decided Thursday has said his concern was over the way some of the congressional districts were drawn.
Republican Vince Leach, now a member of the state House of Representatives, said last year that the commission didn’t properly consider “communities of interest” — areas with geographic or other ties — while drawing the maps.
He specifically cited the state’s sprawling 1st Congressional District, which includes Flagstaff and much of the eastern part of the state, and has gone Democratic since the maps were adopted in 2012.
“It’s very hard to look at the CD1 map and talk about communities of interest, because it’s simply not there,” Leach said. He couldn’t be immediately reached for comment Thursday.
That particular issue never actually came up in court, said Joe Kanefield, an attorney who helped represent the commission.
Instead, the voters’ lawyers focused on whether the commission properly followed the legal requirements for drawing the maps for nine congressional districts.
Brodman said they had, and rejected other criticisms as political sour grapes, especially one that said the commission hadn’t given enough weight to recommendations from the Legislature’s Democratic and Republican members.
“In short, the fullness and completeness that the Commission should give to the legislative reports appears to be largely based on whether one is a Republican or a Democrat,” Brodman said. “This is a partisan political issue, not a judicial issue.”
- Skin Cancer in Arizona: Stats, facts and new immunotherapy drugs making strides
- Caring Crisis: Rising tide In Alzheimer’s disease leads to shortage of caregivers
- Distracted walking injuries end up not so funny
- Scary situations: 5 quick tips before you let a contractor in your home
- Four ways telemedicine is changing the health care industry
- 5 mistakes homeowners make in the spring
- Three rivers run through it: Exploring Arizona's waterways
- Smart home basics: things you need to know to get started
- 5 Surprising things causing back pain
- Arizona agriculture is a $17.1B industry
- Timeline: Arizona's roots in brewing history
- 5 reasons to love the D-backs this season
- Tips for taking your home entertainment experience to the backyard
- Tech-related injuries your parents never experienced
- Workers comp: Signs your co-worker could be a fraud
- Who's the real founder of America's pastime?
- Epidemic rising? What you need to know about Alzheimer's in Arizona
- 5 unforgettable Wooden Award winners
- Family and hard work are keys to success of modern dairy farmers
- Genetic testing could hold answers for colon cancer survival
- Cold beers and baseball: A beer lover's guide to Spring Training
- Telecommuting: 5 tips to make it work for employers and employees
- See how top CFOs feel about economic growth in the Valley
- Migraine myths that keep patients from effective treatments
- Here’s why Gaydos went tankless with his water heater
- Bocce ball and basketball: How you can help Arizona's Special Olympics athletes
- Tips on building the best wine room in Arizona
- Avoid the nightmare: 6 tips to choose a great contractor
- Breast cancer: Improved testing and treatments means more survivors
- Failed back surgery: New hope for patients living in pain
- American cyclist Young dies from injuries sustained in Tucson crash
- State 48 Brewery to ‘brew’ up downtown Phoenix location, set to open in 2018
- Navajo coal plant closure could lead to 1,000 job losses in Arizona, Utah
- Body found believed teen hiker; step-grandmom still missing
- The Latest: 49ers select Iowa QB Beathard late in 3rd round